Here’s why US debt is out of control — and Japanese debt isn’t

As a researcher with a background in finance and economics, I’ve closely followed the debt situations of major economies like Japan and the United States. While it may be tempting to dismiss the U.S.’s debt-to-GDP ratio of 123% as manageable when compared to Japan’s 255%, a closer look reveals significant differences that make their economic situations vastly different.


At first glance, the U.S. debt-to-GDP ratio in 2023 didn’t appear overly concerning compared to international standards. Specifically, it was below the average for the G7 countries (123%) and significantly less than that of the most indebted nation, Japan, whose debt amounted to 255% of its GDP during the same year.

From a numerical perspective, it may seem unimportant that Japan continues to accumulate debt. However, its robust economy and thriving stock market, with the Nikkei 225 index up approximately 31% over the past year as of May 10, might lead one to overlook potential complications. Nonetheless, a closer examination reveals significant distinctions between Japan’s and the U.S.’s economic situations. Strategies that have served Japan well may not be applicable to the United States.

As an analyst, I would highlight the significant distinction between Japan and the United States in terms of debt ownership composition. Approximately 90% of Japan’s debt is held domestically by its citizens and institutions. In contrast, approximately a quarter of U.S. debt is owned by international buyers. Consequently, it becomes essential for the U.S. to ensure that its debt remains appealing to these foreign investors, offering competitive yields compared to other global issuers, particularly as the percentage of U.S. GDP represented by this debt continues to rise, increasing the perceived risk associated with lending to the government.

Last year, Fitch Ratings lowered the United States’ government debt rating from AAA to AA+, which some American officials dismissed as arbitrary and reliant on outdated information. Later in the year, Moody’s adjusted its U.S. debt outlook to negative, but this news also failed to elicit significant concern in financial markets.

Investors need to take notice as the U.S. cannot simply ignore its escalating debt levels, unlike Japan. A significant distinction between the two countries lies in their net debt relative to their gross debt-to-GDP ratios. Japan’s net debt is lower than its gross debt, which implies it possesses more foreign assets than liabilities owed to other nations. In contrast, the U.S. holds a larger amount of debt than its foreign assets. This difference makes it more challenging for the U.S. to manage its increasing debt burden.

Here’s why US debt is out of control — and Japanese debt isn’t

Japan has experienced significantly less inflation than the United States. Its inflation rate presently hovers at 2.7%, reaching a high of only 4.3% in January 2023. In contrast, the U.S. saw an alarming inflation rate of 9.1% in June 2022. The Federal Reserve continues to grapple with controlling inflation in the United States, making its mounting debt a potential concern as it could exacerbate the issue.

As a researcher exploring inflation solutions, I’ve come across the widely accepted approach of implementing restrictive monetary policies. However, this strategy comes with its own set of challenges. When interest rates rise, debt repayments become more burdensome for consumers. Unhappiness ensues, and over time, the economy may start to decelerate. The Federal Reserve is currently grappling with these very issues. Consumer confidence is wavering, last year’s debt repayments surpassed $1 trillion, and the first-quarter growth rate fell drastically below expectations.

To such an extent that there are growing concerns about stagflation – an unwelcome economic condition marked by persistently high inflation and sluggish economic expansion. In this scenario, mounting debt poses additional challenges as it constrains the government’s capacity to employ fiscal measures to bolster a flagging economy. As a result, the Federal Reserve faces a predicament: having already pledged a rate cut, it now finds itself in a difficult position.

During an election year, maintaining elevated interest rates for an extended period could lead to an displeased electorate. Yet, neither Democratic nor Republican candidates seem to acknowledge the looming U.S. debt crisis, which is growing increasingly substantial. No significant plans have been proposed by either party to tackle this issue. However, with the debt-to-GDP ratio currently surpassing 100% and expected to climb rapidly in the coming decades, the government will eventually need to confront this financial elephant in the room.

In simpler terms, what’s the impact on cryptocurrencies? Surprisingly, these events could benefit assets such as Bitcoin, acting as a safe haven amidst growing concerns over escalating U.S. debt. Historically, increasing debt levels often result in currency devaluation. While the U.S. may manage to mitigate some of this due to its status as the global reserve currency, the significant ownership of U.S. debt by foreign entities heightens the risk for the US dollar.

With the anticipated reduction in interest rates coming up this year, it’s unlikely that the dollar’s current robustness will persist for much longer. Consequently, this situation will benefit Bitcoin (BTC), frequently regarded as a protective asset during dollar instability.

The current situation the United States is facing isn’t necessarily detrimental to cryptocurrency markets. It depends on the extent of the chaos that ensues. If, hypothetically, the U.S. were to default on its debt – which is highly unlikely – this would be catastrophic for all markets, including digital assets. However, a weaker dollar and a loss of confidence in the U.S. could provide an ideal environment for the next surge in cryptocurrency prices.

Lucas Kiely is a guest columnist for CryptoMoon and the chief investment officer for Yield App, where he oversees investment portfolio allocations and leads the expansion of a diversified investment product range. He was previously the chief investment officer at Diginex Asset Management, and a senior trader and managing director at Credit Suisse in Hong Kong, where he managed QIS and Structured Derivatives trading. He was also the head of exotic derivatives at UBS in Australia.

The content in this article serves for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal or financial advice. The perspectives, insights, and opinions expressed are those of the author, and may not align with those held by CryptoMoon.

Read More

2024-05-15 03:11