Will Finally Has His Coming Out Moment in Stranger Things (And It’s Perfect)

by

A key strength of Stranger Things has always been its ability to tell complex, long-term stories. Even though the show isn’t perfect, it consistently connects earlier, seemingly minor details to later events, adding depth to the final season. This is especially true for the character of Will Byers (Noah Schnapp), who is central to the plot and essential for the story to progress. From the beginning, the creators, the Duffer Brothers, hinted at a specific development in Will’s story—his sexuality—which unfolded gradually over time (leading some fans to accuse the show of teasing without delivering). However, episode 7 of Season 5, “The Bridge,” finally allows Will to openly acknowledge and come to terms with this part of himself.

The big question after the scene was whether it truly succeeded. Some viewers loved it, while others found it lacking. However, a closer look reveals a more nuanced answer: While Will’s moment isn’t without its problems, it’s undeniably powerful and moving, and it finally allows a character long defined by silence to express themselves. This is likely why many call the scene “perfect,” but it’s worth exploring that idea further.

Why Will’s Coming Out Scene Works

Throughout the series, Will has always felt like an outsider within his friend group. While Mike, Lucas, and Dustin navigated typical teenage experiences like crushes and relationships, Will remained somewhat disconnected, a feeling compounded by his ongoing struggles with the Upside Down and Vecna. Over time, the show subtly revealed the reasons behind his distance, and by the fourth season, it became clear that Will was grappling with his sexuality.

Season 5 is when the show directly addresses Will’s identity as a gay character, moving beyond simply hinting at it as a result of his past experiences. By finally showing him come out, Stranger Things transforms years of subtle clues and unspoken feelings into a clear and meaningful storyline, which is a significant achievement for the show’s narrative.

What I really loved about this show is how they handled a really tough moment for the character. It wasn’t about making a big, heroic statement when he came out – it was raw and real, and that’s what made it so powerful. He fumbled for the right words, clearly terrified of how people would see him differently. It honestly felt so authentic, especially after they’d been hinting at this struggle for so long. It was a satisfying payoff because you’d really followed his journey and understood that he was battling this internally the whole time.

Many viewers were hoping Will would finally deal with his inner struggles and find his voice, and they connected with his feelings of insecurity and fear of judgment. This connection is what makes the scene so powerful. The scene doesn’t rush Will’s emotional journey; it builds slowly through quiet moments and repeated actions. When he finally speaks, the impact is unavoidable. The emotion comes not from what he says, but from understanding everything he overcame to reach that point – it’s a truly moving moment because we’ve witnessed his struggle.

Much of the scene’s emotional impact is due to Noah Schnapp’s performance. He delivers an incredibly authentic portrayal, playing the character with subtlety and avoiding over-the-top expressions. He conveys fear through nuance – in his expressions and pauses – rather than explicitly stating it. Schnapp truly understands Will and the weight of this moment, and that understanding shines through. Despite any weaknesses in the script, he makes the scene feel incredibly real and honest, as if drawn from personal experience. This grounded approach prevents the scene from becoming predictable or falling into tired tropes.

I recently read an interview with the Duffer Brothers about that incredibly moving scene with Will, and it gave me a whole new appreciation for it. They explained they deliberately saved it for the final volume of the season because they wanted it to really land emotionally and feel earned within Will’s journey. They were actually really worried about sending the script to Noah Schnapp, wanting to make sure it felt authentic to both Will’s character and Noah himself. Apparently, the moment Noah read it and got back to them, they felt a huge weight lift! He actually received the scene months before the rest of the script, and he told them he cried reading it – he didn’t even want to suggest any changes, because he thought it was perfect. He even connected with Will’s experience on a personal level, which is amazing to hear and explains why the scene feels so genuine.

However, it would be a mistake to overlook the issues with this scene. Its emotional impact is precisely why many people admire it and find it effective. Even so, that doesn’t change the fact that it could have been integrated into the story more smoothly, and it’s important to discuss that as well.

The Scene Is Great, But It Could Have Been Better Planned

Looking at it from a writing perspective, the way the scene unfolded makes a certain amount of sense. Many viewers have pointed out that Will reveals his feelings in front of a large group, including people he isn’t close to. While it might have been better for Will to have a private conversation with someone he trusts, the script faced a challenge. The group was in the middle of a critical, urgent plan to defeat Vecna, and pausing that to create a private moment would have felt unnatural. From that point of view, having everyone present served a purpose for the story.

That approach significantly diminishes the power of the scene, not because it’s unbelievable – many people do come out under pressure – but because the script doesn’t delve into the emotional weight of the moment. It rushes past potentially meaningful reactions, seemingly prioritizing Will’s storyline resolution over genuine emotional exploration. Considering the sensitivity of the topic, treating it as simply something to be checked off feels wrong. Perhaps the scene would have been more effective if it had happened later in the season, or if Will had started opening up to Joyce, with Mike joining the conversation naturally. That way, the emotional resonance with the audience could have remained strong.

He doesn’t share his truth because he wants to, or because he finally feels secure—he does it out of fear. He’s afraid Vecna will use the information against him, or that continuing to hide it will give the villain an advantage. This fits the season’s storyline, as Vecna thrives on secrets, past hurts, and feelings of guilt. Will needs to embrace his true self to break Vecna’s power. However, the meaning of him coming out is complicated. The decision isn’t about wanting to live authentically, but about needing to survive. It feels like a forced confession, driven by circumstance rather than his own choice.

The confusion around Will’s feelings is highlighted when he explains Vecna showed him a vision of people abandoning him if he revealed his true self. This is a key piece of information about why he’s so upset, but the show simply tells us about it instead of showing us. This is a missed chance for strong storytelling; Stranger Things is usually great at using visuals to portray emotional pain, and it doesn’t do that here. If we’d actually seen that vision, it would have made Will’s desperation feel more real and impactful before the group moves on with their plan.

Overall, the scene is understandable from all angles, but when tackling sensitive topics, careful planning is crucial. It feels like the writers knew the destination but rushed the journey. While it’s a strong and heartfelt scene, the delivery could have been smoother. However, it does succeed in what it’s trying to do, and calling it a failure would be unfair. It’s not the show’s strongest writing, and it’s definitely not perfect, but it’s incredibly moving – and that’s especially important for a character like Will.

What were your thoughts on Will’s coming-out scene? Did you enjoy it, or did it fall flat? Share your opinion in the comments below and discuss it with other fans in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/news/stranger-things-petition-demanding-answers-and-cut-footage-gains-over-300k-signatures-and-a-cast-member-responds/embed/#

Read More

2025-12-31 02:11