Batman is undoubtedly one of the most iconic fictional characters of the last hundred years. Even people who don’t read comic books know the story: a rich and generous man who, after his parents were murdered when he was young, dedicates his life to becoming Batman, a crime-fighting vigilante protecting Gotham City. Since his first appearance in 1939, his story has been retold in countless books and adapted into nearly every type of media imaginable.
Many Batman stories have become classics, helping to shape the character and the world of comics. However, some tales are famous for more troubling reasons. Over nearly a century of Batman comics, a number of stories have sparked controversy, whether due to questionable artistic decisions, problematic portrayals, or simply disturbing themes. Here are five of the most controversial Batman stories ever published. This list focuses on lesser-known controversies, excluding well-documented cases like “A Death in the Family” and Batman: The Killing Joke.
5) Batman: Damned
Mature entertainment often includes violence, strong language, and nudity. However, even within mature-themed Batman stories, there are boundaries, especially when it comes to nudity. Batman: Damned, a three-issue series by Brian Azzarello and Lee Bermejo released between September 2018 and June 2019 under DC’s Black Label (aimed at adult readers), explores this. The story continues the narrative begun in Azzarello and Bermejo’s 2008 graphic novel Joker, and follows Batman as he seeks help from John Constantine to uncover the truth about what happened to the Joker, suspecting he may have killed him. It’s a compelling story idea.
The debate surrounding the comic Batman: Damned wasn’t about the story, but a specific image in the first issue. Several panels showed Batman nude while examining injuries in the Batcave. This nudity only appeared in the printed copies, not the digital version, but it quickly caused controversy. The initial print run sold out quickly, and later versions were released with the image altered. While it might seem like an overreaction, the incident had a real impact, leading to changes in how other mature-readers titles were reviewed to avoid similar problems.
4) “Joe Chill in Hell” (Batman #673)
The tragic murder of Bruce Wayne’s parents, Thomas and Martha, by Joe Chill when Bruce was young is the foundation of Batman’s entire story. This event drives Bruce to become the Batman and, in many versions of the tale, explains his refusal to use guns. Traditionally, Batman hasn’t been motivated by simple revenge, but that began to change with issue #673 of the Batman comic book.
The story “Joe Chill in Hell” features a dark and unusual scenario where Batman, after being shot and experiencing a near-fatal cardiac arrest, hallucinates and torments Joe Chill nightly for a month. This relentless psychological torment culminates in Batman giving Chill the gun used to murder his parents. Chill then realizes Batman’s identity and, it’s implied, takes his own life. Although presented as an alternate reality, the story was criticized by many fans for depicting Batman acting drastically out of character and resorting to such extreme measures.
3) Batman: Night Cries
The 1992 Batman story, Night Cries, isn’t necessarily controversial, but it’s deeply unsettling – and for some, those two feelings go hand-in-hand. Written by Archie Goodwin and illustrated by Scott Hampton, the story follows Batman and Commissioner Gordon as they investigate drug dealers and a series of murders. They soon discover a disturbing connection: all the victims were involved in cases of child sexual abuse, and the killer seems to be seeking revenge on their behalf. Batman must not only find the killer but also grapple with the realization that he can’t eliminate these crimes entirely. Meanwhile, Commissioner Gordon is forced to confront difficult aspects of his own past.
Night Cries is a sensitive and respectful portrayal of a difficult subject, honestly depicting the effects of abuse. While it doesn’t contain anything explicit, its realism makes it a challenging read and a departure from typical Batman stories, potentially surprising some fans. It’s not necessarily controversial, but it’s a story that will definitely make you think.
2) “The Wedding” (Batman #50)
Even people who only casually follow Batman know about the controversy surrounding issue #50. Released almost eight years ago, it remains a sensitive topic for many fans. This issue was intended to be a major moment for the character, written by Tom King as the halfway point of his planned 100-issue story arc. It was heavily promoted as the issue where Batman (Bruce Wayne) and Catwoman (Selina Kyle) would finally get married—something fans had been hoping for for years. The entire storyline had been building towards this eagerly anticipated wedding, often referred to as “Batrimony.”
Honestly, when the wedding was called off at the last second, it totally shocked me! It felt like a huge betrayal of everything we’d been building up to in that Batman storyline, and it really messed with their relationship – they haven’t been the same since, in my opinion. It caused a massive uproar among fans. Some people were intrigued, but most of us were just angry about what felt like a trick. It’s still a really painful topic for a lot of Batman fans, and a lot of us consider that issue a big letdown.
1) Holy Terror
No list of controversial Batman stories would be complete without something from Frank Miller. However, instead of All-Star Batman and Robin the Boy Wonder, this entry focuses on Holy Terror. Published in 2011, Holy Terror began as a Batman pitch to DC Comics, originally titled “Holy Terror, Batman!” The initial concept involved Batman protecting Gotham from an Al-Qaeda attack, and Miller himself described it as a story where Batman defeats Al-Qaeda.
The book wasn’t released as a Batman story. It eventually came out from Legendary Comics as Holy Terror, featuring a new character named The Fixer, clearly distinguishing it from a Batman tale. Despite this, The Fixer shares many similarities with Batman, and his city closely resembles Gotham. However, the controversy surrounding the book wasn’t due to these parallels. It stemmed from its offensive and Islamophobic portrayal of Muslims.
What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!
Read More
- Darkwood Trunk Location in Hytale
- Best Controller Settings for ARC Raiders
- Hytale: Upgrade All Workbenches to Max Level, Materials Guide
- Ashes of Creation Rogue Guide for Beginners
- Daredevil Is Entering a New Era With a Chilling New Villain (And We Have A First Look) (Exclusive)
- RHOBH’s Jennifer Tilly Reacts to Sutton Stracke “Snapping” at Her
- So Long, Anthem: EA’s Biggest Flop Says Goodbye
- 7 Announcements We’re Dying to See at Dragon Ball’s Genki Dama Festival This Month
- The Rip Ending Explained: Who’s The Traitor (And What Those Tattoos Are About) In Ben Affleck And Matt Damon Thriller
- We’ll Never Get Another Star Wars Show Like Andor, But Not Because of Dave Filoni
2026-01-18 02:45