The Walking Dead Almost Cast A Scream Legend As Negan

by

Matthew Lillard, known for his role in Scream, was the second choice to play Negan on The Walking Dead. If Jeffrey Dean Morgan hadn’t taken the part, the iconic villain would have been portrayed very differently. Negan is a difficult character to play because he needs to be both frightening and cruel, yet also possess a peculiar, captivating appeal.

Morgan turned out to be ideal for the role, perfectly blending brutality with a strong, confident presence. However, no production can rely on a single actor. Even if your first choice loves the script and wants to join, a scheduling issue could derail everything and force you to find someone else. It’s also common for actors to be hesitant about committing to a long-term TV series.

As a huge fan of The Walking Dead, I remember everyone thinking Morgan was locked in to play Negan. It felt like a sure thing! But apparently, the showrunners were smart to have a backup plan. They actually considered another actor for the role, and honestly, if they’d gone with him, the whole show could have been very different. It’s wild to think about how close we were to a totally different Negan – and a potentially different Walking Dead!

Matthew Lillard Was The Backup Casting Choice For Negan

Man, I’ve been seeing Jamie Lillard everywhere lately. He’s been hitting the press circuit for the new Scream movie, which is awesome. But the really wild thing? Quentin Tarantino just went on this huge, unexpected rant defending him and a bunch of other actors. It was totally out of the blue! Because of all that, Lillard’s been doing a ton of interviews, and we’re getting some really cool behind-the-scenes stories. It’s been a fun ride as a movie fan!

I was totally shocked to hear this, but apparently, Damian Lillard almost played Negan on The Walking Dead! He was at Comic-Con promoting Twin Peaks: The Return when he ran into the show’s creators. The showrunner actually told him he had the role, but only for about ten minutes! Can you believe that? It’s wild to think how different things could have been.

An offer was made to Jeffrey Morgan, but when it seemed he might decline, the producers quickly considered Billy Lillard for the role of Negan. However, Morgan accepted the offer just ten minutes later, confirming his continued role. While I really enjoy Morgan’s portrayal of Negan, Lillard would have been a fascinating alternative.

Lillard acknowledged his version of Negan would have been quite different from Jeffrey Dean Morgan’s. He described Morgan’s portrayal as powerfully tough and masculine, while he would have leaned into a more eccentric and humorous take on the character – something fans familiar with his roles in films like Scream, Scooby-Doo, and Without a Paddle might expect.

Lillard’s Negan Might’ve Improved The Walking Dead’s Darkest Season

Negan’s arrival marked a turning point for The Walking Dead, shifting it from a mainstream hit to something primarily enjoyed by dedicated fans. The shocking violence, like Glenn’s death, caused many viewers to stop watching altogether. Only the most committed fans continued to follow the show and its later spin-offs.

Throughout its sixth season, The Walking Dead steadily hinted at the arrival of a powerful new villain named Negan. He was presented as the leader of a much larger and more dangerous group than any seen before, and the season finale delivered on that promise. Negan proved to be truly frightening, immediately establishing himself as a major threat by killing a key character – a moment that mirrored the events of the original comic book.

The show made a strange and frustrating decision, similar to a plot twist from Dallas: it showed a murder from the victim’s perspective, but didn’t reveal who was killed for several months. After a summer of guessing, The Walking Dead returned for its season 7 premiere, and it was an incredibly difficult episode to watch.

The episode titled “The Day Will Come When You Won’t Be” was a turning point for many viewers. While the show had been declining in quality for a couple of years, the graphic violence – specifically Negan killing Glenn and brutally torturing Rick, and almost making Rick amputate Carl’s hand – made it no longer enjoyable to watch.

The biggest issue with season seven of The Walking Dead is that it became excessively bleak. After Negan arrives and Rick’s group falls under his control, the show unfortunately focuses too much on relentless torture and suffering. Each episode becomes difficult to watch, as beloved characters are constantly terrorized.

Jeffrey Dean Morgan was the ideal choice for Negan, but if Billy Lillard had gotten the part, he probably would have brought a more comedic and less intimidating energy to the role. Lillard has said he would have approached the character with a similar sense of humor to his performances in films like Serial Mom and Five Nights at Freddy’s, envisioning a post-apocalyptic version of his character Stu Macher. Some believe this lighter take could have made season 7 of The Walking Dead less relentlessly grim.

Jeffrey Dean Morgan Was The Perfect Actor To Play Negan

It would have been fun to see Damian Lillard as Negan, but Jeffrey Dean Morgan was the ideal choice. Trying to picture anyone else in the role feels wrong, like imagining a different actor as Walter White (Bryan Cranston) or Homelander (Antony Starr) – Morgan was perfectly cast and seemed destined to play Negan.

Morgan often points to the Walking Dead episode “Here’s Negan” as a prime example of what made him ideal for the role. The episode reveals Negan’s heartbreaking history with his wife, Lucille – the woman for whom he named his barbed-wire bat. Negan deeply loved Lucille, but was helpless to save her when she became ill in a world ravaged by apocalypse, ultimately leaving him devastated and isolated.

This week’s episode surprisingly made us sympathize with Negan, the villain responsible for Glenn’s death. It’s a testament to actor Jeffrey Dean Morgan’s incredible range. He perfectly portrays Negan’s terrifying side, reminiscent of Heath Ledger’s Joker, while also making him feel surprisingly vulnerable and relatable in this episode focusing on his past.

Most actors couldn’t pull off this role. They’d either be convincing as the villain but lack the needed vulnerability, or they’d portray the sympathetic side so well that the character’s darkness wouldn’t come across. Morgan managed to keep viewers engaged with The Walking Dead for several more seasons by skillfully balancing these opposing traits.

Read More

2026-04-03 21:09