How Many Times Has DC Beaten Marvel at the Summer Box Office?

by

It’s evident now that Superman’s movie, on track to earn around $360-$375 million domestically, will undoubtedly be the top-grossing superhero film of summer 2025 at the box office. Even facing off against two Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) movies and virtually all other summer 2025 releases except for Lilo & Stitch, Superman is expected to come out on top. Given its potential for success, this James Gunn-directed effort has surpassed expectations, proving it’s not just another unnecessary reboot in the eyes of moviegoers.

This implies that it’s unusual for a DC Comics film to earn more than a Marvel movie during the summer box office season. However, it’s worth noting that DC has managed to snatch the top spot in the box office on several remarkable instances, even though Marvel is typically the dominant force during this hot period.

The Earliest DC Summertime Box Office Champions

For a long time, live-action comic book movies were scarce, with only the original Superman and Batman films being exceptions. Consequently, summer movie seasons typically featured either a Marvel or DC production, but not both simultaneously. This pattern was broken in the 21st century when X-Men and Spider-Man franchises became blockbusters at the box office. The first direct competition between these labels occurred in 2004, as Spider-Man 2 significantly outperformed Catwoman.

In the summer of 2005, Christopher Nolan’s film “Batman Begins” significantly outperformed “Fantastic Four” at both the U.S. and global box office, giving DC a significant win over Marvel in terms of box office earnings. This trend continued three years later when “The Dark Knight” outearned both “Iron Man” and “The Incredible Hulk”. In fact, if you were to add up the domestic earnings of those first two Marvel Cinematic Universe movies, they still wouldn’t match the lifetime North American gross of “The Dark Knight”.

For quite some time, I found myself cheering as DC reigned supreme at the summer box office, despite formidable Marvel competition. However, that was about to change, marking the end of DC’s dominance during the summer months. The underwhelming performance of films like “Jonah Hex” and “Green Lantern,” even against powerhouses like “Iron Man 2” in 2010, foreshadowed a shift in the balance of power.

As the Marvel Cinematic Universe continued to grow in popularity, it became clear that DC’s subsequent releases, such as “Suicide Squad,” would struggle to outperform their Marvel counterparts. Warner Bros. and DC found themselves consistently taking the silver medal in this box office rivalry, a stark contrast to the days when Michael Keaton’s Batman movies reigned supreme across all summer films.

A Wonder-ful Box Office Upset for DC

2017 marked a remarkable summer for me as a film enthusiast, with the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) releasing blockbusters one after another, a rare occurrence in their history that happened just three times before. Among these, “Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2” and “Spider-Man: Homecoming” were standout hits, each earning over $330 million at North American box offices alone. However, they didn’t hold the top spot for superhero movie earnings that year. That honor went to “Wonder Woman,” a film that surpassed all expectations and grossed an impressive $400+ million.

This haul significantly surpassed the North American earnings of previous DC Extended Universe films such as “Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice” and most Marvel Cinematic Universe movies (except for the Avengers series) that were released prior to it. In fact, it set a new record for Warner Bros., becoming their highest-grossing non-Dark Knight DC film in North America. Moreover, its financial success was all the more noteworthy considering it was released between two successful Marvel movies, further highlighting its impressive box office performance.

During the latter part of the 2010s decade, Warner Bros. chose to debut DCEU films such as “Shazam!” and “Aquaman” at times other than summer blockbuster seasons. This decision postponed any potential conflicts between Marvel and DC until summer 2021, when “The Suicide Squad” faced competition from “Black Widow”. Although the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) saw unprecedented success in the 2010s following the release of “The Avengers” in 2012, it has been less financially robust in the 2020s.

Superman now has the opportunity to mirror the success of the initial two Batman films and Wonder Woman by being a DC Comics movie that outperforms Marvel at the summer box office – an unusual feat. This accomplishment underscores the strong connection audiences have formed with Superman, as well as the somewhat tarnished image the Marvel Cinematic Universe currently holds among the public.

Superman is now playing in theaters. Wonder Woman is now streaming on HBO Max.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/superman-just-crossed-a-major-box-office-milestone-and-set-a-dc-record/embed/#

Read More

2025-08-05 14:41