Silent Hill: Townfall Has One Simple Choice to Make

by

If key elements aren’t adjusted, Silent Hill: Townfall risks feeling like just another horror game, diminishing its potential as a unique addition to the series. While comparisons to Silent Hill 2 are inevitable, Townfall already shares some similarities, making it hard to stand on its own. The story currently seems promising, but a single change could elevate it from interesting to truly unforgettable by differentiating it from previous games’ narratives.

The story of Silent Hill: Townfall was first suggested in the game’s trailer. The main character, Simon Ordell, appears to be drawn to the town of St. Amelia – and potentially into danger – by a strange voice coming from a small, portable TV. Unlike previous Silent Hill games, Townfall uses a first-person perspective, similar to games like Resident Evil 7: Biohazard and Resident Evil Village, to offer a fresh and distinctive experience.

Silent Hill: Townfall Should Only Have One Clear Ending To Its Psychological Story

Previous Silent Hill games were known for their storytelling, especially Silent Hill 2, which featured multiple endings determined by player choices. These endings were often open to interpretation, with some including hidden jokes to lighten the game’s dark atmosphere. However, Silent Hill: Townfall might take a different approach by having only one ending, creating a definitive and memorable conclusion for players.

The way Townfall avoids open-ended conclusions, unlike some Silent Hill games, strengthens its own unique message. Simon’s goal of fixing things could lead to either success or failure, and a clear ending—no matter the outcome—might be more compelling than letting players achieve both. The game’s design and how you play could reinforce this idea, creating an experience where you learn to accept the past, no matter what you do.

Silent Hill 2 Is Famous For Multiple Endings Players Unlock Through Their Actions

The remake of Silent Hill 2 now features eight different endings, determined by the choices players make throughout the game. These endings feel personal, reflecting how you understand the story and are unlocked by how you interact with characters and events. While the main character’s inner turmoil is central to the game’s climax, it’s ultimately up to the player to decide how things conclude and how they confront the truth about their past.

The different endings in Silent Hill 2 encourage players to replay the game, almost like unlocking achievements or finding hidden secrets. The “Dog” and “UFO” endings, and some new ones added to the remake, require starting a new game after finishing once. Many players feel these endings deepen your understanding of Silent Hill 2’s story, offering new perspectives on details you might not have grasped during your first playthrough.

Other Actions To Separate The Two Games Could Help Townfall Stand On Its Own

While a unique ending would set Silent Hill: Townfall apart from Silent Hill 2, there are other ways to make the game just as engaging. To match Silent Hill 2‘s replayability, Konami could add more story variations. For instance, the player character, Simon, could explore St. Amelia without meeting any other people, finding clues only through recordings and encountering monsters. Unraveling the game’s mystery could then rely solely on solving puzzles and discovering fragments of the past.

One idea for Townfall is to use a gameplay loop similar to roguelikes, where Simon restarts at the water near St. Amelia whenever he’s defeated. Like Returnal, the game could feature consistent progress alongside a haunting atmosphere, with the town changing slightly as the story unfolds. While Silent Hill: Townfall would likely build on the familiar elements of Silent Hill 2, it needs unique gameplay mechanics to become a memorable experience on its own.

As a huge Silent Hill fan, I’m really curious to hear what everyone thinks Silent Hill: Townfall needs to do to stand out from the other games in the series. What would you like to see that’s different? Let me know in the comments, or head over to the ComicBook Forum to discuss!

Read More

2026-02-26 22:12