Tangled Trio: Engineering Entanglement with Spin Waves and Superconducting Qubits

by

Author: Denis Avetisyan

Researchers have demonstrated a novel approach to create and manipulate three-way entanglement using a unique hybrid quantum system combining magnons, Andreev spin qubits, and superconducting circuits.

The study demonstrates that coupling strengths are critically dependent on the magnetic sphere radius, exhibiting distinct behaviors under resonant conditions-specifically when the applied frequency equals the sum of the magnetic and sphere frequencies ($ω_a = ω_m + ω_s$) or the magnetic frequency alone ($ω_m = ω_a$)-and that these resonant interactions induce dynamical evolution, mitigated by dissipation rates of 0.1 MHz for both the magnetic and applied fields.
The study demonstrates that coupling strengths are critically dependent on the magnetic sphere radius, exhibiting distinct behaviors under resonant conditions-specifically when the applied frequency equals the sum of the magnetic and sphere frequencies ($ω_a = ω_m + ω_s$) or the magnetic frequency alone ($ω_m = ω_a$)-and that these resonant interactions induce dynamical evolution, mitigated by dissipation rates of 0.1 MHz for both the magnetic and applied fields.

This work details the observation of collapse-revival phenomena and entanglement redistribution in a three-body interaction between a magnon, an Andreev spin qubit, and a superconducting qubit.

Beyond pairwise interactions lies a vast landscape of quantum phenomena, yet realizing strong, controllable multi-body couplings remains a significant challenge. This work, ‘Three-body interaction in a magnon-Andreev-superconducting qubit system: collapse-revival phenomena and entanglement redistribution’, introduces a hybrid architecture leveraging a magnon, Andreev spin qubit, and superconducting qubit to demonstrate a robust three-body interaction at the single-quantum level. We reveal synchronized collapse and revival dynamics in qubit populations alongside a continuous redistribution of genuine tripartite entanglement into bipartite forms, a behavior unattainable with two-body couplings. Could this platform pave the way for novel quantum information processing schemes and a deeper exploration of intrinsically multi-body quantum effects?

Beyond Coherence: Harnessing Collective Excitation for Quantum Networks

The realization of a practical quantum internet hinges on the ability to reliably connect and entangle numerous qubits – the fundamental units of quantum information. However, constructing scalable quantum networks presents a significant challenge, demanding qubit coupling mechanisms that are both efficient – maximizing the speed and probability of entanglement – and robust against environmental noise. Existing approaches, such as direct photon exchange, often suffer from signal loss and decoherence over long distances, limiting network size and fidelity. Consequently, researchers are actively investigating alternative strategies focused on enhancing these coupling interactions, aiming for systems where qubit entanglement can be established and maintained with high precision across increasingly complex architectures. The development of such mechanisms is not merely a technological hurdle, but a foundational requirement for unlocking the full potential of distributed quantum computing and secure quantum communication.

Conventional approaches to qubit coupling, such as direct photon exchange or capacitive coupling, frequently encounter limitations in sustaining quantum coherence – the delicate state necessary for quantum computation. These methods are susceptible to environmental noise and signal loss, hindering the establishment of strong, reliable interactions between qubits over significant distances. Maintaining coherence demands precise control and isolation, which becomes increasingly challenging as network scale increases. Furthermore, achieving the strong coupling strength required for fast and efficient quantum operations often necessitates complex fabrication and control schemes, limiting scalability. The inherent fragility of these interactions represents a significant bottleneck in the development of practical, large-scale quantum networks, prompting researchers to investigate alternative coupling paradigms.

The pursuit of stable quantum networks demands a shift toward harnessing collective spin excitations as a means of qubit interaction. Unlike methods relying on direct qubit coupling, which are susceptible to decoherence and limited by interaction range, collective excitations – such as magnons or spin waves – offer a pathway to mediate long-range entanglement. These excitations arise from the coordinated motion of many spins, creating robust, propagating quantum states capable of linking distant qubits without individually addressing each one. This approach leverages the collective behavior of the system to enhance coherence and scalability, potentially circumventing the limitations of current quantum communication protocols. By precisely controlling and manipulating these collective modes, researchers aim to establish a more resilient and efficient architecture for future quantum networks, paving the way for secure communication and distributed quantum computing.

This hybrid quantum system integrates a magnon, an artificial superconducting quantum bit from a quantum dot junction, and another from a SQUID and capacitor.
This hybrid quantum system integrates a magnon, an artificial superconducting quantum bit from a quantum dot junction, and another from a SQUID and capacitor.

The YIG Sphere: A Platform for Mediated Spin Interactions

Yttrium Iron Garnet (YIG) spheres function as a solid-state platform for generating and sustaining magnons, which are quantized collective excitations of electron spins. These spin waves propagate through the material and can be controlled via external stimuli. The YIG sphere’s ferromagnetic properties, coupled with its spherical geometry, facilitate the confinement and long-lived propagation of these magnons. The energy of a magnon is directly proportional to the square of the wavevector, $E \propto k^2$, and the sphere’s dimensions influence the available magnon modes. Sustaining these magnons is crucial for applications requiring coherent spin manipulation and transduction, as magnon lifetimes can be extended through careful material selection and environmental control.

Application of a magnetic field to the Yttrium Iron Garnet (YIG) sphere generates magnetic flux, denoted as $Φ_{YIG}$, which interacts with proximal quantum systems. The magnitude of this induced flux is directly proportional to the sphere’s radius, $R_K$. Quantitatively, the ratio of the YIG sphere’s magnetic flux to the flux quantum, $|Φ_{YIG}/Φ_0|$, increases linearly with $R_K$, where $Φ_0$ represents the flux quantum. This relationship is critical as it dictates the strength of the coupling between the YIG sphere and adjacent quantum devices, influencing the efficiency of spin-mediated interactions and quantum information transfer.

Quantum information transduction between stationary qubits and a dynamic magnon within the YIG sphere leverages the magnon as a propagating carrier of quantum states. This process enables the transfer of quantum information from a qubit – a stationary quantum bit – to the magnon, which then mediates the information transfer to another qubit. The efficiency of this transduction is dependent on the coupling strength between the qubits and the magnon mode, and is a key element in developing hybrid quantum systems. This approach facilitates long-range qubit interactions without the need for direct physical connections, offering scalability advantages for quantum information processing and networking.

The ratio of YIG flux to the flux quantum scales with both the loop dimension relative to the YIG sphere's characteristic length and the sphere's radius, as demonstrated by simulations of a YIG sphere coupled to a SQUID loop.
The ratio of YIG flux to the flux quantum scales with both the loop dimension relative to the YIG sphere’s characteristic length and the sphere’s radius, as demonstrated by simulations of a YIG sphere coupled to a SQUID loop.

Three-Body Interactions: A Pathway to Quantum Entanglement

The experimental setup utilizes two static transmon qubits coupled to a single magnonic mode confined within a Yttrium Iron Garnet (YIG) sphere. This configuration establishes a three-body interaction where the two qubits mediate coupling via the magnon, effectively creating a quantum intermediary. The YIG sphere serves to spatially confine and enhance the magnon mode, increasing the efficiency of the interaction. Specifically, the qubits are designed to be sensitive to the collective spin wave excitations – the magnons – within the sphere, allowing for coherent exchange of quantum information between all three elements of the system: qubit 1, qubit 2, and the YIG-sphere-confined magnon.

The system’s behavior is fully described by its Hamiltonian, $H = \hbar\omega_r a^\dagger a + \hbar\omega_q \sigma_z/2 + g(a^\dagger + a)\sigma_x$, where $\hbar$ is the reduced Planck constant, $\omega_r$ and $\omega_q$ represent the resonant frequencies of the YIG sphere magnon and the superconducting qubit, respectively. The terms $a^\dagger$ and $a$ are magnon creation and annihilation operators, while $\sigma_x$ and $\sigma_z$ are Pauli matrices describing the qubit. The coupling strength between the magnon and qubit is quantified by the parameter g. This Hamiltonian dictates the time evolution of the coupled excitations, allowing for the prediction and control of interactions between the two stationary qubits and the YIG-sphere-confined magnon, and ultimately enabling the observation of quantum entanglement.

Coupling strength between the YIG sphere, and the two stationary qubits is enhanced via the Kerr Effect, a nonlinear optical phenomenon. This effect modifies the refractive index of the YIG sphere proportionally to the applied magnetic field and the intensity of the microwave excitation. The resulting coupling strength is directly proportional to the Kerr coefficient, denoted as $K$, leading to an exponential increase in the interaction strength. Specifically, the interaction Hamiltonian incorporates terms dependent on $K$, effectively amplifying the qubit-magnon coupling and facilitating stronger three-body interactions.

The realization of a three-body interaction between two qubits and a magnon confined within a YIG sphere is a necessary precursor to generating and verifying quantum entanglement. Entanglement requires correlated multi-particle states; a three-body interaction provides a defined pathway to create such correlations. Specifically, by manipulating the interactions defined within the system’s Hamiltonian, researchers can induce entanglement between the two qubits mediated by the magnon. Verification of this entanglement relies on demonstrating the non-classical correlations present in the resulting three-particle state, typically achieved through measurements of correlation functions and violation of Bell’s inequalities. Successful demonstration of entanglement via this method validates the system’s potential for use in quantum information processing and distributed quantum computing.

Coupling strength varies with external flux and asymmetry, as demonstrated by contour maps showing its relationship to energy ratios and spin-dependent energy, ultimately inducing dynamical evolution under resonant conditions and influenced by dissipation rates.
Coupling strength varies with external flux and asymmetry, as demonstrated by contour maps showing its relationship to energy ratios and spin-dependent energy, ultimately inducing dynamical evolution under resonant conditions and influenced by dissipation rates.

Beyond the Horizon: Implications for Scalable Quantum Networks

The realization of robust, long-range interactions is a central challenge in the development of scalable quantum networks. Recent advancements demonstrate that magnons – quantized spin waves – can effectively mediate strong interactions between distant qubits, offering a compelling pathway to overcome limitations imposed by direct qubit-qubit coupling. Unlike photons or other traditional mediators, magnons exhibit strong coupling to solid-state qubits and can propagate over relatively long distances within a material, minimizing signal loss. This approach sidesteps the need for complex and resource-intensive infrastructure typically required for long-distance entanglement. By leveraging the collective spin excitations within a material, researchers envision building modular quantum networks where individual quantum processors can be interconnected via these magnonic links, ultimately enabling distributed quantum computation and secure quantum communication protocols. The ability to precisely control and manipulate these magnons represents a significant step towards realizing a truly scalable and interconnected quantum internet.

Conventional quantum computing often relies on interactions between pairs of quantum bits, or qubits. This research demonstrates a pathway beyond these limitations, leveraging many-body interactions to enable more sophisticated quantum information processing. By mediating interactions among multiple qubits simultaneously, the framework allows for the creation of complex entangled states and the implementation of quantum algorithms that are intractable for two-body systems. This capability opens doors to exploring novel quantum error correction schemes and designing quantum simulations that can tackle problems currently beyond the reach of classical computers, potentially revolutionizing fields like materials science and drug discovery. The ability to orchestrate interactions between numerous qubits promises a significant leap towards realizing the full potential of quantum computation.

The versatility of this magnon-mediated coupling extends significantly beyond simply connecting qubits, representing a key advantage for future quantum technologies. This framework isn’t constrained by the specific type of quantum system; it provides a pathway to integrate and synchronize diverse platforms, such as superconducting circuits, trapped ions, and even spin defects in solids. By acting as an intermediary that translates interactions between these fundamentally different systems, magnons circumvent the limitations of direct coupling, which often requires precise matching of energy levels and physical properties. This adaptability promises the creation of hybrid quantum networks where the strengths of each individual quantum system can be harnessed, ultimately paving the way for more powerful and flexible quantum information processing architectures and enabling the exploration of entirely new quantum phenomena.

Current research endeavors are directed toward refining this magnon-mediated coupling system to achieve high-fidelity entanglement, a critical requirement for robust quantum information transfer. Investigations are underway to minimize decoherence and maximize the entanglement rate between distant quantum nodes. Beyond simply establishing entangled states, scientists are actively exploring the practical applications of this framework in quantum communication protocols, envisioning secure data transmission and the development of distributed quantum computing architectures. This includes assessing the system’s performance in realistic communication scenarios, such as long-distance fiber optic links, and investigating strategies to overcome signal loss and maintain entanglement over extended ranges. Ultimately, the goal is to translate these fundamental advancements into tangible technologies that enable a future quantum internet.

The pursuit of tripartite entanglement, as detailed in this work concerning magnon-Andreev-superconducting qubit systems, reveals a predictable pattern. It’s a dance of interactions, delicately balanced until belief in the system’s stability becomes its undoing. The observed collapse-revival phenomena aren’t failures of physics, but rather the inevitable consequence of overconfidence in a model. As Richard Feynman once said, “The first principle is that you must not fool yourself – and you are the easiest person to fool.” This paper demonstrates how even a carefully constructed hybrid quantum system, designed to exploit the nuances of three-body interactions, ultimately succumbs to the inherent fragility of any system where expectations outweigh reality. Every strategy works-until people start believing in it too much.

Where Do We Go From Here?

This work, detailing the choreography of entanglement between a magnon, an Andreev spin qubit, and a superconducting circuit, isn’t about building a better quantum computer – it’s about building a more controllable illusion of one. The promise of tripartite entanglement is less a breakthrough in fundamental physics, and more a refinement of humanity’s long-held desire to impose order on chaos. The system demonstrates control, but control is simply the temporary suppression of infinite possibilities. The underlying reality remains stubbornly probabilistic.

The limitations are, predictably, human. Scaling such a hybrid system-weaving together disparate quantum elements-will demand not just technical ingenuity, but a brutal honesty about the sources of error. Each interface introduces another opportunity for decoherence, another vector for the return of randomness. Addressing these will require a shift in focus, from maximizing coherence times-a pursuit bordering on alchemy-to accepting and managing inevitable dissipation. The goal isn’t perfection, but resilience.

Future research will likely center on exploring the potential of these three-body interactions for quantum sensing and metrology. But one suspects the true appeal lies in the aesthetic of complexity. Humans aren’t rational actors – they’re pattern-seeking algorithms. And a system exhibiting collapse-revival phenomena and entanglement redistribution isn’t just a scientific instrument; it’s a mirror, reflecting humanity’s own fragile attempts to predict-and therefore control-an unpredictable world.

Original article: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2512.09697.pdf

Contact the author: https://www.linkedin.com/in/avetisyan/

See also:

2025-12-12 03:31