I’m Calling It Now, 2026 Will be the Peak of Cozy Game Spinoffs (And I Don’t Mean Just Pokemon’s)

by

Cozy games have become really popular lately, even though there’s still debate about exactly what makes a game ‘cozy.’ Games like *Stardew Valley* and *Disney Dreamlight Valley* have built huge followings, with players spending lots of time and money on them. This has caught the attention of major game developers, leading to more relaxed spin-offs from well-known franchises. While these spin-offs have had varying degrees of success, there are many more planned for 2026. However, if these new games don’t perform as well as previous cozy titles, this surge of relaxed installments in big franchises might not last.

2024 saw the release of *Bandle Tale*, a relaxing spin-off from *League of Legends*. While it received decent reviews, it didn’t become hugely popular. This year brought *Tales of the Shire*, a cozy *Lord of the Rings* game that proved controversial. Despite being enjoyed by many cozy game fans, including myself, it received mixed reactions and quickly lost momentum. If upcoming spin-off games in 2026 similarly miss the mark on what makes a truly engaging and lasting cozy experience, I believe this trend may be coming to an end.

Everyone Wants a Slice of the Cozy Gaming Pie, But It’s Not So Simple

More and more people are looking for relaxing and low-pressure games. Some, like fans of *The Sims 4* and *Disney Dreamlight Valley*, focus on these types of games entirely. Others who enjoy a variety of games are increasingly seeking them out as a way to de-stress and escape daily life. This growing popularity means game developers and companies are eager to create their own relaxing games. However, it’s proving more challenging than expected to design a truly good and calming gaming experience.

Games like *Stardew Valley* often involve doing the same things over and over, but they’re engaging because there’s a lot to discover and enjoy. Players are willing to put in the effort, but the gameplay needs to feel rewarding. Story is also important. *Tales of the Shire* was popular for a short time, but its brief and conclusive storyline was a factor in its decline. While players appreciate a good story, games with definitive endings struggle to retain an audience. Creating a successful cozy game requires a delicate balance, and some recent releases haven’t quite gotten it right.

Games such as *Tales of the Shire* often have very defined endings, which can make continuing to play afterward feel less appealing. *Stardew Valley* is different – it has a story, but the world is rich with things to discover, so it doesn’t feel like there’s a true ending. Creating this kind of endlessly engaging and satisfying experience isn’t easy, and we’ve seen a lot of cozy games fall short this year. Titles like *Pixelshire* launched with many problems, and others, like *Sugardew Island*, offered only a superficial farming experience. As a result, players who enjoy cozy games are being extra careful before buying new releases.

I Have High Hopes For These Games, But Cozy Gamers Have Been Burned Before

2026 is shaping up to be a great year for relaxing games set in worlds we already know and love. We’re finally getting a life simulation game in the Pokémon universe with *Pokémon Pokopia*, and the creators of *Palworld* are following that trend with *Palfarm*, which is likely to release next year. Plus, *Genshin Impact*’s developer, HoYoverse, just announced their own cozy life sim, *Petit Island*, and Gameloft is working on a relaxing *Dungeons & Dragons* game. It looks like 2026 could deliver some charming experiences from well-known developers, but I do have some reservations.

I’ve shared my initial thoughts on the *Pokopia* trailer, and while I know many cozy game fans are looking forward to it, it’s not quite the Pokemon experience I was hoping for. Right now, it feels like it might repeat a mistake made by other cozy spin-offs: taking ideas from popular games without really understanding what makes those games so enjoyable. I’m hoping to be surprised by future reveals, but currently, it appears to be a copy of *Minecraft* and *Animal Crossing*, just with a Pokemon theme.

We haven’t gotten a good look at *Palfarm* yet. Although it looks beautiful visually and plays well, it’s uncertain whether it will bring anything new to the farming simulator genre or simply follow familiar patterns. That could be a success, or it could fall flat—it all comes down to how well it’s made. As for the cozy game based on *Dungeons & Dragons*, we haven’t heard much news since its announcement in 2024. Gameloft had a hit with *Disney Dreamlight Valley*, but the world of *D&D* doesn’t naturally lend itself to the same easy, comforting feel as Disney stories.

I’m going into this expecting to be disappointed, honestly. I’m a huge fan of Pokémon, Dungeons & Dragons, and I’ve spent way too much time playing Genshin Impact! But a lot of the recent, more relaxed games based on these popular series feel like they’re just trading on the name recognition, instead of focusing on what really makes a cozy game fun. I’m just not very hopeful that these new releases will truly satisfy fans of either the original franchises or the cozy gaming genre.

Whether these games succeed or fail will probably determine if other popular franchises try making similar, relaxed spin-offs. If they’re popular with fans and sell well, we might see even more of these types of games. However, I believe if they don’t do as well as hoped, 2026 will likely be the height of this trend for calmer, more laid-back games based on existing properties.

What are your thoughts on the new, more relaxed spin-offs? Share your opinion in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/gaming/news/im-more-worried-than-ever-that-witchbrook-isnt-releasing-in-2025/embed/#

Read More

2025-10-07 19:42