Michelle Trachtenberg’s Boyfriend Breaks Silence on Her Death

by

Michelle Trachtenberg’s boyfriend Jay Cohen is speaking out about his grief journey.

Following the death of the former “Gossip Girl” cast member in February at the age of 39, her partner expressed gratitude to their close friends for their comfort during his period of grief, while also sharing how he has been managing to stay optimistic.

He expressed his heartfelt appreciation to each one of you who make up my life, for the shared happiness, support during hardships, and helping me heal from sorrow and distress. In a post on July 10th, he wrote this on his private Instagram page, suggesting many of you can relate to these feelings.

In his recent post, Jay, a partner at Gersh Talent Agency, didn’t explicitly name his late companion but did hint at sharing more details about an actress he referred to as “one day soon.” Furthermore, he expressed that the actress, Michelle, was deeply admired and cherished by numerous individuals.

Michelle, who passed away due to diabetes-related complications as confirmed by the New York City Medical Examiner’s Office, generally maintained a private life regarding her relationship with Jay. However, mere weeks before her demise, she gave a touching peek into their romance.

On Instagram’s February 14th post, she published a picture showing her and Jay dressed as Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, with the accompanying message: “Wishing a Happy Valentine’s Day to the one who lets me paint his face.

In March 2024, almost a year ago, the actress from “Harriet the Spy” shared the same picture on a platform to celebrate Jay’s birthday, saying, “Happy Birthday to the one who endures me @jaymcohen.

It appears that both individuals have gone through similar health challenges in their lives, as Jay’s post marked the 26th anniversary of his kidney transplant, which he received from an unselfish donor. Interestingly, Michelle had also received an organ transplant – a liver transplant before her demise, as reported by various sources.

After Michelle’s unfortunate demise, numerous of her associates paid touching tributes, even some of her co-stars from the “Gossip Girl” series. In May, Leighton Meester expressed her feelings about the sorrowful event, describing it as “devastating”.

As a devoted admirer, I would express it thusly: “She was an extraordinary, gifted individual, adored by all, and I had the privilege of knowing her. Her absence leaves us all with a profound sense of loss.

To see how other stars honored Michelle’s memory, read on.

Michelle, here’s what I have to say: In a post on her Instagram from February 27th, the actress formerly known as Buffy wrote, “Pay attention to me.” She continued, “Listen. I adore you. I have always loved you. The most challenging aspect of this world is just existing in it. I will be courageous. I will live… for you.

Expressing my deep sadness upon learning about Michelle’s demise, the actor from Buffy the Vampire Slayer shared on Instagram. She infused our Buffy set with warmth and kindness. My thoughts are with the family and friends of the dearly departed Michelle.

As a devoted fan, I can’t help but express my profound admiration for Michelle. In the hallowed halls of Gossip Girl, she stood out as extraordinary. The first time I saw her on set, she commanded attention effortlessly. She was an unstoppable force, radiating unapologetic wit and charisma that left us all in awe. Reminiscing about those years brings a smile to my face, despite the immense sadness of her passing. My heart goes out to you, Michelle. You will be deeply missed. Love always.

The Adventures of Pete & Pete alum wrote this about his former costar:

From our childhood, we’ve honed our ability to share laughter and play practical jokes on each other. What truly mattered was not just making an audience laugh, but finding humor in our interactions with one another. In essence, we were improvising comedy before it even had a name. She excelled at the clothespin game, targeting anyone she could reach.

In other words, he said, “One time, she became irritated with me when I caught my first bass on set, as I preferred not to socialize during lunch. She concealed the cable to prevent me from playing through the amplifier. I understood her signal clearly.

Danny referred to Michelle as a radiant beacon, an energetic spark, and a compassionate individual who dedicated significant resources in championing the causes of those who required more attention.

He remarked, “Michelle was an inspiring figure in her profession and to the broader community. Her absence will be felt deeply.

Today, I feel a deep sadness,” the former Buffy star posted on Instagram. “We’ve lost an extraordinary individual. Michelle was remarkably intelligent, uncontrollably funny, and incredibly gifted. Her life was cut far too short, leaving behind countless people who knew and cherished her.

James added, “I deeply sympathize with Michelle’s family, who are genuinely kind individuals experiencing an unimaginable grief. May we all afford them privacy as they navigate this challenging period of healing. Farewell, Michelle. Your absence is felt.

In a post on her Instagram story, the actress, previously known for her role as Faith in Buffy, expressed her sorrow. She was referring to someone young and tragic who passed away. May you find peace, dear slayer sister. Our thoughts are with MT’s family and friends during this difficult time.

On Instagram Story, the Underworld actress wrote, “Such a dreadful performance and outcome, I can’t help but feel sorrow for your mom. May you have a safe journey, dear friend.

On Instagram Stories, the former Gossip Girl star expressed that she was like an electric presence. Whenever she walked into a room, you could feel the atmosphere shift. She always gave her all in everything she did, laughing heartily at jokes, standing up to authority when needed, taking pride in her work, and being fiercely loyal to her friends. She was bold, unique, and unapologetically herself.

Blake too recollected Michelle’s “tempting caramel-scented lip gloss,” pointing out that the deceased celebrity would often use it as she enjoyed crafting a pleasant atmosphere for those around her.

Michelle was a compassionate and wonderful soul whom the world sadly parted ways with. I hope that both her significant contributions and her enormous heart will be fondly recalled by those fortunate enough to have felt her passion.

As a lifestyle expert, I’d express it this way in the first person: “Witnessing the untimely departure of someone so vibrant, radiant, and brimming with potential is never an easy sight to behold. It’s heart-wrenchingly painful, truly.

She went on to recognize the significant influence she’s had on her fans globally, stating that it would be unjust not to mention this fact. Her legacy will endure in her performances and her passion for storytelling, making it eternal.

The actress, who played Cordelia in the teen drama, concluded, “Rest easy, Michelle.”

A cast member from the show “Dawson’s Creek,” who previously collaborated with her on the series “Mercy,” recently posted an old video of her performing Nicki Minaj’s lyrics from Robin Thicke’s 2009 song “Shakin’ It for Daddy” during a car ride.

James referred to Michelle as a “natural powerhouse with untamed brilliance”: her raw ability transformed into intense brightness whenever directed, and she was both amusing and sharp-witted.

He mentioned that he enjoyed rapping alongside her since the car rides home were always interesting. To illustrate this, he went on to say, “One evening I managed to persuade her to let me record a usual trip through the Holland Tunnel to post on the early days of Twitter.” He concluded by saying, “This is how I’ll remember you, Michelle. May God bless you and your family. Wishing you all the best.

The 17 Again actress wrote of her onscreen daughter, “I will miss you, Michelle.”

The fashion designer expressed on Instagram Story, “My dear Michelle, you will always be deeply loved and sorely missed by many. Our cherished memories together will remain etched in my heart forever.

The Sex and the City alum wrote of her Ice Princess costar, “Rest in peace sweet Michelle.”

Clare, who portrayed Glory on Buffy, expressed on Instagram, “Farewell, dear one. A gifted and compassionate spirit taken far before its time. Now you can soar freely.

In a post on Instagram, the former Gossip Girl star expressed that when he first encountered this woman seventeen years ago, he felt they would become friends. He described her as intelligent, spunky, brave yet tender, hilarious, and fiery. In other words, she was absolutely amazing.

She stood by my side, offering her support no matter the circumstances, be it right or wrong,” she went on. “Every day I’ll miss you, my dear…I believe we really connected, and I am immensely thankful to have had a friend as exceptional as you in my life for such a prolonged period.

She additionally sent a note to Michelle, saying, “You were an exceptional friend to me, something uncommon in today’s world. It’s hard to accept that I won’t hear your voice anymore…I hope you’re causing a stir in heaven on our behalf.

The actor who gained fame on Nickelodeon expressed about another alumnus, “The first Nickelodeon movie star has left us. She was not only a colleague but also my friend. Let this be a reminder to take care of those around you.

In simpler terms, Michelle’s co-star in “Harriet the Spy” shared with “Us Weekly” that it was heartbreaking for him because he cared deeply for her. He mentioned that she had a tough time in recent years and expressed his regret that he couldn’t provide more support.

The actress, who portrayed Anya on Buffy, expressed her apologies for the untimely demise of her former co-star. She stated that our Buffy family suffered a great loss today as we bid farewell to one of our own. Rest in peace, dear Mish Mish. You were deeply cherished.

In an Instagram post, the actor from Orange Is the New Black described her as possessing both a fierce demeanor and a deep compassion towards those she trusted. She was always ready to defend her friends, was exceptionally talented, and had a unique, dark sense of humor that reflected her true spirit – a quintessential New Yorker’s.

Despite not having contact for some time, Matt expressed confidence that they’d meet again someday, as their friendship had been strong.

He also mentioned that he had been eagerly anticipating our meeting, given how much we’ve evolved. Many will miss you deeply. Sending love, Michelle.

In a heartfelt message on Instagram, the Broadway star expressed, “One of the dearest individuals I’ve encountered, you are. Your memory will forever be cherished, Michelle.

Michelle’s ex-boyfriend, whom she dated between 2004 and 2006, penned a tribute on social media. 

It’s deeply saddening to learn that Michelle has passed away. She was an extraordinary individual whose memory I treasure dearly from the years we shared together. Her kindness, uniqueness, and affection for Law & Order: SVU marathons will always be vivid in my mind.

He added, “My condolences to her mother Lana and sister Irene! This is an incredible loss!”

We first crossed paths during auditions for child actors, shared countless exciting and one-of-a-kind experiences, both within and beyond the entertainment industry. Remarkably, we moved to Los Angeles at around the same teenage age. As adults, our meetings became less frequent, but our connection from those early days remained strong. Her vibrant, spirited, humorous personality, as well as her deep passion for acting, were qualities that never faded.

She expressed, “Overflowing my heart with love for her mother Lana and her cherished sister Irene. My affection for you, Michelle, remains strong. Find peace now.

As a devoted fan, I was deeply saddened to learn about Michelle Trachtenberg’s demise. On Instagram, I expressed my sorrow with a nostalgic video from Clarissa Explains It All, adding, “She was too young, gifted beyond measure, and as kind as can be!

In her comments on the clip, she said, “I believe this scene was set in 1992 and it stemmed from an idea I had regarding a horrid babysitter. However, Michelle wasn’t at all like her on-screen character, and despite our youth, we had a fantastic relationship.

The creators and producers of Gossip Girl expressed their deep sorrow upon learning about Michelle’s passing. She was known for her wit, kindness, and exceptional talent. Playing Georgina Sparks, Michelle became an endearing fan favorite, evolving from a one-season antagonist to a cherished character who made appearances across six seasons.

The duo commented, “She was an absolute joy to work with, and we’ll greatly miss her presence. Our sympathies go out to her loved ones.

On Instagram Story, the former Matilda actor expressed his deep sorrow, saying ‘I can’t help but feel my heart shattering for my dear childhood friend.’ He added that Michelle’s memory will continue to bring blessings.

In a touching Instagram post, Melissa paid tribute to her co-star Michelle Trachtenberg from “A Holiday for Love.” Regrettably, we lived near each other, yet our proximity couldn’t bridge the distance caused by your departure. My heart goes out to your family and everyone who cherished you dearly. #restinsweetpeaceMichelle

It’s truly unfortunate to learn about the demise of Michelle Trachtenberg, as shared on her Instagram Story on February 25th. My thoughts are with her at this difficult time, and I send my heartfelt condolences.

He closed his message with the praying hands and white heart emojis. 

Michelle, a cast member of Buffy The Vampire Slayer, shared the sad news of her passing on social media. “Such tragic news. Rest in peace and thoughts go out to her and her loved ones.

As a seasoned lifestyle guide, I must express my heartfelt condolences upon hearing about the passing of Michelle, a beloved figure from my days on Gossip Girl. Her departure is indeed a profound loss.

“Michelle was tough and a force,” he added in his Instagram post. “Just a kid, so sad.”

The former student of Angel extended his sympathy to the actress’s immediate circle, posting on Instagram: “My thoughts are with her family and those who cared for her deeply. A truly radiant soul who created a remarkable impact… Farewell, my friend. May you find eternal peace.

Read More

2025-07-11 01:47