Comics Are Failing DC’s Best Character (But Here’s Who Is Getting It Right)

by

Batman is often considered one of DC Comics’ greatest characters. First appearing in 1939, he’s been a consistently popular and complex figure ever since. Throughout his long history, Batman’s story has been developed and expanded, and he’s faced countless challenges both as the masked hero of Gotham and as his public identity, Bruce Wayne.

Although Batman and Bruce Wayne have evolved significantly over the years, some core aspects of the character remain constant. He still struggles with loneliness, despite forming relationships, and doesn’t seem to undergo major personal growth. While Gotham City changes around him, Batman largely stays the same. Continuously revisiting the same basic character traits feels like a disservice to his potential, except in one particular instance where the character is being handled exceptionally well.

Batman Has Great Comics, But He’s Not Actually Changing

I’m a big Batman and Batman comics fan – there are some truly amazing stories. However, it feels like the character often gets stuck in a rut. Run after run, we see the same themes repeated: Batman isolating himself and insisting on working alone, even though he’s built a whole team of allies and sidekicks to help him. It’s like the character isn’t growing or changing. You could practically create a game where you take a drink every time Batman decides to go it alone – no one would finish the comic book run!

Batman’s relationships consistently cycle through progress and setbacks. He might make headway with a son like Damian, only for them to clash again in the next story. This pattern is even more pronounced with Jason Todd, and it’s often unclear what’s happening with Tim Drake. While Batman’s trauma explains some of his difficulties, writers often show him having moments of insight that suggest lasting change. However, these changes rarely stick – when a story ends and a new creative team takes over, he usually reverts to being a solitary figure. While these stories can be compelling, it feels like we’re constantly starting over.

TV and Movies Let Batman Change (And That’s a Good Thing)

Batman remains fairly consistent in comic books, but his portrayal in movies and TV shows often shows him changing and growing. Unlike the comics, these adaptations usually give Batman a complete character arc – a journey where he develops over the course of a series, like in Christopher Nolan’s Dark Knight trilogy. This means if you were to revisit that world years later, you’d find a Batman who isn’t stuck repeating the same patterns. He might face similar challenges, but he’d be tackling them in new ways.

Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight Rises perfectly showcases Batman and Bruce Wayne’s growth throughout the trilogy. Batman Begins offered a fresh take on the origin story, while The Dark Knight presented a more experienced hero in action. The Dark Knight Rises, however, forced Batman to confront his limits and learn from his past. The film concludes with a sense of completion – he’s achieved his goals and found peace. While Nolan chose to end his narrative there, it doesn’t necessarily mark the end of Batman’s journey. In fact, Bruce Wayne’s healing and acceptance at the film’s end could pave the way for him to become an even more impactful hero. A Batman free from the weight of past trauma would have a stronger motivation to improve Gotham and ensure its future, potentially inspiring other heroes to carry on his work.

Comics often tell the same Batman story: a brooding, isolated hero who keeps returning to that state, even after showing growth. This limits the potential for more interesting and complex narratives. A Batman with a more fulfilling personal life would face higher stakes, making his struggles feel more meaningful and impactful. If other media can successfully evolve Batman into a more relatable and human character, comics should do the same – it would only enhance one of DC’s most iconic heroes.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/list/7-dc-characters-who-defeated-the-joker-who-werent-batman/embed/#

Read More

2025-12-01 01:11