The Marvel Cinematic Universe has consistently tried to balance making compelling films with staying true to the original comic books. But adapting comics to the big screen isn’t always easy, and some changes are necessary, particularly for modern audiences. Certain comic book villains just wouldn’t work in a movie, no matter how much fans want to see them. And while Marvel has tried to bring popular comic storylines to life, many haven’t been successful in the final film adaptation.
The Marvel Cinematic Universe has sometimes struggled to live up to expectations, whether with characters that didn’t quite hit the mark or stories that didn’t capture the magic of the original Marvel comics. Here’s a look at some instances where the MCU fell short of what fans were hoping for.
7) The Mandarin
Iron Man 3 took a risk that paid off creatively, but frustrated some viewers who weren’t expecting the story’s direction. The film was promoted as a showdown between Iron Man and his iconic enemy, the Mandarin, and featured a compelling performance by Ben Kingsley. While Kingsley’s casting as a traditionally Asian character initially sparked debate, it turned out to be a deliberate choice by the filmmakers.
A major surprise in *Iron Man 3* was the reveal that Trevor Slattery was an actor hired to pretend to be the villain, The Mandarin. This twist, orchestrated by the true antagonist Aldrich Killian, was cleverly done. However, many viewers who were hoping for a traditional Mandarin character disliked the movie because of it. While the Marvel Cinematic Universe later addressed this with Shang-Chi’s father being revealed as the *real* Mandarin, it didn’t satisfy those fans, and the character hasn’t been fully developed on screen.
6) Gorr the God Butcher
Christian Bale did a solid job playing Gorr the God Butcher, and the movie *Thor: Love and Thunder* followed the comic book storyline where Gorr turned to villainy after his daughter died – that emotional core of the film was particularly strong. The depiction of Eternity was also excellent. However, while the movie centered around Gorr, a character known for being a fearsome god-killer, it relied too heavily on humor, which didn’t quite fit the tone.
While Gorr’s story had potential, the movie struggled to balance its serious themes with over-the-top comedy, like silly scenes with screaming goats and Russell Crowe’s exaggerated portrayal of Zeus. Despite being enjoyable at times, the film didn’t give Gorr’s tragic arc the weight it deserved. *Thor: Love and Thunder* felt tonally inconsistent and ultimately failed to do justice to a compelling character from the comics.
5) Adam Warlock
At the end of *Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2*, a scene showed Ayesha (Elizabeth Debicki) standing near a large cocoon, declaring she would name whatever emerged ‘Adam.’ This immediately sparked excitement among Marvel comic book fans, who believed it hinted at the arrival of Adam Warlock – a character who finally appeared in the third *Guardians of the Galaxy* movie.
As a big fan of the *Guardians of the Galaxy* films, I was really looking forward to seeing Adam Warlock finally appear in *Vol. 3*. Unfortunately, the character didn’t quite live up to the hype. While Will Poulter is a talented actor, his portrayal felt more like an angsty teenager than the powerful being we’d been teased with in the previous movie. James Gunn definitely leaned into the comedic side of things with Warlock, and honestly, it didn’t quite work. A lot of fans, myself included, were pretty disappointed with how the character turned out.
4) The Silver Surfer
The Silver Surfer in *Fantastic Four: First Steps* was a compelling character, drawing inspiration from the Marvel Comics version. In the comics, Shalla-Bal was Norrin Radd’s love interest on their planet, Zenn-La, and Norrin sacrificed himself to save her and their world from Galactus. However, this movie presented an alternate universe where Shalla-Bal made the ultimate sacrifice instead of Norrin, which served the story better.
Fans have seen the Silver Surfer before, both in *Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer* – where Doug Jones gave a great performance, despite the film being disappointing overall – and in *Fantastic Four: First Steps*. While those versions had some good qualities, many fans believe the character hasn’t been fully realized on screen yet, and the Marvel Cinematic Universe still has an opportunity to get it right.
3) Red Hulk
As a huge Hulk fan, I was so excited to finally see Thunderbolt Ross transform into Red Hulk in *Captain America: Brand New World*! It was a moment we’d all been waiting for. But things got a little complicated. Sadly, William Hurt, who originally played Ross, passed away, so they had to find a new actor. I was a bit surprised they didn’t go with Sam Elliott, who played him in Ang Lee’s *Hulk* movie, but honestly, having Harrison Ford step into the role was pretty amazing!
Despite being a popular actor, Harrison Ford didn’t quite seem to grasp the nuances of his role. While he played President Thaddeus Ross well, his transformation into Red Hulk felt like an unplanned addition. Initially, the Red Hulk’s identity was a mystery in the comics, and the movie *Captain America: Brand New World* suffered from noticeable editing issues, appearing disjointed. The film showed Ross turning into Red Hulk publicly, immediately followed by a confrontation with Captain America. This wasn’t the debut fans had hoped for for the character in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.
2) Planet Hulk
Many fans consider *Thor: Ragnarok* to be one of the strongest films in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and it’s widely regarded as the best *Thor* movie. Interestingly, while the film drew heavily from Marvel comics, it didn’t adapt a classic *Thor* storyline. Instead, it took inspiration from the *Planet Hulk* story arc, placing Thor as the central character. This meant the *Planet Hulk* elements were somewhat sidelined, as the movie ultimately focused on Thor’s journey back to Asgard and his efforts to defeat Hela.
The movie took inspiration from the ‘Planet Hulk’ storyline, featuring characters like Korg and Miek, who also appear in ‘World War Hulk’. However, it didn’t go much further than that. While Jeff Goldblum was funny as the Grandmaster, his portrayal differed significantly from the comic book version. A full adaptation of ‘Planet Hulk’ wasn’t possible due to rights issues, and fans were disappointed to miss key elements like Hulk’s relationship with Caiera.
1) Secret Invasion
Many fans consider the *Secret Invasion* series on Disney+ to be the MCU’s biggest letdown so far. While the MCU successfully adapted the *Civil War* comic event – even improving upon it – *Secret Invasion* had the potential to be even better with the longer format of a miniseries. Unfortunately, it didn’t live up to expectations and disappointed many viewers.
As a big MCU fan, I was really excited for this series, but honestly, it let me down. While Samuel L. Jackson was fantastic as Nick Fury, a lot of the core characters from the comics were missing, and the show just didn’t deliver. Maria Hill’s death was a shock, and the Super Skrull wasn’t what I’d hoped for. It felt like one disappointment after another, and it’s easily the most letdown I’ve been by anything Marvel has released so far.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
Read More
- The Most Jaw-Dropping Pop Culture Moments of 2025 Revealed
- Ashes of Creation Rogue Guide for Beginners
- ARC Raiders – All NEW Quest Locations & How to Complete Them in Cold Snap
- Best Controller Settings for ARC Raiders
- Ashes of Creation Mage Guide for Beginners
- Where Winds Meet: How To Defeat Shadow Puppeteer (Boss Guide)
- Where Winds Meet: Best Weapon Combinations
- Berserk Writer Discuss New Manga Inspired by Brutal Series
- Bitcoin’s Wild Ride: Yen’s Surprise Twist 🌪️💰
- Netflix’s One Piece Season 2 Will Likely Follow the First Season’s Most Controversial Plot
2025-10-11 00:45