Round Up: Total Lack of Mafia: The Old Country PS5 Reviews Is a Red Flag

by

The feedback on Mafia: The Old Country is out, and although the general sentiment is relatively favorable, it’s clear that a significant issue exists: thus far, only the computer (PC) version of the game has received reviews.

There might have been some confusion about giving early access to game previews to the press from both Sony and Microsoft. In such circumstances, it’s best to exercise patience and wait for reviews based on console play before getting too excited about upcoming games.

Regarding the feedback available, Mafia: The Old Country has sparked a mix of opinions among critics. Some have commended its narrative and atmosphere, while others have criticized its gameplay mechanics as outdated and the optimization as inadequate. This latter concern could potentially impact the console releases negatively.

Again, all of the following reviews are based on the PC version of the title.

Press Start Australia – 9/10

As a die-hard fan of the Mafia series, diving into “Mafia: The Old Country” felt like stepping back into a cherished world. This prequel, spanning around 10-15 hours, is brimming with elements that truly resonated with me – from its engaging narrative to breathtaking cinematics, and let’s not forget the thrilling gameplay that kept me hooked every step of the way.

Of course, it’s not perfect; there are a few hiccups here and there. But overall, I believe Hangar 13 has crafted an eloquent tribute to a series that’s held a special place in my gaming heart for years.

GamingTrend – 8.5/10

The Old Country” brings back the feel of the past in multiple aspects. Although the gameplay is typical third-person action, it’s enjoyable because it offers substance without excessive filler content that needs to be navigated to get to the good parts.

Gamepressure – 8/10

The Old Country” brings back the original essence of the Mafia series. Although there are a few minor issues, it offers an interesting narrative that’s definitely worth playing. Plus, it includes several nods to the franchise that longtime Mafia fans will enjoy.

Meristation – 7/10

As a devoted gamer, I must say that Mafia: The Old Country offers an immersive cinematic experience filled with compelling characters and a gripping narrative. However, its gameplay, much like the Old Country itself, seems reminiscent of yesteryears.

Digital Trends – 6/10

Mafia: The Old Country struggles to present a coherent theme. Its components don’t seem to complement each other effectively, and it fails to develop a unique or engaging gameplay mechanic. Moreover, there seems to be a lack of compelling characters with defined motives, making the game appear indistinct.

Game Informer – 6/10

The Old Country isn’t exceptional; it’s neither terrible nor fantastic. Perhaps its most disheartening aspect is that it’s just average, without causing offense. There’s nothing unique about it that you haven’t seen in other places or films. What’s more disappointing is that it likely hasn’t been done better elsewhere. Despite the many impressive prequels, The Old Country demonstrates that going back isn’t always an engaging path to progress.

Gamereactor UK – 6/10

In a game like this, an action-packed one that’s relatively brief, I believe it would have benefited from a wider range of experiences and a faster pace to create a more immersive and exciting conclusion.

Stevivor – 5/10

Few games have stirred such intense frustration within me like ‘Mafia: The Old Country’ did at the end. Even dedicated series enthusiasts might find it hard to justify playing

This paraphrase conveys the same sentiment as the original sentence while using a more natural and conversational tone that is easy to understand.

Read More

2025-08-07 16:32