Every Spider-man Love Interest, Ranked

Peter Parker, famously known as Spider-Man, always seems to struggle to catch a break. Between school, his job, and constantly rescuing New York City from villains, his love life always suffers. He’s incredibly capable, but maintaining a healthy relationship proves surprisingly difficult.

However, it’s important to remember that each romantic interest plays a role in the overall story. They aren’t simply there as someone for Peter to rescue, though that happens frequently. These relationships usually allow the writers to delve into Peter’s character – specifically, how he tries (and often fails) to juggle his personal life with the demands of being Spider-Man.

10. Carlie Cooper

Carlie was intended to be a stable and sensible partner for Peter Parker. As a smart and ethical forensic scientist with the NYPD, she seemed capable of understanding his life as both Peter and Spider-Man. She genuinely cared for him and made an effort to keep her work separate from their relationship, offering a calmer dynamic than his past romances.

The main issue was that Carlie and Peter never felt like a truly convincing couple to readers. Carlie worked better as a friend and teammate than a love interest. While learning Peter was Spider-Man did create some emotional depth, it also sped up their breakup. Her leaving the story after the Superior Spider-Man arc highlighted that she was more suited to a supporting role than a long-term relationship.

9. Debra Whitman

Debra was a kind, gentle, and delicate person. She reminded Peter of a time when he was still figuring out his life and what he wanted. Their relationship in the late 1970s and early 1980s was sadly marked by Peter leading a double life, which caused Debra increasing worry and emotional distress.

Debra’s story highlighted the challenges of being close to Spider-Man. She struggled with keeping his secret, and Peter deeply felt her pain when she couldn’t handle it anymore. Ultimately, she needed to step away to protect her own well-being, demonstrating how damaging Peter’s double life could be to those who cared about him.

8. Liz Allan

Liz was Peter’s first high school crush and represented his initial self-consciousness. Initially, she was a popular girl who didn’t pay much attention to him. But after Gwen’s death and Flash learning a lesson in humility, they developed a genuine connection. Liz grew up, and Peter’s teenage crush blossomed into a strong friendship.

After she married Harry Osborn, her life became forever linked to the world of Spider-Man. She blames Peter for the hardships her family faced, believing his involvement with Spider-Man caused them all.

7. Betty Brant

Peter Parker’s first serious girlfriend, Betty Brant, met him at a difficult time in his life when he was struggling emotionally. Though she was very loyal and believed in his good nature, she couldn’t cope with his secretive life and the risks it involved. Their relationship, shown in the early issues of The Amazing Spider-Man, was marked by stress and regret, especially after her brother died.

Betty continued to appear in Peter’s life, demonstrating how old feelings and fond memories can stay with us even after a relationship ends. Their eventual friendship highlights how both of them matured and moved forward, despite knowing their romantic connection wouldn’t last.

6. Felicia Hardy (Black Cat)

As a movie fan, I always found Felicia Hardy, Black Cat, so compelling. She just exploded onto the scene, bringing this wild energy and a really intense, self-centered passion. Honestly, she was more into Spider-Man as a persona than Peter Parker as a person, and that made their relationship incredibly messy but also super captivating. They clicked instantly because she lived for the thrill just as much as he did, but it was all about attraction, not building something stable. It was magnetic, but you knew it couldn’t last – she couldn’t get on board with his whole ‘doing the right thing’ thing, and he could never fully let his guard down around her. Still, she’s one of his most memorable loves because she made him face the parts of himself that others didn’t – the part that genuinely loves being Spider-Man, the adrenaline, the danger, all of it.

5. Michelle Gonzales

Michelle was a lively but somewhat harsh person, and she briefly became someone Peter was romantically interested in during a turbulent period for him. She was a disorganized roommate, and her presence highlighted the chaos Peter was experiencing after a particularly difficult time in his life.

Michelle wasn’t a typical romance story, but her connection with Peter was surprisingly unpredictable. Her straightforward personality showed that Peter could connect with someone who challenged him, not just someone who simply admired him. Though their relationship didn’t last long, it was definitely memorable.

4. Silver Sable

Silver Sable embodies a more complex and morally ambiguous side of Peter Parker’s life. As the leader of a mercenary group, she’s motivated by both profit and a personal code of ethics, putting her in the same high-stakes world as Spider-Man. Their connection develops through a shared respect and a bond forged in battle. While her professional approach often conflicted with Peter’s strong moral compass, she recognized his ability to look beyond her work as a mercenary. And they’ve even shared a kiss, adding another layer to their dynamic.

3. Mary Jane Watson

Mary Jane is central to Spider-Man’s emotional journey. Her strength and humor perfectly complemented Peter Parker. When she revealed she’d always known his secret identity, it proved she was much more than just a girlfriend.

Despite facing countless obstacles – including characters dying, storylines being restarted, and even their marriage being forgotten – this couple remains a fan favorite. Even when writers try to keep them apart, the deep connection between them always feels real.

2. Gwen Stacy

Gwen Stacy was Peter Parker’s first great love, a bright spot in his life. She was intelligent, compassionate, and resilient, representing everything positive that gave him strength in a difficult world. Her death in Amazing Spider-Man #121 profoundly impacted Peter’s life and changed the way superhero stories were told.

Gwen embodies lost innocence. Her death marked the end of a hopeful period for Spider-Man and established a pattern of tragedy shaping heroes. Every relationship Peter Parker had after Gwen was colored by her loss. She’s remembered as a symbol of tragic, perfect love – a love that remained untainted because it ended too soon.

1. Mary Jane Watson (Post- “One More Day” Interpretation)

After their separation, Mary Jane’s character development is particularly interesting. She returns to Peter’s life as a self-reliant woman determined to forge her own identity, separate from being known just as Spider-Man’s girlfriend. Her resilience, wit, and understanding of herself demonstrate she’s still his equal, even without being married.

This period in the comics made Mary Jane Watson one of Marvel’s most complex and well-developed female characters. She has a deep understanding of Peter Parker, yet remains independent. Even with changes to the storyline over time, fans still see her as Peter’s true love because their bond isn’t based on neediness, but on a strong, lasting loyalty that endures through every version of their story.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/list/7-great-dc-villains-who-carried-iconic-weapons/embed/#

2026-01-30 20:19