Fantastic Four Director Fired for Wanting It More Like the Comics (& He Was Right)

As a cinephile looking back on Hollywood’s past, I must share an intriguing tidbit about the 2005 adaptation of “Fantastic Four“. The original director’s dismissal from the project will leave you stunned, and it turns out that this decision has proven to be regrettable 20 years later.

Before Marvel Studios launched the Marvel Cinematic Universe with “Iron Man” in 2008, 20th Century Fox introduced Marvel’s First Family to live-action films, with Tim Story (director of “Barbershop” and “Ride Along”) at the helm. Interestingly enough, Story wasn’t always set to direct “Fantastic Four”. In fact, he was the sixth director attached to the project – five other directors had been considered before him!

The first director has now come forward to share his insights on the production, offering a rare glimpse into the early days of Marvel’s live-action adaptation.

Chris Columbus shared during the Fade to Black podcast (as reported by Variety) that he found himself in an unusual predicament regarding the Fantastic Four. “I had developed a script, multiple writers were involved,” he explained. “The studio was preparing to produce the film, and I was serving as the producer. I proposed my ideas to the director, suggesting that the visual concepts should reflect the style of Jack Kirby, the creator of Fantastic Four, and the Silver Age of Marvel. After voicing these suggestions, I was summoned back home, only to receive a call from the head of 20th Century Fox shortly after, informing me that I had been let go and was considered too opinionated.

Why Chris Columbus Was Right About 2005’s Fantastic Four

Chris Columbus’ remarks imply that he believed the Fantastic Four should closely resemble their comic book counterparts in their initial Fox film. However, this notion was met with disagreement by the executives at Fox, who opted for a distinctly different approach. Instead of staying true to Jack Kirby’s original 1961 Marvel Comics portrayal, they made several alterations: the characters wore darker suits, the Thing was much smaller, and the first fight pitted them against Doctor Doom (Julian McMahon). In retrospect, Columbus seems to have been correct in his vision.

2025’s film titled “The Fantastic Four: First Steps” has solidified director Tim Columbus’ belief that the Fantastic Four thrive in live-action adaptations when they are more closely tied to their original comic book origins. Marvel Studios and director Matt Shakman have outfitted the characters with costumes reminiscent of the comics, set them in a lively, colorful world with a retro-future aesthetic, and initially faced them with minor villains before confronting Galactus (Ralph Ineson) and the Silver Surfer (Julia Garner). The film “First Steps” has since become the most acclaimed and widely viewed “Fantastic Four” movie to date, affirming Columbus’ theory.

Columbus, known for notable movies like “Home Alone”, “Mrs. Doubtfire”, and the initial two “Harry Potter” films, seemed deserving of more trust from Fox. His take on “Fantastic Four”, closer to Jack Kirby’s original designs and likely more comic-accurate than Tim Story’s, might have been a significant success. Regrettably, we can only speculate about this possibility. However, the 2025 reboot of “The Fantastic Four: First Steps” has finally delivered what fans have longed for – an authentic live-action representation of the team for years.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/fantastic-four-first-steps-characters-most-powerful-ranked/embed/#

Read More

2025-08-28 17:10