Sorry Tom King Fans, DC’s New Supergirl Series is Her Best Modern Comic

by

While many are excited about Woman of Tomorrow, I’m really enjoying the new Supergirl comic series more. A few years ago, Tom King wrote a very popular limited series featuring Supergirl that was a huge success. In fact, that story is being used as the foundation for Kara Zor-El’s introduction into the DC Universe in the upcoming Supergirl movie. That earlier series was definitely good, but I think this current Supergirl series is a better and more fulfilling read.

As part of DC’s “Summer of Superman” event, a new ongoing Supergirl comic series launched, written by Sophie Campbell (known for Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and Wet Moon). This comic takes a lighter approach, with Kara revisiting her past in Midvale and stumbling into strange situations – like someone pretending to be her, or monsters appearing unexpectedly. It’s a different feel than the Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow series, but it feels like just the right tone for a Supergirl story.

Supergirl Takes a Different, But More Fulfilling Approach to Kara Zor-El

This Supergirl series offers a cheerful take on the classic character. Instead of teaming up with Superman in Metropolis, Kara goes back to Midvale, the town where she first used her powers. It’s clear the writer aimed for the feel of older, classic comics. The story not only brings Supergirl back to her beginnings, but also uses old-fashioned thought bubbles to show what Kara and other characters are thinking. The fun, retro style doesn’t stop there!

The writer skillfully incorporates elements from the very beginning of the Supergirl comics, including a reimagining of the classic villain Lesla-Lar, who originally tried to impersonate Supergirl. However, this isn’t just a repeat of old ideas. The writer uses these familiar pieces to create a fresh and satisfying story. Instead of portraying Lesla-Lar as an enemy, she’s turned into an ally, enriching Supergirl’s network of friends and demonstrating Kara’s positive impact on others.

While this series has a classic, optimistic feel, it doesn’t shy away from Supergirl’s difficult past. The story acknowledges the trauma Kara has experienced, including her death, time with the Red Lanterns, and the events of Woman of Tomorrow. However, the series truly shines by showing how Kara overcomes these hardships and maintains her hopeful and positive outlook.

Woman of Tomorrow is Good, But Supergirl is the Ongoing She Needed

I appreciate Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow and Tom King’s work on it. It clearly connected with a lot of readers, and I liked that it explored Supergirl’s difficult emotions, like the guilt she feels as a survivor. That’s the kind of depth I enjoy in Supergirl stories. King did a great job of recognizing that Kara isn’t just a female Superman and crafted a story that felt true to her character. Still, I think the story could have used more of the optimistic and cheerful tone that’s so important to balancing out who Supergirl is.

I think my expectations for a Supergirl comic are heavily influenced by Sterling Gates’ previous work, which I consider to be the best Supergirl series. That run understood that Supergirl shines when her past trauma is acknowledged without overwhelming the story. While she’s faced hardship, she’s ultimately optimistic and ready for anything. The current series by Campbell seems to understand this balance, and it has the potential to be just as good.

Supergirl is a really compelling character within the Superman mythos, and I’m thrilled to see her featured in a comic that understands her journey. Sophie Campbell’s Supergirl strikes a great balance between serious moments and fun, and her clever use of classic Silver Age elements makes the series truly special. While Woman of Tomorrow is popular, this current Supergirl run is exactly what I’ve been wanting to read.

Enjoying the new Supergirl show? Let us know what you think in the comments or on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/every-version-of-supergirl-ranked/embed/#

Read More

2025-11-27 21:40