Simulating Quantum Security with Laser Light

Author: Denis Avetisyan

Researchers have built a cost-effective optical setup to mimic the behavior of a six-state quantum key distribution protocol, paving the way for accessible educational tools and security testing.

This work demonstrates a classical emulation of the six-state QKD protocol using pulsed lasers and polarization optics, validating its statistical properties and resilience against intercept-resend attacks.

While secure communication relies increasingly on quantum principles, practical implementation demands accessible and cost-effective validation methods. This work, ‘Emulation of the Six-State Quantum Key Distribution Protocol with Pulsed Lasers’, presents a classical optical emulation of the six-state protocol-an extension of BB84-demonstrating key statistical features with readily available components. Our approach successfully reproduces the expected behavior under potential eavesdropping attacks, validating its utility as both an educational tool and a platform for further research. Could such emulations bridge the gap between theoretical quantum cryptography and practical, scalable secure communication systems?

The Elegant Foundation of Quantum Security

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) represents a paradigm shift in cryptographic security, moving beyond the mathematical complexity that underpins current encryption methods to leverage the fundamental laws of physics. Unlike traditional public-key cryptography, which relies on the difficulty of factoring large numbers or solving discrete logarithms, QKD’s security is rooted in the principles of quantum mechanics – specifically, the act of observing a quantum system inevitably disturbs it. This means any attempt to intercept and read the key during transmission will introduce detectable errors, alerting the legitimate parties. The increasing threat posed by quantum computers-capable of breaking many widely used encryption algorithms-underscores the urgency of QKD’s development, offering a future-proof solution for safeguarding sensitive information in an increasingly interconnected world. While practical implementations face challenges, the theoretical guarantee of unbreakable security positions QKD as a vital component of next-generation communication networks and data protection strategies.

While Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) promises information-theoretic security based on the laws of physics, its practical implementations are susceptible to a range of attacks that exploit imperfections in hardware and the transmission channel. These aren’t breaches of the underlying quantum principles, but rather clever manipulations of the real-world components. For instance, single-photon detectors aren’t perfect; they have efficiencies below 100% and can register false positives, creating opportunities for eavesdroppers. Similarly, variations in fiber optic cables, or the use of imperfect lasers, introduce errors and disturbances that an attacker can leverage. Consequently, simply adhering to the QKD protocol isn’t enough; robust security demands meticulous calibration, continuous monitoring of system performance – specifically, the Error Rate and quantum bit error rate (QBER) – and the implementation of sophisticated countermeasures to detect and mitigate these practical vulnerabilities. The ongoing challenge lies in bridging the gap between theoretical security and the realities of building and deploying QKD systems in noisy, imperfect environments.

Quantum Key Distribution, while theoretically secure, faces practical threats from eavesdropping attacks like the Intercept-Resend scheme. This attack hinges on an adversary intercepting the quantum signals, measuring them to gain information, and then resending new, albeit disturbed, signals to the intended recipient. Detecting such intrusions necessitates constant monitoring of the quantum channel’s characteristics; specifically, a rising Error Rate – indicating signal corruption – and measurable Disturbance to the quantum states themselves serve as red flags. Sophisticated detection methods analyze these parameters, comparing them against expected values to identify anomalies indicative of an attack. The effectiveness of these countermeasures relies on meticulously calibrated systems and a deep understanding of how even subtle deviations from ideal quantum behavior can betray an eavesdropper’s presence, ensuring the confidentiality of the transmitted key.

The realization of truly secure Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) hinges not simply on the principles of quantum mechanics, but on their flawless execution and the mitigation of inevitable imperfections. Quantum mechanics dictates that any attempt to observe a quantum system inevitably disturbs it; however, real-world devices introduce additional disturbances stemming from detector inefficiencies and channel noise. These imperfections create vulnerabilities that attackers can exploit, necessitating a rigorous approach to system calibration and monitoring. Robust error correction protocols, capable of distinguishing between legitimate disturbances and malicious interventions, are therefore essential. These protocols must account for the probabilistic nature of quantum measurements and the finite key rates achievable in practical systems. Successfully implementing these safeguards-demanding precise control over single photons and sophisticated data analysis-is the crucial pathway towards realizing the promise of unbreakable quantum communication, safeguarding sensitive data against evolving threats and ensuring long-term security in a post-quantum world.

Core Principles Underpinning Quantum Advantage

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) systems achieving information-theoretic security necessitate the use of single photons as information carriers. Generating these single photons requires specialized Single-Photon Sources (SPS), which must reliably emit photons on demand with minimal multi-photon emission. Simultaneously, detection relies on Low-Noise Detection systems capable of registering individual photons while minimizing dark counts-false detections occurring in the absence of a signal. Typical detectors include Single-Photon Avalanche Diodes (SPADs) and Transition Edge Sensors (TESs), all operating at cryogenic temperatures to reduce thermal noise. The performance of both SPS and detection systems directly impact the key generation rate and the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) of the QKD system, ultimately determining the security and feasibility of the key exchange.

The BB84 protocol, and its enhancement the Six-State protocol, establish secure key exchange by encoding information onto quantum states polarized along different, non-orthogonal bases. BB84 utilizes two mutually unbiased bases – rectilinear (0° and 90°) and diagonal (45° and 135°) – while the Six-State protocol expands this to include additional bases. Each bit is randomly encoded using one of these bases, and transmitted. The receiver independently chooses a basis to measure each bit. Following transmission, a process called sifting is used to compare the bases used for transmission and measurement; bits are discarded when different bases were used, leaving a shared key. Security relies on the fact that any attempt to eavesdrop and measure the quantum states will inevitably disturb them, introducing errors detectable by the legitimate parties and alerting them to a potential breach. The Six-State protocol offers increased security and key generation rates compared to BB84 by increasing the number of possible states and bases.

Maintaining the fidelity of quantum states during transmission in Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) and its classical emulation necessitates precise optical alignment. Deviations in alignment, including angular misalignment and translational drift, introduce errors in the polarization or phase of transmitted photons, directly impacting the Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER). These errors arise because misaligned optical components alter the intended quantum state, leading to incorrect detections at the receiver. The sensitivity to alignment stems from the wave-like nature of photons; even small angular deflections can cause significant path length differences and decoherence. High-precision alignment systems, often incorporating piezoelectric actuators and feedback loops, are therefore crucial for both establishing and maintaining stable quantum communication channels. Furthermore, alignment tolerances are often comparable to the wavelength of the photons used, requiring sub-wavelength precision in component positioning and stabilization.

Sifting is a crucial post-processing step in Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols like BB84 and the Six-State protocol. It involves comparing a subset of bits between the communicating parties – Alice and Bob – to identify and discard instances where different measurement bases were used. Specifically, Alice and Bob publicly compare which bases they used for each bit, but not the bit values themselves. Only bits transmitted and measured using the same basis are retained. This process eliminates approximately 50% of the initially exchanged data in BB84, and a proportionally higher amount in protocols with more than two bases. The resulting sift key, comprised of only the matching basis bits, forms the raw data for subsequent error correction and privacy amplification stages, and its length directly impacts the final secure key rate.

Classical Emulation: A Bridge to Quantum Realities

Classical emulation of Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols utilizes standard optical components – including lasers, beam splitters, and detectors – to recreate the information processing steps of a QKD system without relying on quantum phenomena. This approach allows researchers and educators to comprehensively test and validate QKD protocol implementations and security analyses in a controlled laboratory setting. By simulating the protocol’s logic with classical optics, potential vulnerabilities and performance limitations can be identified and addressed before deployment in a true quantum system. This is achieved by carefully configuring polarization-maintaining fibers and components to mimic the behavior of quantum states and measurements, enabling detailed analysis of bit error rates, key generation rates, and resilience against eavesdropping attacks.

Classical emulation of Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocols utilizes polarization optics – specifically half-wave plates (HWPs) and quarter-wave plates (QWPs) – to replicate the manipulation of photon polarization states inherent in quantum communication. These waveplates alter the polarization of light by rotating the polarization ellipse, effectively simulating the quantum bit (qubit) states used in QKD. HWPs rotate the polarization by an angle determined by their orientation, while QWPs introduce circular polarization. By precisely controlling the orientation of these waveplates, the system can generate and analyze various polarization states, mimicking the behavior of single photons and allowing for the reconstruction of the QKD protocol’s logic using entirely classical components. This allows researchers to test, validate, and analyze QKD protocols without the need for complex and expensive single-photon sources and detectors.

Photonic simulations complement classical emulation by providing a computational environment to model QKD protocol behavior under varied conditions and attack strategies. These simulations allow for detailed analysis of signal propagation, detector characteristics, and the impact of noise, which can be difficult or impossible to fully control in a physical emulation setup. By comparing simulation results with those obtained from the physical emulation – and ultimately with theoretical predictions – researchers can validate the emulation’s accuracy and identify potential discrepancies. Furthermore, simulations facilitate the exploration of a wider range of attack scenarios and system parameters, enabling a more thorough assessment of protocol vulnerabilities and the effectiveness of countermeasures before implementation in a real-world quantum network.

This research presents a classical optical emulation of the six-state Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) protocol. In a secure, undisturbed configuration, the emulation achieved an undisturbed bit fraction of 31.3%, which closely aligns with the theoretical prediction of 33.3%. Furthermore, the emulation accurately reproduced the results of an intercept-resend attack, demonstrating a bit fraction of 10.4% – a value consistent with the predicted 11.1%. These findings confirm the emulation’s functionality as a dependable platform for both educational purposes and further research into QKD protocols and security vulnerabilities.

Expanding the Horizon: Free-Space Quantum Security

Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) traditionally relies on fiber optic cables, but free-space QKD dramatically expands the possibilities for secure communication by transmitting quantum signals through the atmosphere or even to and from satellites. This approach bypasses the limitations of terrestrial cabling, enabling secure links over vastly greater distances – potentially spanning continents. Unlike classical communication, QKD leverages the principles of quantum mechanics to guarantee secure key exchange; any attempt to intercept the quantum signals inevitably introduces detectable disturbances. Consequently, free-space QKD offers a compelling solution for establishing secure networks where laying fiber is impractical or impossible, opening doors to applications like secure satellite communication and long-distance terrestrial links for critical infrastructure protection.

The transmission of quantum signals through the atmosphere presents a unique challenge due to atmospheric turbulence, which causes distortions in the wavefront of light. These distortions, arising from variations in air density and temperature, can severely degrade the quantum state and introduce errors in key distribution. To counteract this, Free-Space Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) systems employ Adaptive Optics. This technology utilizes deformable mirrors and wavefront sensors to dynamically correct for the atmospheric distortions in real-time. By precisely shaping the transmitted beam to compensate for these aberrations, Adaptive Optics ensures that the quantum information arrives at its destination with minimal error, effectively preserving the integrity of the secure key and enabling long-distance, secure communication.

Adaptive Optics systems are crucial for maintaining the fidelity of quantum signals in free-space Quantum Key Distribution (QKD). Atmospheric turbulence introduces wavefront distortions that broaden and scatter photons, corrupting the delicate quantum states used for key exchange. These systems employ deformable mirrors and sophisticated algorithms to precisely counteract these distortions in real-time. By measuring the wavefront aberrations and adjusting the mirror’s shape, Adaptive Optics effectively “undoes” the blurring effects of the atmosphere, refocusing the quantum signal and ensuring accurate transmission over distances previously unattainable. This correction is not merely about improving signal strength; it’s about preserving the quantum properties – superposition and entanglement – essential for secure communication, allowing for the reliable distribution of encryption keys even through turbulent air.

The advent of fully realized free-space quantum key distribution (QKD) promises a fundamental shift in the landscape of secure communication, particularly for safeguarding critical infrastructure. Unlike conventional encryption methods vulnerable to increasingly powerful computational attacks, QKD leverages the laws of quantum physics to guarantee secure key exchange. This technology will allow for the creation of unhackable communication networks, protecting sensitive data for sectors like finance, government, and energy. Beyond the inherent security, free-space QKD extends the reach of this protection beyond the limitations of fiber optics, enabling secure links between cities, countries, and even satellites. The result is a resilient, global security infrastructure capable of defending against both present and future threats, ushering in an era of unparalleled data confidentiality and integrity.

The presented work mirrors a holistic approach to system design, much like understanding an interconnected ecosystem. The emulation of the six-state quantum key distribution protocol, though achieved through classical optics, validates the underlying principles of secure communication. This isn’t merely about replicating functionality; it’s about demonstrating the scalability of clear ideas-in this case, the core concepts of basis selection and intercept-resend attacks-without relying on complex quantum infrastructure. As Erwin Schrödinger observed, “Quantum mechanics is… a structure of rules which governs the change of what we perceive.” The research beautifully exemplifies this – a classical ‘structure’ successfully emulating a quantum one, highlighting that clarity of principle, not technological power, allows for a functional and instructive system.

Beyond Simulation

The successful emulation of the six-state protocol with readily available optical components reveals a fundamental truth: security isn’t solely about the exotic. While true quantum key distribution relies on the inviolable laws governing individual photons, this work demonstrates that mimicking the statistical consequences of those laws can provide a surprisingly effective, and accessible, testbed. This is not to diminish the importance of genuine quantum systems, but to highlight the possibility that some vulnerabilities – and indeed, some benefits – arise from the architecture of the protocol itself, rather than the physics underpinning it. The emulation, therefore, acts as a magnifying glass, revealing weaknesses in the design of security measures.

Future work should not focus solely on perfecting the emulation-increasing fidelity is a diminishing return. Instead, attention must shift to exploring how deviations from perfect quantum behavior – noise, imperfect detectors, even classical attacks subtly disguised – propagate through the system. The architecture dictates behavior; altering one element inevitably triggers a cascade of effects. A complete understanding demands not merely replicating the protocol, but systematically perturbing it, charting the resulting failures, and building a predictive model of resilience.

The temptation will be to chase ever more complex quantum states, but elegance suggests a different path. Simplicity, rigorously tested, is often more robust than complexity. The true challenge lies in understanding the fundamental limits imposed by information theory, not in overcoming the limitations of current technology. The emulation serves as a potent reminder: the map is not the territory, but it is a valuable tool for navigating it.

Original article: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2511.13413.pdf

Contact the author: https://www.linkedin.com/in/avetisyan/

The Elegant Foundation of Quantum Security

Core Principles Underpinning Quantum Advantage

Classical Emulation: A Bridge to Quantum Realities

Expanding the Horizon: Free-Space Quantum Security

Beyond Simulation

See also: