The Penguin Is the Best Comic Book TV Show of 2024 (Golden Issue Awards)

As a lifelong comic book enthusiast and TV junkie who’s spent countless hours immersed in both worlds, I can confidently say that 2024 was a golden year for comic book-inspired television. It was truly a challenge to narrow down the contenders for Best Comic Book TV Show at this year’s Golden Issue Awards, with an impressive lineup including The Penguin, Agatha All Along, Batman: Caped Crusader, The Boys, and X-Men ’97.

2024 could be labeled as a disappointing year for comic book movies, but it was quite the opposite for television shows inspired by comics. In fact, 2024 might become remembered as one of the standout years for comic book TV in recent history. From reviving animated characters to high-end HBO series, there was something for every comic fan – and that’s not even mentioning the highly anticipated Creature Commandos, which premiered after our nominee voting period had ended.

This year’s Golden Issue Awards, determined by our ComicBook team, saw a particularly challenging competition for the Best Comic Book TV Show. With outstanding contenders such as “The Penguin”, “X-Men ’97”, “Agatha All Along”, “Batman: Caped Crusader”, and “The Boys”, the winner could have easily been any one of them. However, there can only be a single victor in this category.

And the Golden Issue for Best Comic Book TV Show is…

The Penguin!

Given the challenging nature of the competition, one might not be taken aback by the outcome. The Penguin, which captivated viewers since its debut on HBO this autumn, held our interest week after week until its thrilling conclusion.

Among numerous excellent comic book series that aired in 2024, The Penguin stood out as the top choice for many of our viewers. It carried the aura of prestige associated with HBO, seamlessly integrating intricate character developments within intense storylines without overpromising and underdelivering. Each episode of The Penguin was skillfully crafted to make the most of its hour-long runtime, and it expertly balanced the amount of mature content that came with its HBO release.

One noteworthy aspect of the show “The Penguin” was undeniably the outstanding performances at its core. Colin Farrell, who was almost unrecognizable, elevated Oz Cobb’s character to a new level compared to his portrayal in “The Batman“. With an entire season devoted to the villain-to-be, Farrell had ample opportunity to let loose and he truly excelled.

Cristin Milioti’s portrayal of Sofia Falcone was equally, if not more, striking compared to Farrell’s performance. Her acting was captivatingly beautiful, haunting, and heart-wrenching from start to finish. It’s challenging to match the intensity of an actor like Farrell, scene after scene, but Milioti consistently held her own – often surpassing him in various scenes throughout the series. Both actors deserve Emmy nominations for their exceptional work.

The competition was stiff, but The Penguin outclassed the field of comic book television in 2024.

The full list of nominees for Best Comic Book TV Show:

  • Agatha All Along
  • Batman: Caped Crusader
  • The Boys
  • The Penguin  – WINNER 
  • X-Men 97

Read More

2024-12-24 17:10