Assessing U.S. SEC’s latest move against FTX: Crypto regulation goes too far?

  • SEC demands FTX repayments in stablecoins, sparking industry criticism.
  • Gensler’s regulatory approach faces backlash amid concerns over future influence.

As a seasoned researcher who has witnessed the evolution of cryptocurrencies and their regulatory landscape over the past decade, I find myself increasingly alarmed by the ongoing tussle between the SEC and the crypto industry. The latest development involving FTX’s repayment in stablecoins, as demanded by the SEC, seems to be another instance of regulatory overreach that is causing unnecessary confusion and uncertainty within the industry.


According to a recent statement made by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the troubled cryptocurrency platform FTX has been advised firmly about compensating affected parties. The SEC strongly recommends that FTX should consider utilizing stablecoins or other digital currencies for this purpose.

Coinbase CLO slams SEC

This action has drawn criticism from numerous executives, including Paul Grewal, the Chief Legal Officer of Coinbase, who claims that the Securities and Exchange Commission is intentionally creating confusion regarding the regulatory environment for cryptocurrencies.

Taking to X (formerly Twitter), Grewal noted, 

Assessing U.S. SEC’s latest move against FTX: Crypto regulation goes too far?

Additionally, he emphasized the agency’s unwillingness to explain whether the transactions at hand were legal or not, and made this assertion.

“Why provide clarity to the market when threats and aspersions will do?” 

Expressing frustration on the matter, he further added, 

“Investors, consumers and markets deserve better. Way better.” 

What happened so far?

As a crypto investor, I’ve recently learned from a court filing on the 30th of August with the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Delaware, SEC attorneys have mentioned that making payments to creditors using stablecoins isn’t necessarily illegal, but it’s not an outright green light either. This means that while it’s possible, there may still be some regulatory hurdles to overcome.

However, the SEC retains the option to contest such payments if they involve US-dollar pegged crypto assets. 

Assessing U.S. SEC’s latest move against FTX: Crypto regulation goes too far?

Clearly, after its fall in November 2022, FTX has been looking into multiple approaches to settle outstanding debts from creditors. One such approach, which was eventually discarded, involved reopening the trading platform.

Although several creditors prefer repayment in the form they are owed, FTX’s recently proposed liquidation strategy chooses to resolve claims using U.S. dollars instead.

Crypto community against SEC?

Just as anticipated, Grewal wasn’t the only one voicing criticism; generally speaking, the larger cryptocurrency community has largely expressed disapproval of the SEC’s position.

Alex Thorn, the Head of Research at Galaxy Digital, shared similar sentiments with Grewal, noting that the ongoing actions taken by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) are causing perplexity and doubt within the sector.

“This is the height of  jurisdictional overreach.” 

He further added, 

“The SEC is not presenting an argument here; rather, they seem reluctant to drop the issue. It appears they want to keep their authority over these seemingly conventional tools, in case any legitimate parties decide to use them.”

Gensler’s crypto approach in question

As a seasoned investor with several decades of experience in the financial market, I have witnessed numerous changes in the regulatory landscape over the years. However, under Chairman Gary Gensler’s leadership at the SEC, I find myself increasingly concerned about the direction the agency is taking. The current regulatory approach seems to be more focused on imposing new rules and regulations without fully considering their potential impact on market participants and investors like me. This situation underscores the need for a balanced and thoughtful approach that prioritizes both investor protection and fostering a vibrant and competitive market.

Regarding cryptocurrency, Gensler’s time in office is characterized by a strong regulatory approach that some perceive as going beyond the necessary boundaries. This skeptical figure has taken steps that are seen as quite assertive by many.

If Vice President Kamala Harris becomes president in November, there’s a possibility that Gary Gensler might be chosen for the position of Treasury Secretary.

This could significantly increase his control over financial laws, potentially affecting the cryptocurrency market as well.

It’s uncertain if the SEC will keep Gensler on board, given the growing criticism from the crypto community, or decide to bring in fresh leadership instead.

Read More

2024-09-02 18:16