A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms’ Big Death Brings Back a Common Game of Thrones Misconception

by

While A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is different from Game of Thrones, it still unfolds in the same dangerous world, so a major death in Episode 5 isn’t unexpected. Dunk’s Trial by Seven was always a risky undertaking. However, the character who dies might surprise viewers who haven’t read George R.R. Martin’s Dunk and Egg stories. This death also highlights a common misunderstanding from the original series, one that began with Ned Stark’s fate. Spoiler alert: This explanation contains spoilers for Season 1, Episode 5 of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms.

Since the Kingsguard couldn’t harm any Targaryens during the Trial by Seven, characters like Princes Maekar and Baelor were expected to be safe. That’s why Baelor Targaryen’s death in the first season is so surprising – especially since he was just shown standing and talking moments before. Baelor died because he volunteered to join Dunk’s team, completing the group and saving Dunk from a faster defeat. This has led some to compare his death to that of Ned Stark, and to a conclusion that, while common, isn’t necessarily accurate.

Baelor Targaryen’s Death Is Bringing Up The Cost of Honor in Westeros

Watching Dunk’s story unfold, especially after Baelor’s death, really got me thinking about honor in Westeros. It feels like he was punished because he tried to do the right thing, defending those who couldn’t defend themselves. I’ve seen a lot of discussion, even on places like The A.V. Club and Reddit, about how this death just reinforces the idea that being a genuinely good person in that world comes with a terrible price. And honestly? I think there’s something to that. George R.R. Martin doesn’t seem to let goodness go unpunished, and this episode really drove that home for me.

We’ve seen this happen before with characters like Ned Stark and Jon Snow. In the world of Westeros, staying true to your principles can create powerful enemies—and prove fatal if those enemies don’t share your sense of right and wrong. This is what led to Ned’s execution and Jon Snow’s betrayal, and now Baelor has suffered a similar fate. However, focusing solely on their honorable intentions misses a larger point about their deaths—a point that’s often ignored.

A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms Also Brings Back a Common Game of Thrones Misconception

Many viewers of A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms and Game of Thrones might think the shows prove that being honorable doesn’t lead to success. However, that’s a misunderstanding. While George R.R. Martin’s stories definitely show that honor comes with a high price, they also suggest it’s ultimately worthwhile, even if it demands sacrifice. After all, if characters aren’t willing to sacrifice for what they believe in, can they truly be considered honorable?

Watching Baelor’s story unfold in A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, told through Dunk’s eyes, really makes you consider the power of staying true to your principles, even when it leads to a grim end. Yes, Baelor’s sacrifice is tragic, but it directly saves Dunk, and that’s huge. Seeing how Dunk shapes Egg’s life, and knowing the man Egg eventually becomes, I think Baelor’s choice ripples outward in a surprisingly positive way. It’s a payoff, just not the one you anticipate – it’s subtle, but undeniably there.

As a huge fan, I’ve always thought about Ned Stark’s story. While it’s not as simple as one thing leading directly to another with him, his death definitely caused a ripple effect. It was awful for his family right away, but it also kicked off the War of the Five Kings. If Ned hadn’t been executed, the Lannisters would have stayed in power, and their corruption would have continued unchecked. Honestly, so much of what happens in Game of Thrones wouldn’t have happened at all, and Westeros would have stayed stuck in the same old power dynamics.

I’ve always felt that when characters like Baelor or Ned meet tragic ends, it’s not a lesson about honor being a weakness. It’s more about how incredibly difficult it is to actually do what’s right, and yet, despite all the pain, it’s still a path worth taking. It really resonated with me that sticking to your principles, even when it hurts, is ultimately worthwhile.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/feature/3-theories-about-who-where-dunk-is-during-a-song-of-ice-and-fire-after-game-of-thrones-canon-change/embed/#

Read More

2026-02-19 01:40