Dead Space Was Killed (Twice) and No One Has Been Able to Pick up the Torch

Dead Space initially drew inspiration from games and movies like *Resident Evil 4*, *Event Horizon*, *The Thing* (1982), and *Alien*, but it quickly evolved into something uniquely its own. Thanks to its memorable hero and innovative gameplay, Dead Space distinguished itself and made a significant impact on its genre.

Electronic Arts unfortunately cancelled the Dead Space series, and then, true to form, did so again about ten years later. While the franchise has been revived and cancelled multiple times, nothing has managed to replicate its unique success, which speaks poorly about the current state of the gaming industry.

Dead Space Came at the Right Place at the Right Time

The creation of *Dead Space* came about because some developers wanted to shift away from Electronic Arts’ focus on sequels and games based on existing movies. Executive producer Glen Schofield had been working on movie tie-ins like *The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King* and *007: From Russia With Love*, and then *System Shock 3*. However, after the team was heavily influenced by *Resident Evil 4*, they re-evaluated their direction. Instead of just pitching the idea, they showed EA a playable demo. Impressed, EA—despite usually avoiding risks—approved the game.

When Capcom wasn’t focused on less-than-stellar sequels and spin-offs, Dead Space stepped in and innovated within the survival horror genre, building on the foundation laid by Resident Evil 4. The game’s signature dismemberment mechanic wasn’t just for show; it genuinely heightened the tension. Players had to strategically target specific limbs while under attack, creating a truly terrifying experience. As art director Ian Milham explained, it captured the frantic, precise movements of a horror movie character desperately trying to escape – like fumbling with keys while a killer closes in.

Unlike many games of its time that relied on static headshots, *Dead Space* focused on a more fluid and active combat system, perfectly complementing its telekinetic abilities. Skilled players could conserve ammo by strategically using environmental hazards like explosive canisters or detached enemy claws. This ability to move while shooting set *Dead Space* apart from games like *Resident Evil*, which emphasized stationary combat. Importantly, this new approach didn’t compromise the game’s intensity. Combined with a detailed universe and compelling backstory, *Dead Space* felt remarkably polished and unified – an impressive feat for a first game. According to developer Schofield, quality and innovation were central to the game’s design, and that commitment is clearly evident throughout the experience.

Look, I loved the first two *Dead Space* games – they were genuinely scary and had awesome gameplay. Visceral Games really nailed it. But then, with *Dead Space 3*, things just…changed. It felt like the people making the game were being told what to do by suits who didn’t *get* what made Dead Space special. They wanted more action, tried to make it appeal to everyone, and started cutting corners with the budget. Then came the microtransactions – seriously? It totally ruined the horror vibe. They even had a cool idea for what came next, but the damage was done. After *Dead Space 3*, the series just kind of…fizzled out. It felt like it was waiting for someone to pick it up and do what it did to *Resident Evil* when that series was struggling – step in and be the new king of space horror.

The Callisto Protocol Was Not the Spiritual Sequel Dead Space Deserved

With a team made up of creators from the popular game *Dead Space*, *The Callisto Protocol* looked like it could be the next big horror title. Like early versions of *Dead Space*, it featured a terrifying space setting and a main character who was imprisoned. However, despite the developer’s promises of prioritizing quality, the final product didn’t quite live up to expectations.

Despite claims that the game was rushed to release due to publisher pressure, the issues with *The Callisto Protocol* run much deeper. Its clunky controls and simplistic gameplay made combat feel tedious, and it failed to deliver genuinely frightening moments. The story, which started uninspired, became even more predictable as it progressed, ultimately lacking the strong narrative and clever design that made *Dead Space* so successful. Coupled with a disappointing attempt to expand the game and a significantly reduced development team, it’s doubtful the studio will be able to create a truly compelling spiritual successor to *Dead Space*.

Electronic Arts (EA) unexpectedly cancelled further development of the *Dead Space* series, despite the critical and commercial success of the 2023 remake. This came shortly after the similar failure of the game *Callisto*. The remake was considered one of the best in the industry, praised for its innovative ideas and faithfulness to the original *Dead Space* games, but it wasn’t enough to secure the series’ future. EA reassigned the remake’s developer, Motive Studio, to work on the safer, though less exciting, *Iron Man* and *Battlefield 6* projects. It’s unfortunate that Motive now works on *Battlefield*, considering the previous *Dead Space* team, Visceral Games, was moved to the underwhelming *Battlefield Hardline* after *Dead Space 3* didn’t perform well. The *Dead Space* team has been scattered, and plans for a sequel are currently on hold, leaving the door open for another studio to potentially continue the series.

Cronos: The New Dawn Was Yet Another Terrible Attempt at Dead Space

Cronos: The New Dawn aimed to be a standout horror experience. After Bloober Team successfully remade Silent Hill 2, proving they could deliver a quality horror game, the announcement of Cronos generated excitement. The debut trailer immediately showed the game’s inspiration from Dead Space, featuring an armored protagonist with futuristic weaponry battling strange, blob-like creatures – a connection the developers later confirmed.

As the game *Callisto* demonstrates, initial inspiration can become a problem if the final product isn’t good. *Cronos*, unfortunately, suffered from this, delivering a game filled with cheap, ineffective scares and frustrating combat. This was made worse by limited resources, enemies that barely reacted to damage, and a core gameplay idea – monsters merging with corpses – that felt weak and underused. It wasn’t a strategic system at all. The game also failed to capitalize on its potentially interesting world, offering a bland main character, overly cynical story elements, and a jarring, unexpected plot twist at the end. It seemed Bloober Team had fallen back into old, uninspired habits.

Honestly, the chances of getting another game like Dead Space feel pretty slim these days. It feels like the gaming industry has really changed for the worse in recent years, with so many executives just chasing quick profits and not caring about making truly great games. Survival horror isn’t exactly mainstream, and big publishers are hesitant to invest in things that might not bring in huge returns. When the Dead Space remake was first announced, things felt different. The success of *Resident Evil 2* and *The Last of Us Part II*, plus everyone being stuck at home during the pandemic, meant there was money flowing around and it seemed like a good time to take a risk. But then things changed as people started going back to their normal lives, and a lot of those pandemic-era projects – like EA’s cancelled Black Panther game – suddenly looked like bad investments. That’s why we’ve seen so many layoffs and studios closing down lately, and it makes me worry about the future of the genre.

A New Dead Space (Or “Dead Space”) Seems Unlikely

A purchase of EA is likely to happen soon, and with the company potentially taking on $20 billion in debt (or paying a $1 billion fee if the deal falls through), a new Dead Space game is very unlikely. Publishers generally don’t invest in single-player horror games when they have such large debts. While the Dead Space franchise *could* be sold, it’s common for companies to simply hold onto franchises without planning to use them.

Creating another horror game like *Callisto Protocol* is currently difficult due to a lack of funding. Glen Schofield recently shared that his proposal for a new *Dead Space* game was rejected by EA, and generally, securing large investments for AAA games is proving challenging. *Callisto Protocol* itself cost a substantial $160 million to develop, and after its poor performance, publisher Krafton is unlikely to risk that amount on another horror title. This trend isn’t limited to EA; publishers are increasingly focusing on well-known franchises, particularly in the US, where economic conditions are worsening.

A smaller game studio could potentially create a horror game similar to *Dead Space*, but it’s unlikely. While a modestly sized team would be ideal for this type of project, financial constraints are a major issue throughout the gaming industry. The game *Cronos* fit this profile, but Bloober Team isn’t currently capable of consistently delivering high-quality, mid-range horror experiences, especially not in the style of *Silent Hill*.

It’s becoming increasingly difficult to create a new horror game like Dead Space. Financial pressures within the gaming industry, combined with risk-averse decision-making by company executives, have made it hard for these kinds of games to succeed outside of companies like Capcom and Sony. It’s unlikely that a smaller studio could create a truly impressive, similar game, or that a larger developer would receive the necessary funding and time to make a proper sequel or successor. Instead, Dead Space will likely be kept alive through small references and expensive in-game items, allowing the series to generate profit without substantial investment – much like a necromorph being controlled by a host.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/gaming/news/silent-hill-f-series-best-22-years-breaks-free-sh2-grip/embed/#

2025-10-09 22:51

Dead Space Came at the Right Place at the Right Time

The Callisto Protocol Was Not the Spiritual Sequel Dead Space Deserved

Cronos: The New Dawn Was Yet Another Terrible Attempt at Dead Space

A New Dead Space (Or “Dead Space”) Seems Unlikely

Read More