Netflix’s Upcoming Twilight TV Show Needs To Keep 1 Controversial Book Element

by

The upcoming Netflix series based on Twilight should include a potentially divisive part of the original books and movies. The Twilight Saga was a huge hit with young adult audiences, and even though interest faded after the final film, Breaking Dawn: Part 2, it’s seen a major resurgence in popularity recently.

The original fans of Twilight were always welcoming, which helped the series gain a huge following. So, it’s not surprising that Netflix is creating a new Twilight TV show. Instead of retelling the original story, the show will be based on Midnight Sun, a 2020 book that offers a fresh perspective on the same beloved romance.

The television adaptation of Twilight is facing calls to update the story for modern audiences. Considering the first book was published in 2005 and the movie premiered in 2008, a lot has changed in the years since. Despite this, the show’s creators should avoid altering one particularly debated part of the original story.

Edward Cullen Is Obsessive & Controlling In The Twilight Books & Movies

A major point of criticism with the Twilight series is Edward Cullen’s controlling and possessive behavior. Many argue that the books and movies present this behavior as romantic, which normalizes abusive dynamics. This issue is being discussed more openly now than when Twilight first came out, and the criticism is valid – Edward often is controlling and overbearing.

Okay, let’s talk about Edward Cullen. From the moment he meets Bella, he just takes over her life. It’s unsettling, honestly. He’s constantly watching her – literally, watching her sleep – and following her around like a shadow, even going so far as to stalk her to Port Angeles. And it doesn’t stop there. He starts dictating where she can and can’t go, especially as the story goes on, and often completely ignores what she actually wants. It’s a classic case of control, and it’s frankly a bit disturbing to watch unfold. He’s presented as romantic, but I see a lot of red flags.

Some viewers have suggested changing a certain aspect of Edward in the Twilight TV show, but doing so would drastically change both his character and the overall story. It’s important to keep this part of his personality, even though it’s sparked debate. The creators need to have faith that the audience understands the difference between the show and real life.

Midnight Sun Finally Provides Some Insight Into Edward Cullen’s Controversial Behavior

Fortunately, fans can still enjoy the story without it becoming a romance-focused retelling. The upcoming Twilight TV series will adapt Midnight Sun, which retells the first book through Edward’s point of view instead of Bella’s. This shift allows us to understand Edward’s motivations and what drives his actions, as we gain insight into his thoughts.

Edward is far more strongly drawn to Bella’s blood than he admits. The scent is incredibly potent, actually clouding his judgment when she’s near. It intensifies his vampire instincts, leading to a dangerous buildup of venom. He even begins to fantasize about violence, driven by the desire to taste her blood. Understanding this intense attraction is crucial to the story.

At first, Edward is fascinated and frustrated by Bella because he can’t figure her out. Being over a hundred years old and a vampire, he’s always been able to read minds – but Bella is different. She’s an exception to his ability, and he’s determined to understand why he can’t hear her thoughts.

The original Twilight book and movie only briefly touch on how strongly Edward is affected by Bella. We know he’s drawn to her blood – famously described as his ‘personal brand of heroin’ – and that he can’t read her thoughts. But the full extent of his intense reaction isn’t really clear until the story is told from his point of view.

Netflix’s Twilight TV Show Is The Perfect Place To Explore Edward’s Obsession With Nuance

The Twilight TV series has the opportunity to delve into aspects of Edward’s character that aren’t fully seen through Bella’s eyes. It can showcase his internal struggle between his human side and his vampire instincts, and portray his possessiveness as a natural part of being a vampire, rather than simply a display of affection.

After reading Midnight Sun, it’s worth discussing whether Edward is truly a monster, and the Twilight TV show could delve into this. The story even shows Edward struggling with his own behavior, recognizing that he was controlling and stalked Bella.

Giving Edward Cullen more depth and background transforms him from an ideal boyfriend into a flawed hero. This doesn’t change the character or the plot, but it explains his questionable actions – antiheroes often do wrong things with good intentions. This more complex, morally ambiguous version of Edward is crucial for a successful Twilight TV show while staying true to the original story.

Read More

2026-01-01 20:40