Brooks Nader’s Dating History: Taron Egerton, Carlos Alcaraz, More

by

Brooks Nader readily acknowledges she hasn’t had much practice with love, or with being loving towards others, for that matter.

She told People magazine in September 2025 that she met her ex-husband, Billy Haire, when she was 18, and they were together for nine years. Because he was her first boyfriend, she had no prior dating experience and wasn’t familiar with manipulative relationship tactics like ‘love-bombing,’ or even basic relationship dynamics.

When she started filming her reality show, Love Thy Nader, with her sisters Sarah Jane, Grace Ann, and Mary Holland Nader, she realized she acted very immaturely in her relationships.

She and her Dancing With the Stars partner, Gleb Savchenko, quickly became romantically involved. The Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model told Andy Cohen on Watch What Happens Live in December 2025 that their connection began “the day I met him.” She jokingly requested to be paired with the show’s “hottest” partner, and she felt an immediate, intense attraction to Gleb, predicting it would only grow stronger.

Despite finishing ninth in the show’s thirty-third season, she rated their intimate life a perfect ten.

She said with a laugh, “Definitely don’t marry him, but feel free to have some fun.” It’s ironic, considering their relationship recently fell apart with rumors of cheating – though Gleb insists he didn’t have an affair. Who really cares about the details of their messy split, anyway?

Okay, so Brooks is really owning the dating scene these days! She’s been spotted with some seriously amazing guys – tennis stars Carlos Alcaraz and Janik Sinner, even football legend Tom Brady. And now? She’s currently seeing Taron Egerton, you might recognize him from Rocketman! It seems she’s definitely enjoying life and exploring her options.

I saw them out on a date on March 28th, and they looked so happy together! They had dinner at Capo Steakhouse in Santa Monica, and then continued the night with drinks at Shutters on the Beach. It was really sweet to see.

As we wonder if this love story will last or fade quickly, let’s remember those who cherished the delicate moments before.

As a lifestyle expert, I’ve always admired those who bravely chase their dreams, and Brooks Nader is a perfect example. She left Louisiana at 19 to pursue modeling in New York, and let me tell you, it wasn’t easy! She recently shared a hilarious, but relatable, story with People magazine. Her dad, being practical, basically told her she had a ‘full-ride scholarship’ in life and needed to be resourceful. His advice? Find a boyfriend to help with rent! Thankfully, she did, and it saved the day. It just goes to show, sometimes you have to get creative when building your life in a new city!

I always got the sense she really fell for Billy Haire, that advertising executive. They seemed so happy together, and they actually got married in New Orleans’ French Quarter in December 2019 – it was a beautiful event!

I was so heartbroken when I had to tell my parents I was getting divorced, almost five years after everything started. It was like I’d done something truly awful, according to them! I shared this on our reality show, Love Thy Nader, with my sisters – Sarah Jane, Grace Ann, and Mary Holland – and they just couldn’t understand. They honestly thought it was the worst possible choice and told me divorce was a sin. It was a really tough time.

The Sports Illustrated Swimsuit model sees things differently. She told Bustle in 2025 that realizing her own strength after ending a ten-year relationship was incredibly empowering. “I realized I could do anything I set my mind to,” she explained. “I’ve proven to myself that I’m capable of anything – I can have a child, build a business, and overcome any challenge. It’s an amazing feeling.”

Billy continued his streak of dating reality stars, getting engaged to Naomie Olindo, who previously appeared on Southern Charm, in December 2025.

After her divorce, rumors began circulating that Brooks was dating retired NFL quarterback Tom Brady. They were seen together at Michael Rubin’s Fourth of July party in 2024, but the connection didn’t last, and they were no longer together by the fall.

According to her sister, Sarah Jane, she’s enjoying being single and is having a really exciting time, as she told the Daily Mail that September.

Shortly after her divorce in 2024, Brooke Shields joined the cast of Dancing With the Stars, and she was hoping for more than just a win. She was partnered with professional dancer Gleb Savchenko, and the pair quickly developed a close relationship off the dance floor as well.

Similar to their passionate dancing, their relationship was mostly physical. She explained on Love Thy Nader that, having been single for the first time in years and dancing with someone she considered incredibly attractive, things moved very fast.

Brooks explained on the Freeform series that their entire relationship consisted of physical intimacy, as they didn’t have much meaningful conversation.

Maybe their communication issues led him to be shocked when she told him in April 2025 that they were growing apart.

Gleb was surprised to learn, through a recent article, that Brooks had ended their relationship. He stated on April 7th to Us Weekly that the last time he heard from her was a text message on April 6th, where she requested a conversation. He tried calling her that day, but she hasn’t responded.

Jimmy Kimmel playfully asked Nader if the rumors about her dating tennis star Jannik Sinner were true. During her September 2025 appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live, he asked, “Are you dating Italian superstar Jannik Sinner?” She responded with a bit of humor, saying, “Is this like an interrogation? I’m so scared right now.”

She hinted that Stephen Colbert might know the truth. She mentioned sitting next to him at the U.S. Open on August 31st and suggested asking him which match they attended. She also pointed out that Jannik Sinner likely wasn’t at that particular match, saying, “You’re close, but we weren’t at that one.”

During an appearance on Kimmel, Brooks subtly suggested she was seeing Spanish tennis star Carlos Alcaraz. Her sister, Grace Ann, confirmed the rumors to TopMob News at New York Fashion Week, saying, “The rumors are true.” However, she clarified that things were still early stages. “‘Dating’ is a strong word,” Grace Ann explained, “but he’s definitely someone special right now.”

While Grace Ann was still hoping to be introduced, he’d already met her sisters. “I can’t wait to,” she said about meeting the seven-time Grand Slam champion. “He’s so cute!”

When asked about dating both a swimsuit model and tennis players, she playfully responded on Watch What Happens Live in September 2025, “‘Dating’ means something different now, doesn’t it? Men do this all the time, so what’s the problem if I do?”

Let me tell you, it was such a sweet sight! I happened to be in Los Angeles on March 28th, 2026, and spotted Taron Egerton – you know, the Rocketman star – on a date with his partner. They had a lovely three-hour dinner at Capo in Santa Monica, and then strolled hand-in-hand to Shutters on the Beach. It was just a really tender, intimate moment – they were completely lost in each other’s company.

Read More

2026-03-31 18:17