The Death of Sony’s Spider-Man Universe Explained: How It Went From Box Office Records to a Reboot in 8 Years

by

Sony Pictures is completely restarting its Spider-Man spin-off movies, effectively ending a challenging eight-year effort. For almost a decade, Sony tried to create a movie universe centered around Spider-Man’s supporting characters, but audiences weren’t very interested in stories that didn’t feature Spider-Man himself. This decision to begin anew with a “fresh narrative perspective” comes after several unsuccessful attempts to build a lasting franchise around the villains, despite Spider-Man’s huge popularity.

For the past eight years, Sony had a complicated plan to profit from Spider-Man in multiple ways. They teamed up with Marvel Studios to include Spider-Man (Tom Holland) in the larger Marvel Cinematic Universe, but also tried to create their own separate Spider-Man-related movies. While the first few, like Venom, did well, later films and spin-offs weren’t successful, ultimately leading Sony to abandon their plans for a separate Spider-Man Universe.

Sony’s Spider-Man Universe Promising Debut with Venom

When Sony launched their Spider-Man Universe with Venom back in 2018, I admit, I was intrigued. Despite not being a critical darling, the film was a huge financial success – over $850 million worldwide! That convinced Sony they could build a whole universe without Spider-Man himself, and potentially make even more money than sticking to a single hero’s story. But, and this is a big but, they seemed to double down on style over substance. They went for a campy vibe that, frankly, didn’t quite land. We saw diminishing returns with Venom: Let There Be Carnage, and the latest installment, Venom: The Last Dance, released late last year, stalled out around $477 million globally. It’s clear the formula just isn’t working as well as they’d hoped.

The Venom movies, despite their popularity, revealed a key problem with Sony’s approach to building a connected universe: they frequently hinted at larger storylines without ever fully developing them. A prime example is when Eddie Brock briefly appeared in the Marvel Cinematic Universe in Spider-Man: No Way Home, only to be immediately sent back without actually interacting with any of the main heroes. Many saw this as a disappointing marketing ploy with no real purpose. Similarly, the final film introduced Knull, a powerful villain voiced by Andy Serkis, as a major threat, but he ended up being mostly a visual effect with no clear role in future movies. This habit of teasing big stories but not delivering on them ultimately frustrated fans, demonstrating that even a well-liked character like Venom couldn’t save a series lacking a clear direction.

The Multiple Bombs of Sony’s Spider-Man Universe

Sony’s Spider-Man Universe (SSU) faltered because its films consistently strayed from the source material and failed to connect with audiences. The 2022 film Morbius became a prime example of this, earning only $167 million worldwide despite costing $80 million to make. Its attempt to update the character of Michael Morbius (Jared Leto) was hampered by a weak story and a confusing post-credits scene featuring the Vulture (Michael Keaton) being transported to Sony’s universe, a move that contradicted established rules about the multiverse and felt forced. Things got even worse in early 2024 with Madame Web, which was widely criticized for its awkward dialogue and for not showing Dakota Johnson as the iconic Cassandra Webb in her comic book costume until the very end of the film.

The release of Kraven the Hunter effectively ended Sony’s attempts to build a Spider-Man universe without Spider-Man. After numerous delays, the film flopped, earning only $62 million worldwide. A key misstep was reimagining the villain Sergei Kravinoff (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) as an environmentalist, which turned off dedicated comic book fans. These repeated failures highlighted the flawed strategy of hinting at future crossovers the studio couldn’t deliver. This lack of creative direction led to the cancellation of several other planned projects, including films starring Bad Bunny as El Muerto, a team-up featuring Silver Sable and Black Cat (Silver & Black), and a solo movie about Hypno-Hustler with Donald Glover.

What the Future Holds for Sony’s Spider-Man Franchise

Sony’s attempts at standalone villain movies have stalled, but the Spider-Verse franchise continues to be a huge success, demonstrating the incredible potential of focusing on heroes like Miles Morales (voiced by Shameik Moore). Now, Sony is building on this success with a new television strategy, starting with a live-action Spider-Noir series starring Nicolas Cage as a hard-boiled version of the character from the 1930s. This shift signals a move towards unique, hero-focused stories, a departure from the villain-heavy films of the past. The planned spin-offs featuring Spider-Gwen (voiced by Hailee Steinfeld) and Spider-Punk (voiced by Daniel Kaluuya) show that Sony understands Spider-Man – and all his different versions – is what audiences connect with, not just the villains.

The success of recent Spider-Man movies highlights how important it is for Sony and Marvel Studios to continue working together. Their partnership has led to the biggest financial gains for the character, far exceeding the performance of standalone villain-focused films. It started with Spider-Man: Homecoming, which earned $880 million, then Spider-Man: Far From Home with $1.13 billion, and reached a peak with the massive success of Spider-Man: No Way Home at $1.9 billion. Although their original deal had limitations and briefly fell apart in 2019, Sony and Marvel have renewed their collaboration to create a new trilogy of Spider-Man films, beginning with Spider-Man: Brand New Day.

Recent reports indicate Sony is more willing to let Marvel use more of its characters in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, likely to help guarantee success as the storyline restarts. This suggests Sony recognizes the value of a stable creative partnership with Marvel Studios for its Spider-Man properties. If Sony wants to create more live-action Spider-Man projects, continuing to do so within the MCU seems like a logical step.

The live-action Spider-Noir series will debut on MGM+ on May 25th, and Spider-Man: Brand New Day will hit theaters on July 31st.

Can Sony build a successful Spider-Man Universe even without Spider-Man himself? Or would it be better for them to team up fully with the Marvel Cinematic Universe? Share your thoughts in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/movies/list/7-alternate-universe-spider-man-who-deserve-their-own-spider-verse-spinoff/embed/#

Read More

2026-02-25 21:13