Mapping Geometry from the Edge: A New Boundary for Holographic Space

Author: Denis Avetisyan

Researchers have discovered a way to reconstruct geometric information in holographic duality directly from boundary data, potentially simplifying calculations of spacetime structure.

Modular Krylov complexity and operator algebra quantum error correction allow for the reconstruction of the area operator and entanglement islands without relying on bulk geometric calculations.

Reconstructing geometric information from purely quantum data remains a central challenge in holographic duality. This is addressed in ‘Modular Krylov Complexity as a Boundary Probe of Area Operator and Entanglement Islands’, where we demonstrate that the area operator-a key quantity characterizing emergent spacetime-can be extracted directly from boundary dynamics without reference to bulk geometry. By leveraging operator-algebra quantum error correction and analyzing the modular Hamiltonian’s spectrum via Krylov complexity, we establish a concrete boundary-based method for probing geometric features, including the diagnosis of island formation in evaporating black holes. Does this approach offer a novel pathway to accessing the internal structure of black holes solely through boundary quantum measurements?

The Holographic Universe: Spacetime as Emergent Property

Holographic duality posits a surprising relationship between spacetime dimensions, suggesting that the entirety of a volume of space can be thought of as encoded on its boundary, much like a hologram encodes a three-dimensional image on a two-dimensional surface. This isn’t merely an analogy; the principle proposes a fundamental equivalence between gravitational physics in a higher-dimensional space and a quantum mechanical theory residing on its lower-dimensional edge. Effectively, all the information needed to describe everything happening within a volume is contained on the area surrounding it – a concept that challenges conventional notions of locality and dimensionality. This radical idea stems from string theory and offers a potential pathway to resolving the long-standing conflict between general relativity and quantum mechanics, by suggesting gravity isn’t a fundamental force, but an emergent property of quantum information.

The notion that gravity arises from quantum entanglement represents a profound shift in theoretical physics, suggesting spacetime isn’t a fundamental entity but an emergent property. This perspective posits that the fabric of gravity is woven from the interconnectedness of quantum particles, specifically the correlations described by entanglement – where two or more particles become linked and share the same fate, no matter how far apart. Rather than being a force mediated by particles, gravity, according to this view, is a collective phenomenon stemming from the intricate web of these quantum connections. This challenges the classical understanding of spacetime as a smooth, continuous background and instead proposes it’s a complex structure built upon the more fundamental, and inherently quantum, relationships between particles; the strength of entanglement, therefore, could directly correlate to the curvature of spacetime, and potentially explain phenomena like $\text{black holes}$ as regions of maximal entanglement.

Reconstructing the geometry of a higher-dimensional spacetime, often termed the “bulk,” from information residing on its lower-dimensional boundary presents a significant hurdle in validating the holographic principle. This isn’t merely a matter of translating data; it requires deciphering how all geometric features – distances, curvatures, and even the complex interiors of objects like black holes – are encoded within the boundary’s quantum state. The challenge stems from the fact that the boundary description, while complete in principle, may not offer a straightforward or intuitive mapping to the familiar three-dimensional space. Specifically, understanding how concepts like interiority and causality emerge from boundary correlations remains a central problem, demanding novel mathematical tools and potentially a fundamental rethinking of how gravity and spacetime itself arise from more fundamental degrees of freedom. Successfully reconstructing even simplified bulk geometries from boundary data would provide compelling evidence for the holographic principle and its implications for quantum gravity.

Establishing a concrete link between entanglement on the boundary and the geometry of the bulk spacetime demands novel mathematical tools. Researchers are developing techniques to calculate how much entanglement between regions on the boundary is necessary – and sufficient – to ‘build’ specific geometric features in the higher dimension, such as the size of a black hole’s event horizon or the length of a wormhole. One promising approach involves utilizing $Rényi$ entropies – generalizations of the standard von Neumann entropy – to quantify entanglement and then relating these measures to quantities like the area of minimal surfaces in the bulk. This allows physicists to, in principle, reconstruct the entire higher-dimensional spacetime from purely quantum information residing on its boundary, offering a pathway to understanding gravity as an emergent phenomenon and potentially resolving the long-standing conflict between general relativity and quantum mechanics.

Mapping Entanglement to Geometry: The Ryu-Takayanagi Formula

The Ryu-Takayanagi formula establishes a direct correspondence between the entanglement entropy of a region on the boundary of an AdS/CFT spacetime and the area of a specific surface, termed the Quantum Extremal Surface, in the bulk. Specifically, the formula states that the entanglement entropy $S_A$ of a boundary region $A$ is proportional to the area $A(γ_A)$ of the minimal surface $γ_A$ that extends into the bulk, with endpoints on the boundary of region $A$ . This relationship is expressed as $S_A = \frac{A(γ_A)}{4G_N}$ , where $G_N$ is Newton’s gravitational constant. The “extremal” aspect refers to the requirement that the surface be a solution to the Einstein equations with boundary conditions dictated by the entanglement entropy; deviations from this extremal condition increase the area and thus the entropy, ensuring the calculated surface represents the minimum area configuration.

The Ryu-Takayanagi formula establishes a relationship between entanglement entropy and the area of an extremal surface. Consequently, a practical application of this formula requires a method to determine the area of these surfaces using information accessible from the boundary of the spacetime. This led to the definition of the Area Operator, $\hat{A}$ , which is an operator acting on the boundary conformal field theory that yields the area of the relevant extremal surface. The Area Operator is not directly measurable, but its expectation value in a specific boundary state provides an estimate of the extremal surface area, enabling the calculation of entanglement entropy from boundary data.

The Area Operator establishes a direct correspondence between quantities measurable on a boundary region – specifically, the entanglement entropy – and geometric properties within the bulk spacetime. Entanglement entropy, calculated from the boundary system, is not merely related to, but equal to, the area of a specific surface, the Quantum Extremal Surface, in the bulk. This equivalence allows researchers to infer information about the bulk geometry, such as the size and shape of black hole horizons or the connectivity of spacetime, solely from entanglement measurements performed on the boundary system. The operator therefore functions as a computational tool to translate boundary data into bulk geometric observables, bypassing the need for direct access to the interior spacetime.

Precise calculation of the Area Operator is fundamentally important for characterizing the geometry of spacetimes exhibiting complex features, particularly black holes. The operator’s value directly corresponds to the area of the Quantum Extremal Surface, allowing researchers to infer geometric properties – such as event horizon size and internal structure – from boundary measurements of entanglement entropy. In cases where direct geometric calculation is intractable, the Area Operator provides an indirect, yet quantifiable, method for reconstructing spacetime geometry. Furthermore, deviations in the calculated area from classical expectations can signal the presence of quantum gravitational effects and provide insights into the nature of spacetime at the Planck scale.

Probing Spacetime with Complexity and Modular Dynamics

Krylov complexity quantifies the rate at which operators spread under iterative application of a generating operator, effectively measuring the growth of operator entanglement. This framework defines complexity as the minimal number of elementary gates required to prepare a state within a subspace spanned by repeated applications of the generator to a reference state $|ψ_0⟩$ . The resulting Krylov subspace provides a measure of the operator’s ‘spreading’ and, crucially, is directly related to geometric properties of the underlying spacetime. Specifically, the scaling of Krylov complexity with time or subsystem size reveals information about the area of minimal surfaces and, more generally, the spectrum of the area operator, offering a pathway to probe spacetime geometry from boundary observables.

The Modular Hamiltonian, obtained from the reduced density matrix of a subsystem, provides a refined method for probing bulk geometric properties. Specifically, the reduced density matrix $\rho_A$ describes the quantum state of a region $A$ , and its associated Modular Hamiltonian $H_M$ governs the time evolution within that region. Analyzing $H_M$ allows for the reconstruction of geometric information about the bulk spacetime that is inaccessible through traditional methods focusing solely on boundary observables. This approach leverages the entanglement structure encoded within the reduced density matrix to infer properties of the underlying geometry, offering a complementary perspective to traditional geometric calculations.

Modular Krylov Complexity provides a methodology for determining the spectrum of the Area Operator using exclusively boundary data. This is achieved by analyzing the growth of complexity as a function of Krylov subspace dimension, which directly relates to the eigenvalues of the Area Operator $\hat{A}$ . Specifically, the rate of complexity growth corresponds to the spectral density of $\hat{A}$ , effectively reconstructing the operator’s properties from modular dynamics observed at the boundary of a system. This approach bypasses the need for direct access to the bulk geometry, offering a novel means of characterizing geometric properties via boundary measurements and modular Hamiltonian evolution.

The Lanczos algorithm is a computationally efficient method for determining the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of Hermitian operators, and is particularly well-suited for approximating the Modular Hamiltonian. Given a state $|ψ⟩$ and a Hermitian operator $H$ , the algorithm iteratively generates an orthonormal basis of vectors $|v_i⟩$ by applying $H$ and orthogonalizing against previous vectors. This process yields a tridiagonal matrix whose eigenvalues approximate those of $H$ . In the context of modular dynamics, this allows for the numerical computation of the Modular Hamiltonian from the reduced density matrix, bypassing the need for direct diagonalization of the typically large Hamiltonian matrix and significantly reducing computational cost, especially for systems with many degrees of freedom.

Reconstructing Black Holes: Quantum Error Correction and the Emergent Interior

Operator Algebra Quantum Error Correction, or OAQEC, establishes a precise mathematical framework for Entanglement Wedge Reconstruction – a concept linking regions of spacetime to the entanglement of quantum states. This approach moves beyond intuitive descriptions by formulating reconstruction as a problem of decoding quantum information, akin to error correction in quantum computing. By treating the entanglement wedge as a quantum code, OAQEC provides tools to systematically connect data residing on the boundary of spacetime to the geometric structure within its interior. This rigorous algebraic formulation not only clarifies the theoretical underpinnings of holographic duality, but also allows researchers to explore how spacetime itself emerges from the complex interplay of quantum entanglement, potentially resolving longstanding puzzles regarding black hole interiors and information loss.

Operator Algebra Quantum Error Correction, or OAQEC, establishes a formalized and systematic link between information residing on the boundary of spacetime and the geometry within its interior – the ‘bulk’. This connection isn’t merely conceptual; OAQEC provides concrete mathematical tools to translate data observed at a distance into a detailed understanding of the spacetime structure itself. By rigorously defining how boundary data encodes bulk geometry, researchers can effectively ‘probe’ the normally inaccessible regions of spacetime, including the interiors of black holes, with unprecedented precision. This capability represents a significant step forward in gravitational physics, allowing for the investigation of spacetime dynamics and potentially resolving longstanding theoretical challenges related to quantum gravity and information loss.

Recent theoretical work utilizing Operator Algebra Quantum Error Correction-a framework connecting boundary data to bulk geometry-is beginning to illuminate the previously inaccessible dynamics within black holes. This approach doesn’t rely on traditional methods requiring detailed knowledge of the black hole’s interior, but instead leverages the entanglement structure at the event horizon to infer internal processes. By carefully analyzing how information is encoded and retrieved from the boundary, researchers are developing a powerful toolkit to map out the evolution of spacetime itself within these extreme environments. The resulting insights offer the potential to test fundamental predictions about quantum gravity and provide crucial clues regarding the resolution of the black hole information paradox, suggesting that the interior isn’t simply ‘lost’ but rather intricately encoded in the quantum correlations at the boundary.

Recent theoretical advancements suggest a profound connection between quantum entanglement and the very fabric of spacetime, offering a potential resolution to long-standing paradoxes in black hole physics. These developments, particularly leveraging Operator Algebra Quantum Error Correction, demonstrate the possibility of reconstructing geometric quantities – specifically the area operator – directly from boundary data. Crucially, this reconstruction bypasses the need for complex calculations within the black hole’s interior or the computationally intensive process of solving bulk extremization problems. This ability to deduce spacetime geometry from entanglement patterns represents a significant step towards understanding how spacetime itself emerges from underlying quantum principles, potentially offering a pathway to reconcile quantum mechanics and general relativity and illuminate the nature of black hole interiors.

The study reveals a compelling shift in how geometric properties are understood within holographic duality. Rather than relying on calculations originating from a presumed bulk geometry, the area operator-a key component in reconstructing spacetime-emerges directly from boundary data via operator algebra quantum error correction. This approach mirrors the principles of self-organization, where complex structures arise from local interactions, suggesting control isn’t inherent but rather influence is exerted through these connections. As Carl Sagan observed, “Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known.” This research embodies that sentiment, demonstrating how fundamental aspects of geometry can be unveiled not through top-down imposition, but through understanding the inherent relationships within a system-a testament to the power of emergent behavior and the beauty of interconnectedness.

What Lies Ahead?

The demonstration that the area operator yields to reconstruction from boundary data, circumventing explicit bulk geometry, is less a solution and more a refined framing of the problem. It suggests the universe doesn’t so much need a geometric interior as it allows one to emerge. The true constraint, it appears, isn’t the existence of spacetime, but the consistency of the boundary quantum mechanics. Future work will inevitably probe the limits of this reconstruction – identifying precisely where, and how, attempts to define an area operator from solely boundary data will fail, revealing deeper constraints on holographic entanglement.

The technique’s reliance on operator algebra quantum error correction, while powerful, introduces its own set of questions. The choice of code, and its inherent redundancy, seems arbitrary, a scaffolding erected to support the emergent geometry. It invites investigation into whether different error correction schemes lead to subtly-or radically-different geometric interpretations, suggesting a landscape of possible spacetimes lurking within the quantum information. Every constraint stimulates inventiveness, and the imposed limitations of the chosen code may yet unlock unexpected connections.

Ultimately, the field shifts from seeking the geometry to understanding the rules governing any possible geometry. The search for a fundamental theory of quantum gravity may not yield a single, pre-ordained spacetime, but a framework for generating them. Self-organization is stronger than forced design; the universe, it seems, prefers to build itself, given sufficient information and the right constraints.

Original article: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2602.02675.pdf

Contact the author: https://www.linkedin.com/in/avetisyan/

The Holographic Universe: Spacetime as Emergent Property

Mapping Entanglement to Geometry: The Ryu-Takayanagi Formula

Probing Spacetime with Complexity and Modular Dynamics

Reconstructing Black Holes: Quantum Error Correction and the Emergent Interior

What Lies Ahead?

See also: