7 Superhero Movies That Stayed Totally True to the Comics

by

As a huge comic book and movie fan, it’s amazing to see how dominant superhero films are now, thanks to the MCU. But even way before that, comic book adaptations were always a big deal in Hollywood. Over the years, though, some movies just… miss the mark. Sometimes filmmakers seem to only grab the name or a basic idea and then completely change the story. You get these results where, like Tim Burton’s Batman, a director’s unique style really clicks with the source material and creates something truly iconic. But then other times, you end up with a movie like The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen – it was such a mess that it actually made the comic book writer regret ever letting anyone adapt his work! It’s a real gamble when a favorite comic goes to the big screen.

As a huge comic book fan, there are certain superhero movies that just get it. They aren’t always perfect, page-for-page adaptations, but they capture the feeling of the comics so well – the tone, the look, the key moments. When I watch them, it’s like the stories I’ve loved for years have jumped right off the page and onto the screen. It’s a complete translation, and honestly, it’s magical.

7) Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990)

While the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles have been reimagined many times, the 1990 movie best embodies the feel of the original comic books by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird. The film matches the comic’s slightly serious and darker atmosphere, and it also closely follows the story. Many scenes from the very first comic book issue appear almost identically in the movie, including the origins of both the Turtles and Splinter, as well as their rooftop battle with the Foot Clan and Shredder.

The original Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movie captured the edgy, darker tone of the early comic books so well that some parents objected. This led to later movies being made much more kid-friendly, resembling the animated series instead. Even so, no other adaptation has ever matched the first film’s faithfulness to those classic TMNT comics.

6) The Crow

Adapting James O’Barr’s The Crow for the big screen involved some changes to the story, similar to what happened with Ninja Turtles. However, the film successfully captures the dark and gritty atmosphere of the original comic, which greatly enhances the experience. Director Alex Proyas creates a detailed and immersive world where everything feels authentic, and every character’s death has a real emotional weight.

As a huge fan of The Crow, I’ve always been fascinated by its production story. It’s well known that the tragic death of Brandon Lee on set forced the filmmakers to drastically rework the editing and even the structure of the film. Because of that, a really cool scene from the original comic book – where Eric has visions of a talking skeleton cowboy – sadly had to be cut. It’s a shame, because I’ve read about it and it sounded amazing, but I understand the circumstances meant it just couldn’t make it into the final cut.

5) Punisher: War Zone

Adapting Marvel’s The Punisher for the screen should have been straightforward – action movies featuring gun-wielding vigilantes are common. However, it took three attempts to get it right. Lexi Alexander’s Punisher: War Zone finally captured the spirit and style of the Punisher MAX comic series by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon. The movie is known for its exaggerated villains, unique action sequences, and unusual story choices. While it might not appeal to all Marvel fans, it closely reflects the tone of the comics, which often feature incredibly over-the-top scenarios – like a fight taking place in a zoo’s polar bear exhibit. If the movie feels too extreme, the comics are likely even more so.

4) Dredd

Many comic book movies successfully capture the spirit of their source material from the start, but Judge Dredd suffered for decades with just one film that completely missed the mark. Fortunately, the 2012 movie Dredd finally delivered a faithful and incredibly entertaining adaptation that fans had been waiting for.

The movie Dredd, starring Karl Urban, differs from previous adaptations—Urban’s character never takes off his helmet. Throughout the entire film, you only see his stern expression through the visor, which is a key characteristic for fans of the character. Beyond that, the film’s visuals and story feel true to the source material, accurately portraying the dark, uncompromising, and futuristic world of Dredd.

3) Deadpool

While the movie doesn’t follow one specific comic book story, Deadpool truly captures the essence of the character and the world he inhabits. The clever writing pokes fun at superhero movies while still respecting the genre, but Ryan Reynolds’ performance is what really makes the film work. It’s challenging enough to play a serious superhero, but Reynolds successfully portrays a funny, yet emotionally damaged character in a way that’s both captivating and avoids being irritating.

2) Shazam

The recent Shazam! movie, while based on decades of comics featuring the character (originally known as Captain Marvel), primarily draws from DC’s 2011 “New 52” reboot. This reboot streamlined the character’s complex backstory, making it more understandable. Fans who’ve seen the movie and then read the comic book written by Geoff Johns and illustrated by Gary Frank will notice striking similarities, especially in the portrayal of a skeptical Billy Batson who eventually embraces his foster family. Key elements like the Rock of Eternity, the Christmas timeframe, and the other children in Billy’s adoptive family are all faithfully translated from the comic to the film.

The film is nearly perfect, with the only real drawback being the absence of Black Adam, Shazam’s main enemy. Dwayne Johnson was committed to playing Black Adam for years, which meant he couldn’t be in this movie. Ultimately, Shazam ‘won’ against him without any actual confrontation.

1) Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

What’s truly remarkable about Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (and its follow-up film) is how effectively it brings a complex comic book idea – the multiverse – to life on screen. The movie clearly explains the concept and, crucially, gives each version of Spider-Man a unique personality and story, drawing on decades of comic book exploration that films are only recently beginning to explore.

While not directly based on a specific Spider-Verse comic book story, the movie perfectly captures the exciting and energetic feeling of a large-scale crossover event – something live-action films have tried to achieve but haven’t quite pulled off. It stays true to the characters and stories from Marvel’s Spider-Man comics and the broader multiverse, and visually, it’s one of the most comic book-accurate movies ever made, incorporating different art styles, comic panel layouts, and even sound effects you’d find in comics.

https://comicbook.com/movies/list/all-7-most-powerful-avengers-endgame-heroes-ranked-by-how-hard-theyll-be-for-doctor-doom-to-defeat/embed/#

Read More

2025-12-06 22:14