Bone Claw Wolverine Was One of His Best Eras (but Marvel Shouldn’t Go Back to It)

by

Wolverine is one of Marvel’s most complex characters, and his introduction was carefully paced, with mysteries unfolding over many years. He’s evolved significantly, which has resonated with fans. Like all heroes, he’s faced losses, including temporary power reductions. Throughout the 70s and 80s, stories often involved Logan losing his healing ability due to technology or other mutants. However, the biggest change came in 1993 with X-Men (Vol. 2) #25, when he lost his adamantium skeleton and claws. This lasted for six years, giving fans a unique take on the character during the 90s.

For years, Wolverine’s use of bone claws instead of his usual adamantium ones made him more vulnerable, leading to some compelling stories by writers like Larry Hama, Chris Claremont, and Warren Ellis. Fans enjoyed seeing how this change affected his fighting style and worldview, and many have fond memories of that period. Now, Marvel is bringing bone claws back in Wolverine (Vol. 8) #21 and #22, but many believe this is a mistake motivated by commercial interests rather than good storytelling. While the bone claw era was well-received, returning to it now feels like a misstep.

Bone Claw Wolverine Was a Great Idea but Repeating It Right Now Will Be a Disaster

In 1993, the decision to remove Wolverine’s adamantium skeleton was a big surprise for fans. The X-Men had been relaunched just two years prior, and the animated series was incredibly popular, making Logan a standout character. While risky, taking away his unbreakable bones and claws ultimately resonated with readers. Marvel had been hinting at Wolverine’s history with the Weapon X program, teasing details but not fully revealing everything fans craved. Removing the adamantium finally opened the door to exploring that backstory.

Rather than Marvel editors preventing Larry Hama from exploring Wolverine’s past too thoroughly, the storyline focusing on his bone claws shifted readers’ attention. Fans were captivated by wondering how and when he’d regain his metal claws – many predicted it would happen in issue #100 – and enjoyed the fresh take on Wolverine’s adventures. It was a really exciting period, and even the attempts to divert attention from the adamantium storyline, by having Logan regress to a more feral state, were often compelling. We saw a new, more vulnerable side of Logan, and it proved surprisingly effective.

While Wolverine’s past struggles with losing his claws and healing factor were effective, revisiting that storyline now feels repetitive. He could benefit from a fresh direction, but not one he’s already experienced. A strong writer is needed—someone who hasn’t recently faltered with another title. Comics often revisit old ideas, and sometimes that works well—like when Wolverine temporarily lost his healing factor, adding a new layer of vulnerability after years of being invincible, especially following the loss of his adamantium skeleton. This current approach, however, doesn’t feel like a compelling new take.

The recent Wolverine run (Volume 8) has been heavily criticized, and for good reason. Like many current X-Men comics, it relies too much on familiar ideas from the past. Writer Saladin Ahmed seems to be trying to imitate the style of Ann Nocenti (who previously wrote Wolverine), but doesn’t quite succeed. While it’s not surprising to see the story revisit Wolverine’s original bone claws – especially with the introduction of a magical metal that can control adamantium and potentially remove it – the approach feels tired and unoriginal. It’s simply a retread of old concepts, and the motivation behind it feels purely commercial.

MCU Synergy Is Going to Ruin Wolverine

The first season of X-Men ’97 ended with a dramatic scene: Magneto ripping the adamantium from Wolverine, who was notably wearing his original brown and orange costume – a different look than his more famous blue and yellow comic book attire. While Marvel recently updated Wolverine’s costume in 2024, the series is bringing back the classic brown and orange, and hinting at the return of his bone claws. This feels like an attempt to connect the X-Men to the broader Marvel Cinematic Universe, but it risks damaging Wolverine’s established story.

The current Wolverine series (Volume 8) is a significant misstep for the character, and arguably one of the weakest iterations in its history. The main issue is the poor writing, and the focus on bone claws only exacerbates the problem. While the bone claw era worked well previously due to strong writing, that quality is currently lacking. Wolverine desperately needs a creative boost, and this series isn’t it. While comics naturally go through ups and downs, this feels like a cynical attempt to capitalize on MCU popularity by rehashing old ideas, which ultimately alienates long-time fans. Hopefully, this is just a temporary direction, because things could get much worse for the character.

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/wolverine-10-most-brutal-fights-sabretooth-hulk-cyber-magneto/embed/#

Read More

2026-03-23 17:12