Black Widow’s 8 MCU Appearances, Ranked

by

In the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), Natasha Romanoff, famously known as Black Widow, has starred in eight different productions. Portrayed by Scarlett Johansson, this enigmatic character with a past as a Red Room assassin made her MCU debut in 2010’s “Iron Man 2” and later joined the original six Avengers in 2012. Throughout four “Avengers” movies and two “Captain America” films, Black Widow played a crucial role, earning her a place among beloved MCU characters.

After her death in “Avengers: Endgame” (2019), her standalone movie “Black Widow” (2021) served as a fitting farewell to Natasha’s storyline. While Black Widow didn’t receive the trilogy of solo films she might have deserved, she left an indelible mark on the big screen during her run.

This list ranks the eight Marvel Cinematic Universe films starring Black Widow, arranged in order from least impressive writing for her character to most impressive.

By rephrasing “worst to best” as “least impressive to most impressive,” and changing “quality of writing for the character” to “writing for her character,” I’ve aimed to make the sentence more natural and easy to read while maintaining its original meaning.

8) Iron Man 2

As a dedicated cinephile, I can’t help but reflect on Black Widow’s remarkable entrance into the Marvel Cinematic Universe, an appearance that sadly has its share of conspicuous shortcomings. In Iron Man 2, Natasha is unveiled as an undercover S.H.I.E.L.D agent, going by Natalie Rushman. It’s not until Tony Stark, aka Iron Man (the charismatic Robert Downey Jr.), uncovers her true identity that she steps into the limelight, playing a pivotal role in dismantling Ivan Vanko. Despite her limited screen presence, Natasha manages to steal the show. The electrifying hallway fight scene at Hammer Industries remains the movie’s most captivating moment, leaving almost everything else feeling secondary.

In the film Iron Man 2, the portrayal of Black Widow, or Natasha, can be seen as a form of on-screen objectification. The movie fails to provide her with substantial character development, instead presenting her as primarily an attractive accessory for the male viewer. A particularly problematic scene in the movie features Natasha changing clothes in Happy Hogan’s car while he watches through the rearview mirror, which serves as a prime example of her over-sexualization and the one-dimensional characterization she faced during her earlier appearances within the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

7) Avengers: Age of Ultron

In the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s “Avengers: Age of Ultron,” Black Widow reunites with Earth’s strongest superheroes to confront their formidable artificial intelligence adversary, Ultron, portrayed by James Spader. Natasha once again gets embroiled in thrilling battles, but a side plot that doesn’t align with her character significantly diminishes the impact of her presence in the film. The romantic entanglement between Black Widow and Bruce Banner/Hulk (played by Mark Ruffalo) is questionable at best, as it seems to be an ill-conceived decision on the part of the writers, with the characters showing little chemistry or convincing reasons for their relationship. The awkwardness of these scenes in “Avengers: Age of Ultron” detracts from both the movie’s overall quality and Black Widow’s narrative arc. To add insult to injury, there is a scene where Natasha suggests she too is a monster because she can’t bear children. This handling of Black Widow borders on character assassination in “Avengers: Age of Ultron,” as it negates much of what she accomplishes in the film.

6) Avengers: Endgame

After Thanos’ (Josh Brolin) Snap wiped out half of all life in the universe, Natasha and the remaining Avengers devised a last strategy to vanquish the Mad Titan. In Avengers: Endgame, Natasha meets her end for the Soul Stone following an emotional exchange with Clint Barton/Hawkeye (Jeremy Renner) on Vormir. While this selfless act aligns with Natasha’s character, its placement in the middle of the movie means her death takes a back seat to Iron Man’s later sacrifice. Additionally, Black Widow’s demise is particularly poignant as she hadn’t yet starred in a solo film at that time. Watching the MCU determine Natasha’s fate after years of unfulfilled promises will always be heart-wrenching. Furthermore, the epic showdown against Thanos involving all Avengers lacks resonance without Natasha. A groundbreaking Marvel hero like Black Widow should have fought alongside her successors, but instead, the MCU chose an early, somewhat incomplete death for her.

5) Captain America: The Winter Soldier

In the movie “Captain America: The Winter Soldier”, Black Widow plays a significant supporting role, teaming up with Steve Rogers/Captain America (played by Chris Evans) and Sam Wilson/Falcon (Anthony Mackie). Together, they aim to stop S.H.I.E.L.D.’s infiltration and fight against the Winter Soldier (Sebastian Stan). While Black Widow plays a crucial part in the story of “The Winter Soldier”, some writing oversights hold it back from being one of the standout appearances of Black Widow in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Throughout the film, she takes part in numerous thrilling action sequences, but unfortunately, her character lacks depth. Instead, her overly flirtatious behavior and contrived one-liners make scenes outside of fights seem dull.

4) Captain America: Civil War

In the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s film, Captain America: Civil War, Black Widow is one of many characters, initially siding with Iron Man in the internal Avengers dispute over the Sokovia Accords. However, unlike most characters in the movie, Black Widow changes her allegiance from supporting to opposing the Sokovia Accords. Her relationship with Steve Rogers becomes crucial in the story, influencing her eventual decision to aid him. The film shows Natasha’s transformation, moving from a desire to maintain Avengers unity and please the U.S. government to bridging the divide when others wouldn’t. Despite its large cast, Civil War provides a more nuanced portrayal of Black Widow compared to her previous appearances. Civil War remains one of the best MCU movies and offers significant character development for Black Widow.

3) The Avengers

In “The Avengers,” this seminal Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) film serves as a cornerstone, introducing the initial six-hero team, including Black Widow. Natasha Romanoff, played by Scarlett Johansson, plays a significant role in the Avengers’ chase for Loki and the Tesseract, helping shape the group’s dynamic and identity. This provides ample opportunity for her character development. However, at times, Black Widow’s portrayal resembles the objectified version from “Iron Man 2.” Nevertheless, this doesn’t hinder her emergence as a key figure in the MCU. The film effectively presents Black Widow as an intelligent operative and formidable fighter first and foremost. Her cunning is evident when she deceives Loki to uncover his plans. Moreover, Black Widow proves crucial during the Battle of New York, and her relationship with Clint adds complexity to her narrative. Ultimately, “The Avengers” elevates Black Widow to an iconic status within the MCU.

2) Avengers: Infinity War

In the fast-paced action movie “Avengers: Infinity War,” there’s less focus on character development but Black Widow stands out significantly during the intense struggle against Thanos and his forces. With her iconic blonde hair and green vest, Natasha fearlessly engages in hand-to-hand combat with a multitude of powerful characters in both Edinburgh and Wakanda. Despite being beaten and knocked down on several occasions, she never wavers and always gets back up. The Avengers ultimately lose to Thanos in “Infinity War,” but Black Widow displays an unprecedented level of bravery and resilience in the Marvel Cinematic Universe at this juncture. Natasha’s survival underscores her courage and strength in the face of formidable challenges, making “Infinity War” a significant milestone in her transformation into a hero.

1) Black Widow

In a refreshing turn of events for Black Widow’s solo film, the storyline gives depth to the character, avoiding common tropes such as background dismissal, objectification, forced romantic entanglements, or premature demise. This movie serves as Natasha Romanoff’s eighth and final appearance in the franchise, a poignant farewell considering it was released posthumously. Despite this somber note, Black Widow offers an intriguing exploration of its lead character’s past, introducing Natasha’s long-lost sister Yelena Belova (played by Florence Pugh) and unveiling the identities of her parents, Alexei Shostakov/Red Guardian (David Harbour) and Melina Vostokoff (Rachel Weisz).

The atmosphere within the group is genuine and touching, but it never overshadows Natasha as the central focus in the movie. Natasha grapples with her role as both a hero and an individual after her failed assassination attempt on General Dreykov (Ray Winstone), and the consequences that linger. Sadly, Black Widow doesn’t quite compensate for the Marvel Cinematic Universe not fully utilizing Natasha’s potential and appeal during her time. Yet, it offers a standalone exceptional portrayal of Black Widow within the MCU due to its raw human storyline and insightful exploration of the protagonist – aspects that were long overdue.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/scarlett-johansson-is-the-perfect-director-for-these-7-possible-future-mcu-projects-after-playing-black-widow-for-11-years/embed/#

Read More

2025-08-02 14:42