Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

As I delve into the potential candidates for the SEC chair role, I find myself particularly intrigued by the experiences and backgrounds of these individuals.


On the 17th of April, 2021, Joe Biden, the U.S. President, named Gary Gensler as the head of the Securities and Exchange Commission. His tenure is scheduled to end on January 5, 2026.

Yet, Gensler’s hands-on approach in regulating the U.S. cryptocurrency sector, along with the absence of definitive regulatory rules, could potentially undermine his standing.

If re-elected, former President and Republican nominee Donald Trump has publicly announced that he plans to dismiss Gary Gensler from his position on his very first day in office, according to statements made at the 2024 Bitcoin Conference in Nashville.

It’s possible for the U.S. President to remove Gensler from his position, but it won’t be an easy process. Trump would need to provide a valid reason for termination, such as negligence, inefficiency, or misconduct. Determining this cause, going through legal reviews, and handling administrative transitions could take up to a year or more.

If Trump wins, it’s possible that Gensler might resign, but ultimately that choice is his own. Either way, Trump may find himself working alongside Gensler for some time before a new person takes over.

On the Democratic side, Vice President and potential presidential nominee Kamala Harris has not explicitly declared her stance regarding the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) chair position. However, there are indications suggesting a potential leadership transition, implying that a change in regulatory policy could be on the horizon.

Billionaire investor Mark Cuban, who claims to have close connections with Harris’ team, told CryptoMoon that Harris favors “bright-line regulations” and opposes “regulation via litigation.” He believes Harris would likely remove Gensler as SEC chair.

“I think the obvious issue is Gensler, and my guess is that, based on the lack of public support for him, that he is gone.”

The likely replacement for Gensler is yet to be determined, as Republicans tend to support a more innovation-friendly, less regulatory stance, whereas Democrats typically prefer stricter supervision and consumer safeguards.

The meeting is expected to shape the direction of cryptocurrency regulations moving forward. Many within the industry are eagerly awaiting to learn about the new chairman’s key focus areas.

This leaves the question: Who will succeed Gensler, and how will they approach the crypto industry?

Hester Peirce: The “Crypto Mom” the industry wants

It’s suggested that Hester Peirce could be a strong candidate to replace Gensler in his position. Given President Trump’s supportive attitude towards cryptocurrency, Peirce’s nomination as SEC chair could signal a more extensive, pro-crypto regulatory strategy.

Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

At George Mason University, Peirce conducted research on financial market regulations, while also providing counsel to the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Development.

Apart from her role, she was additionally a legal representative within the Securities and Exchange Commission’s Division of Investment Management. Previously, she had served as an associate at the law firm WilmerHale.

After receiving a nomination as an SEC commissioner from Former President Barack Obama in 2018, Allison Peirce ultimately secured her position at the SEC.

Among crypto enthusiasts, Pierce is often referred to as the “Crypto Champion” due to her widespread popularity.

She frequently voices disapproval towards Gensler’s assertive stance on the cryptocurrency sector. In a dissenting statement on a crypto case dated September 16th, Peirce and Commissioner Mark Uyeda expressed their disagreement.

“Leaving crypto to be addressed in an endless series of misguided and overreaching cases has been and continues to be a consequential mistake.”

Due to her vocal support for the industry and her criticisms towards the commission’s approaches, there is a growing expectation among cryptocurrency enthusiasts that Trump might appoint her to replace Gensler.

Recent: Bitcoin scammers impersonate police, Sunray Finance $2.7M drain: Crypto-Sec

It seems quite doubtful that she will take on the role of SEC Chair, given that she has openly expressed her intention to leave the commission once her term finishes in 2025.

Chris Giancarlo: “Crypto Dad” of Bitcoin futures

J. Christopher Giancarlo, a lawyer and ex-head of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), is affectionately known as “Crypto Dad” because of his widespread admiration within the cryptocurrency sector.

In the course of my research and subsequent work, I earned the moniker “CryptoDad” upon penning the book titled “CryptoDad: The Struggle for the Future of Currency“. As per reports by Politico, K Street – a symbolic representation of influential American industry lobbying firms – views me as a possible contender for the position of SEC chair.

Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

In his time at the Commodity Futures Trading Commission under the Trump presidency, he gave the green light for Bitcoin (BTC) futures deals. This crucial move paved the way for potential future approval of Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs), traded on a spot basis.

Giancarlo presently serves as a senior counsel and co-chair for Willkie Farr and Gallagher’s digital assets department, all while fulfilling multiple responsibilities in diverse organizations. He is the creator and leader of The Digital Dollar Project, an endeavor that investigates strategies to make the U.S. dollar more resilient for future challenges.

He holds key roles such as being on the board or an advisor for entities like the American Financial Exchange, the Chamber of Digital Commerce, and Nomura Holdings – all significant players in the finance and digital asset industries.

Chris Brummer: The peaceful option for the Democrats

If Harris were to become the next U.S. President, Chris Brummer might well emerge as a notable contender for a role in her administration.

Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

Brummer has had multiple connections to the Democratic Party. Obama put him forward for the position of leading the CFTC in 2016, but Trump later withdrew his nomination. However, under President Biden’s administration, he emerged as a strong candidate for the CFTC chair. Additionally, Brummer was part of the financial regulation transition team for the Biden administration, focusing on the Treasury department.

Anderson P.C., a boutique law firm, thinks that this prospective appointee at the SEC might indicate a more equitable strategy for regulating cryptocurrencies, emphasizing the development of transparent rules without hindering progress and creativity in the field.

As a seasoned crypto investor, I’ve had my fair share of dealing with regulatory complexities. On the 16th of May, I took the initiative to establish Bluprynt, a company dedicated to ensuring regulatory compliance for cryptocurrency firms. Our primary focus is on aligning white papers with the intricate crypto regulations set by the European Union.

As a cryptocurrency investor, I’ve been privy to some insights about Brummer. From what I’ve gathered, he believes himself to be more suited for the role than Gary Gensler. Furthermore, it’s been suggested that if Brummer were to join the Harris campaign, it could potentially be the most significant gesture of goodwill towards the crypto community.

Paul Atkins: SEC commissioner with ties to Bush and Trump

As reported by CNBC, Paul Atkins, who served as an SEC commissioner during the presidency of George W. Bush, is being considered as a possible nominee for the role of SEC chairman within the circle of President Trump.

Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

During his tenure as a Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) commissioner under the Bush administration, he established a reputation for resisting steep penalties against companies found guilty of breaking securities laws. He was also critical of the Dodd-Frank Act, a piece of legislation that bolstered federal regulatory power following the 2008 financial crisis.

Later on, Atkins assumed a crucial position within Trump’s 2016 transition team, significantly influencing the lax financial regulations adopted by the previous president.

Presently, Atkins serves as head of Patomak Global Partners, a consultancy company he established in 2009. Starting from 2017, he has additionally taken up the role of co-chair for the Token Alliance, an organization that champions the interests of the digital asset and blockchain sector.

Erica Williams: Balanced candidate for Harris

As a seasoned crypto investor, I can share that my background includes working hand-in-hand with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Currently, Erica Williams, who holds the position of chair at the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), brings similar experience to the table.

Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

Williams has occupied important positions such as serving as deputy chief of staff for three Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) chairpersons, acting as special assistant and associate counsel on financial and economic matters within the Obama administration, and previously being a litigation partner at Kirkland & Ellis prior to joining the board.

Under the guidance of PCAOB, the board levied a historic $25-million penalty on KPMG Netherlands due to academic dishonesty in their internal training, and also imposed a $900,000 fine for quality control infractions at a Colombian branch of Deloitte. Collectively, these penalties amounted to over $20 million in fines for 2023.

During her time in office, although she didn’t frequently discuss crypto, the PCAOB created a specialized inspection team to address rising audit risks, which encompassed those related to cryptocurrencies as well.

In November, Williams defended herself against accusations of missing signs of trouble at FTX prior to its fall in late 2022. She emphasized during a conference that the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board’s authority only extends to auditing public companies and broker-dealers, not private ones like FTX.

An internal source informed Unchained that Williams holds a forward-thinking perspective on financial regulations, one that might encourage cryptocurrency legislation, all while vigilantly targeting malicious players within the cryptocurrency sector.

Heath Tarbert: The active CFTC chair

Based on reports from CNBC, Heath Tarbert’s tenure as the head of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) from 2019 to January 2021 could make him a strong contender for the position of head at the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). During his time at the CFTC, he oversaw several notable achievements, such as handling more cases in a single fiscal year than any previous leader.

Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

Tarbert boasts a wide range of experience within the federal administration, having served in roles at the White House, the Department of Justice, and the Treasury Department.

For a more conversational rephrasing: He’s been involved in some debates due to the quick transition – just 27 days after leaving the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) – where he was employed as the chief legal officer at Citadel Securities. This move from public service to private work has led to accusations of a “revolving door” scenario, which is often criticized for its perceived conflicts of interest.

Presently, Circle’s top legal advisor and lead in corporate matters, Tarbert, works for a company specializing in payments technology known as Circle. This firm oversees the digital currency USD Coin (USDC), which maintains its value tied to the U.S. dollar.

Robert Stebbins: The adviser close to Trump’s SEC chair

Based on reports from Politico, there’s speculation that Robert Stebbins could be a possible pick for the position of SEC Chair.

Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

At present, Stebbins is spearheading the corporate governance department at Willkie Farr & Gallagher. He’s been associated with this firm since 1993, taking a break between 2017 and his tenure as the top legal official at the Securities and Exchange Commission.

During his time as the general counsel at the SEC, Stebbins was instrumental in providing guidance on more than 85 rules, numerous staff orders, interpretive releases, and oversaw approximately 2,750 enforcement actions, according to Willkie. He aided Jay Clayton, who became the SEC chair under Trump and was once Stebbins’ law school classmate, in forming his team when Clayton took office in 2017.

At Willkie, Stebbins has collaborated with Morgan Stanley on various crucial deals, such as Horizon Therapeutics’ $27.8-billion takeover by Amgen and the proposed union between Allergan and Pfizer. Additionally, he played a role in Fiat’s attempt to secure a significant share of Chrysler during the early 2010s.

Dan Gallagher: The Federal Reserve critic

Dan Gallagher, the top lawyer for financial trading company Robinhood, has had dealings with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for quite some time. He served as a Republican commissioner within the SEC during the Obama administration from 2011 to 2015, and prior to that, he held several positions within the agency.

Meet the pro-crypto contenders who could replace SEC chief Gary Gensler

In the late 2000s, as a crypto investor looking back, I find myself reflecting on my tenure at the SEC’s Division of Trading and Markets. During that tumultuous period, I stood alongside the commission during the liquidation of Lehman Brothers and faced numerous hurdles in navigating through the financial crisis.

Recent: Trump makes big promises about crypto in US — But can he deliver?

The confirmation of Gallagher might encounter some challenges. Traditionally, Democrats are cautious about appointing industry leaders to regulatory positions, and Robinhood’s previous disputes – for instance, their choice to halt GameStop share trading during the meme stock mania in 2021 – could potentially make his nomination more difficult.

It’s unclear if Gallagher would consider switching from Robinhood to the SEC position. He joined their board back in October 2019 and assumed the chief legal officer role in May 2020. In a conversation with Politico, he expressed his satisfaction with his current position and feels privileged to be part of the discussions regarding the next SEC chair.

Read More

2024-11-05 11:45