Gotham City Sirens #1 Review: The Girls Are Back in Town

Gotham City Sirens #1 Review: The Girls Are Back in Town

As a long-time fan of DC Comics and Gotham City Sirens, I must say that this new miniseries is a delightful addition to the roster. Having grown up reading Harley Quinn, Poison Ivy, and Catwoman’s escapades, I can confidently say that Leah Williams has captured their essence perfectly. The story is fast-paced, energetic, and true to the characters, much like a rollercoaster ride through Gotham City.


In DC Comics lore, the Gotham City Sirens, consisting of Harley Quinn, Poison Ivy, and Catwoman, have a rich history of straddling the fine line between good and evil. Unlike the Birds of Prey, these three major female villains of Gotham aren’t shy about doing whatever it takes to either save lives or make a significant profit. In their latest four-issue miniseries, the Sirens find themselves up against an absurd and almost unimaginable danger to Gotham, instigated by a face that is distressingly familiar. Have the Sirens succeeded in their mission this time, or have they stumbled at the last hurdle?

The story kicks off when the antagonist, White Rabbit, flees from a group of shirtless cowboys and their herd of unsavory bison, causing chaos in Gotham City. Similar to other ‘Sirens’ series, each character – Harley, Ivy, and Selina Kyle – is initially preoccupied with their individual tasks: Harley is taking care of her hyenas, Ivy is experimenting with a strange concoction called “XO Punch” for her carnivorous plants, while Selina investigates the mystery head-on. It’s only when circumstances align that they reunite. In the end, it’s discovered that Joker’s new accomplice, Punchline, has a secret plot in motion.

As a gamer, let me tell you, Leah Williams nailed the Sirens’ personalities in this latest Gotham City Sirens story. Harley Quinn is like a pop of bubbly chaos one moment, then a menacing threat the next, just like her character. Poison Ivy is all about intelligence and restraint, while Selina has a commanding attitude that keeps her teammates on their toes. It’s like watching an on-again, off-again dance between them.

Gotham City Sirens #1 Review: The Girls Are Back in Town

In this comic, Punchline has traditionally been a challenging character for me due to her constant comparison with Harley Quinn. However, in this particular issue, her unique plan to unite the Sirens stands out significantly. Although she doesn’t appear much throughout the story, save for the last pages, it is clear that her role here is pivotal. The comic itself may not be packed with details, but its focus on characters like Harley, Ivy, Selina, and Punchline contributes to its overall strength, making it more impactful in the process.

Absolutely, a writer doesn’t work in isolation when it comes to their artistic duties. In this issue, Matteo Lolli and Triona Farrell add an electrifying energy that jumps out from the pages. The scenery and colors are vividly portrayed, making each Siren distinct while maintaining a familiar Gotham feel. At the same time, the trio’s identities are seamlessly incorporated into their roles. This debut is both flashy and substantive, with the art perfectly complementing the narrative. While it builds on what has been successful in the past, it doesn’t shy away from exploring new territories.

The newest interpretation of Gotham City Sirens enhances the strengths of its three captivating villainesses without fundamentally altering their roles. The revamped Gotham City Sirens carries an upbeat, lively tone that might necessitate a few adjustments to ensure a top-notch performance, but it presents a promising foundation for this new ensemble of anti-heroines.

Published by DC Comics

On August 7, 2024

Written by Leah Williams

Art by Matteo Lolli

Colors by Triona Farrell

Letters by Hassan Otsman-Elhaou

Cover by Terry Dodson with Rachel Dodson

Read More

2024-08-07 16:40