In Taylor Sheridan’s Yellowstone, John Dutton (Kevin Costner) frequently points out that his children are all different. While Lee Dutton (Dave Annable) didn’t last long, Kayce Dutton (Luke Grimes) quickly became a viewer favorite, and it was revealed that Jamie Dutton (Wes Bentley) wasn’t a biological Dutton. For the first two seasons, Beth Dutton (Kelly Reilly) was a particularly divisive character. Though Kelly Reilly consistently delivered a strong performance as the vengeful daughter, Beth’s often cruel behavior – especially toward Jamie – felt excessive to many. This made some of her early scenes unpleasant for viewers.
Just like Kayce discovering how to be a good father and prioritizing his family, even the most flawed characters in Yellowstone have the potential for redemption. The show is full of criminals we surprisingly come to care about, and Beth Dutton’s transformation proves it – she went from being a truly unlikeable character to one of the best in just one episode.
Jamie and Beth’s Relationship Was the Worst Part of ‘Yellowstone’s Early Seasons
Yellowstone
Beth Dutton bursts onto the scene in Season 1 as a force of chaos. She’s a heavy drinker, uses relationships manipulatively, ruthlessly destroys businesses to get what she wants, and has a complicated relationship with her father. Watching her, you always expected trouble – and it was usually harsh. Her interactions with her brother Jamie only amplified that unpredictability and intensity.
Throughout the first season, Beth and Jamie had a recurring conflict. But in Season 2, their rivalry became a central focus of the story. While John Dutton struggled to save his ranch and Kayce worked to hold his family together, Beth and Jamie’s constant fighting felt repetitive and slowed down the season’s momentum. The scenes weren’t just lengthy, but Beth’s intense dislike for Jamie started to feel less about past events and more like simply being a cruel personality. However, a single episode dramatically changed everything, completely reshaping Beth’s character, her connection with Jamie, and what had been the weakest part of Season 2.
How ‘Yellowstone’ Saved Beth Dutton
Paramount Pictures
Viewers always suspected there was a complicated history behind Beth and Jamie’s ongoing feud, but no one anticipated how intense it would be. The show finally reveals the truth in Season 3, Episode 5, “Cowboys and Dreamers.” The episode opens with a young Beth turning to her brother Jamie for help after becoming pregnant with Rip’s baby. Knowing their conservative father wouldn’t approve, she asks Jamie to secretly arrange an abortion.
Initially, Jamie takes Beth to a clinic, seemingly for a routine procedure. However, it’s revealed the clinic performs hysterectomies, resulting in complete sterilization, not just abortions. Without telling Beth, Jamie consents to this procedure on her behalf. She only discovers the truth – that she can no longer have children and that Jamie made this life-altering decision for her – when she wakes up after the operation, realizing he’s taken away her chance to have a family.
The show has become increasingly intense, but a recent plot twist is perhaps the most shocking moment yet. After this reveal, Beth’s actions to harm Jamie feel less like satisfying revenge. This twist is especially poignant in later seasons as Beth dedicates herself to Rip, but struggles with the fact she can’t have children, leaving her feeling she’s failed him. This emotional storyline is expected to be a major focus in the upcoming spin-off, Dutton Ranch, which will follow Beth and Rip’s lives after the main series ends.
What Made ‘Yellowstone’s Plot Twist So Good?
Paramount Network
A surprising plot twist catches viewers off guard. A truly great one is hinted at throughout the story, building anticipation for the reveal. But the best plot twists change how you understand everything that came before. That’s what happened with the reveal in “Cowboys and Dreamers” for fans of Yellowstone. Initially, the conflict between Jamie and Beth seemed childish and pointless. But learning about their shared past makes their interactions much more meaningful and adds layers to their relationship.
Subscribe for deeper Yellowstone character insights
Get more perspective by subscribing to the newsletter for thoughtful deep dives into Yellowstone’s characters, plot twists, and storytelling craft — and similar in-depth TV and pop-culture analysis to broaden your view.
The show cleverly reworked frustrating rivalries from Season 2 into moments that hinted at future tragedy. Even more impressively, it turned Beth, who initially came across as unlikeable, into a deeply sympathetic and complex character. While the flashbacks confirm Beth has always been manipulative, they also offer crucial insight into why she behaves the way she does when we first meet her. She’s still flawed, but understanding the traumatic event that shaped her, and how it continues to affect her decades later, makes her earlier scenes far more compelling – less of a burden to watch, and more of a fascinating character exploration.
Found an error? Send it info@movieweb.com so it can be corrected.
Read More
- Best Controller Settings for ARC Raiders
- Ashes of Creation Rogue Guide for Beginners
- DCU Nightwing Contender Addresses Casting Rumors & Reveals His Other Dream DC Role [Exclusive]
- Stephen Colbert Jokes This Could Be Next Job After Late Show Canceled
- 7 Home Alone Moments That Still Make No Sense (And #2 Is a Plot Hole)
- 10 X-Men Batman Could Beat (Ranked By How Hard It’d Be)
- Is XRP ETF the New Stock Market Rockstar? Find Out Why Everyone’s Obsessed!
- 29 Years Ago, 1990s Gamers Experienced a Star Wars Moment New Fans Will Never Get
- Gigi Hadid, Bradley Cooper Share Their Confidence Tips in Rare Video
- ANIIMO Brings Adorable RPG Action to Xbox and PC As Second Beta Signups Go Live
2026-02-01 19:20