Every Season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Ranked from Best to Worst

by

Buffy the Vampire Slayer was a groundbreaking and popular television show that helped define the urban fantasy genre. It ran for seven seasons and remains culturally significant today. Created by Joss Whedon, who also wrote the original 1992 film, the show follows Buffy Summers, a teenage girl destined to fight vampires, demons, and other monsters. Along the way, she’s aided by a group of friends known as the Scooby Gang, as well as the vampires Angel and Spike. Beyond the supernatural action, Buffy also explored important themes like LGBTQ+ representation and female empowerment.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer ran for seven seasons, beginning with the introduction of Buffy in Sunnydale and culminating in the activation of a new generation of Slayers, with a glimpse into the future. Now, with a new Buffy series on the way, let’s revisit and rank the best seasons of the original show.

7) Season 7

The last season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer brought the show’s storylines to a close and hinted at big changes for the Slayers. It featured major events like the disbanding of the Watchers Council, the emergence of multiple active Slayers, and a climactic showdown against the First Evil – played by Nathan Fillion – that threatened Sunnydale and the Hellmouth.

The final season suffered from being both overly complicated and strangely empty. With so many potential slayers introduced, Buffy lost her unique importance, and the finale made some major missteps, like the unimpactful death of Anya. Many fans believe the series could have ended perfectly after the fifth season, as things felt forced and overdone in the later episodes.

6) Season 4

Season 4 of Buffy the Vampire Slayer suffered in comparison to its phenomenal third season, especially after the dramatic events of ‘Graduation Day.’ The season started slowly as Buffy adjusted to college life, and these changes unfortunately diminished what made the first three seasons so great. Compounding the issues were weak villains, particularly Adam, and an uninspired romantic storyline with Riley.

Despite some weaker points, the season had truly memorable moments, particularly the introductions of Tara and Willow’s storylines. Although the college setting presented challenges for the show, the season was ultimately saved by standout episodes, most notably “Hush,” which is widely considered a masterpiece of television, regardless of the show’s genre.

5) Season 6

Season six of Buffy the Vampire Slayer is often debated among fans, with several storylines causing disagreement. A major point of contention was the complicated relationship between Buffy and Spike, and whether they would become a couple – something many viewers felt wouldn’t work. Another issue was Willow’s decision to resurrect Buffy, unaware she was in the afterlife. While this could have been the central focus of the season, the story shifted towards Buffy’s connection with Spike instead.

Okay, so this season wasn’t perfect, but there were definitely some highlights. For me, the best part was Willow’s descent into darkness. When Tara was killed, it just completely broke her, and watching her spiral out of control was genuinely gripping TV. It was a really emotional arc, and honestly, it reminded me that even the weaker Buffy seasons can have these amazing, redeeming moments. And let’s not forget, this is the season we got “One More Time With Feeling” – a musical episode that’s still talked about today!

4) Season 1

When Buffy the Vampire Slayer first aired, its first season immediately captivated audiences. The show was remarkable because the actors seemed perfectly suited to their roles right from the beginning, allowing it to quickly gain popularity. The cast, including Sarah Michelle Gellar, David Boreanaz, Alyson Hannigan, and Nicholas Brendon, were all wonderfully developed characters, and their performances made the show a fan favorite.

While a good start overall, the first season wasn’t quite as strong as later ones because the quality of the episodes varied. It had some fantastic highlights, like introducing the character Angel and showcasing exciting battles with vampires and demons. But it also included a few weaker episodes, such as “I Robot… You, Jane” and “Teacher’s Pet.” Considering it was the show’s beginning, it was a pretty solid foundation.

3) Season 5

Season 5 of Buffy the Vampire Slayer had a major flaw: the sudden appearance of Dawn, a new character presented as if she’d been part of the group all along. A lot of the season felt bogged down by constant arguments between Buffy and Dawn. Despite this, the season also included a standout episode, “The Body,” which powerfully depicted Joyce’s death and Buffy’s struggle with grief.

Buffy’s death at the end of one season felt like a fitting conclusion – the show could have ended with the idea of her finding peace in the afterlife. Interestingly, when Willow brought her back in a later season, Buffy confirmed she had been in a Heaven-like place. That season also featured a fantastic villain, Glory, and had so many strong episodes that it would have been a perfect ending to the series.

2) Season 2

If you’re an Angel fan, many consider Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season 2 to be the best. It features the peak of Buffy and Angel’s romance, but also marks a turning point where Angel struggles with his darker impulses. David Boreanaz brilliantly portrays both sides of the character – the soulful vampire and the ruthless killer – showcasing his impressive range as an actor.

The season featured powerful moments, like the heartbreaking loss of Jenny Calendar and Buffy’s difficult decision to kill Angel to prevent the end of the world. It also introduced the memorable duo of Spike and Drusilla, who added excitement to every episode. With Angel as a major villain, it was a truly outstanding season of television.

1) Season 3

Many fans agree that season three of Buffy the Vampire Slayer is the show’s best, and by a significant margin. Everything just seemed to work perfectly that year. The introduction of Faith as a rival Slayer instantly energized the show, even though Buffy wasn’t actually gone. Plus, Angel returned from the dead, which complicated things with Buffy and ultimately led to his departure to star in his own series.

The Mayor was the main villain, and the episodes surrounding Graduation Day are considered some of the show’s best. The entire series built towards the characters finishing high school, and the storylines perfectly came together as they prepared to graduate and start their adult lives. Plus, this season included the fantastic ‘Elseworlds’ episode where Willow and Xander temporarily became vampires.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/feature/buffys-greatest-episode-shows-why-1-character-shouldnt-return-for-the-reboot/embed/#

Read More

2026-01-05 23:13