I Still Think This is the Best Twist in Television History

by

A well-crafted plot twist can significantly impact a story’s outcome, sometimes for better, other times for worse. M. Night Shyamalan, known for his exceptional storytelling skills and filmmaking prowess, is often remembered for brief moments in his most renowned films. However, memorable twists, when executed effectively, remain part of a storyteller’s toolkit and spark endless discussions. With countless twists throughout TV history, cataloging them all would be an insurmountable task. Yet, one stands out as the undisputed champion among them all.

In 2016, Michael Schur’s sitcom “The Good Place” debuted with an intriguing high-concept comedy about the afterlife. The storyline was straightforward yet brilliant: Eleanor Shellstrop (played by Kristen Bell), a self-centered and ordinary woman from Arizona, unknowingly ends up in a heaven-like community meant for only the most virtuous individuals throughout human history. Upon meeting the architectural figure, Michael (portrayed by Ted Danson), Eleanor soon discovers her mistake and must conceal her past while learning to transform into a genuinely good person to avoid being exposed and sent to “The Bad Place.

In this setup, The Good Place show struck comedic brilliance right off the bat by matching Eleanor, a character, with her supposed soulmate, Chidi Anagonye, an indecisive ethics professor played by William Jackson Harper. What’s more, when it was revealed that Eleanor is actually a morally questionable person, she found herself among an irritatingly virtuous group of individuals, such as Tahani Al-Jamil, a philanthropic celebrity, and Jason, a mute monk. To complete the ensemble, there was Janet, an omniscient celestial being portrayed by D’arcy Carden, who struggled to behave in a human-like manner while overseeing The Good Place under Michael’s instructions.

In contrast to being just a witty sitcom, The Good Place soon demonstrated much more depth. Though it kept audiences laughing, the series also delved earnestly into the question of what truly constitutes being a good person. Eleanor’s covert ethics lessons with Chidi formed the backbone of the show, employing genuine philosophical concepts to illustrate her bumbling efforts at self-betterment. Consequently, The Good Place emerged as a narrative revolving around the profound human struggle to acknowledge past errors and commit to the challenging process of personal growth, not just for oneself but also for the people in one’s life.

This extraordinary collection of storyline components transformed “The Good Place” into a humorous, emotional, and remarkably profound series, one that appeared to follow a distinct and captivating arc as Eleanor underwent personal growth. And then, in the finale of its first season, the show masterfully pulled off a stunning twist, shattering its foundation and earning a legendary spot within television lore.

The Good Place Season 1 Twist Redefined Everything

In the grand finale of Season 1, entitled “Michael’s Gambit,” as a movie enthusiast immersed in this narrative, I found myself witnessing the four human inhabitants of The Good Place – Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani, and Jason – squarely confront their fate. After a rollercoaster ride of deceptions, antics, and philosophical turmoil, they stood before a celestial judge to plead their case. However, their constant bickering and inability to cooperate only added fuel to the fire. As they began to understand that they had been causing each other misery since their arrival, Eleanor was hit by a chilling revelation. She erupted into laughter and exclaimed, “This is the Bad Place!

In a surprising twist of events, amiable architect Michael unveils a shocking truth: he is not an ethereal being like an angel but rather a malevolent demon in disguise. Far from the idyllic heaven, this flawlessly designed neighborhood turns out to be a hidden torment chamber, specifically engineered to make these four souls suffer each other for an eternity of a thousand years.

This clever plot twist isn’t just for shock value; it gives every detail from the first season a darker, more ominous interpretation instead. For instance, the countless frozen yogurt shops were strategically placed to exploit Chidi’s indecisiveness, and Tahani’s seemingly smaller mansion compared to her neighbors was a continuous source of insecurity for her. Similarly, Eleanor felt inferior among the people around her, while Jason, a failed DJ from Florida, was compelled to maintain silence as a Buddhist monk. Each oddity or minor irritant was meticulously crafted to inflict psychological torment. This twist added depth to Season 1, encouraging fans to rewatch it and discover how the hints for the grand reveal were cleverly concealed in plain sight.

The Good Place‘sTwists Offered Constant Reinvention

The outstanding twist in The Good Place Season 1 that stands out from others lies in what the show did subsequently. The season finale has Michael snapping his fingers, erasing everyone’s memories to restart his experiment with a fresh start. This cliffhanger implied that Season 2 might just be a repetition of the characters gradually discovering the same secret all over again. However, the following episode in Season 2 turned this expectation on its head. The premiere of Season 2 quickly runs through many of Michael’s reboots in a comical montage, where Eleanor and other afterlife prisoners swiftly uncover the truth in each one. Instead of resting on their laurels, the showruners discarded the “do-over” idea within the first episode, forcing Michael to collaborate with the humans to conceal his failure from other demons. This drastically altered the series’ dynamics once again.

The unique trait that set “The Good Place” apart was its consistent narrative reimagining. Each season would upend the existing situation, propelling both the characters and the premise into uncharted realms, ranging from a second chance on Earth to navigating heavenly bureaucracy, to overhauling divine judgment systems. This approach allowed the show to fulfill its mission early on, signaling to viewers that it would be a series dedicated to continuous transformation rather than predictable repetition. In essence, the show’s structure echoed the experiences of its characters, a tireless, sometimes chaotic, yet ultimately inspiring saga of trial, error, and personal development.

The Good Place is available to stream on Netflix.

What do you consider the greatest twist in television history? Share your pick in the comments.

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/news/10-underrated-sitcoms-nobody-talks-about/embed/#

Read More

2025-07-06 03:40