Star Trek Almost Brought Captain Kirk Back 10 Years After His Death (& Honestly, The Scrapped Plan Sounds Amazing)

by

For decades, *Star Trek* has successfully built on its history and extensive storytelling. While each new series introduces fresh characters and adventures, fans often get most excited about seeing familiar faces return. Whether it’s a beloved character remembering the past, like McCoy, or a surprise appearance, such as Sulu on *Voyager*, these cameos offer instant nostalgia and cleverly connect different *Star Trek* shows, creating a sense of continuity and allowing for the resolution of old storylines and updates on where our favorite characters are now. Sadly, a potentially huge cameo moment that could have been one of the biggest in *Star Trek* history never actually happened.

Before *Strange New Worlds* brought renewed excitement for the original *Star Trek*, *Enterprise* almost achieved a major crossover event. Writer and producer Mike Sussman told *TrekMovie.com* that the show’s creator, Manny Coto, planned a two-part story set in the Mirror Universe for the fourth season, with William Shatner playing a central role. However, despite months of effort, the network or studio wouldn’t agree to Shatner’s asking price.

A Mirror Universe Kirk?

In 2004, ten years after Kirk’s death in the film *Star Trek: Generations*, *Enterprise*’s producer, Manny Coto, wanted to revitalize the show. He planned an ambitious story set in the *Mirror Universe* and hoped to bring back William Shatner to play an evil version of his famous Captain Kirk.

The idea, created with experienced *Star Trek* novelists Judith and Garfield Reeves-Stevens (who previously co-wrote *Star Trek: Spectre* with William Shatner), centered around ‘Emperor Tiberius’ – the Mirror Universe version of Captain Kirk. The proposed story would have featured him unexpectedly transported to the past, where he’d be forced to collaborate with Captain Jonathan Archer and the crew of the NX-01 in a difficult partnership. The two captains would have had to work together despite their differences. This story aimed to expand the *Mirror Universe* lore, acting as both a sequel to existing stories and a prequel explaining the origins of the Terran Empire.

The idea was incredibly ambitious and perfectly suited William Shatner’s style – fitting, considering his Captain Kirk was always a little extra. It’s easy to picture him fully embracing the role of Emperor Tiberius, bringing his usual charm and dramatic flair to create a truly unforgettable performance. It would have been more than just a cameo; it could have been legendary. Seeing Shatner really let loose and recapture the confidence that made Kirk so beloved, but with a darker edge, had the potential to make the episode one of the most talked-about in *Star Trek* history. It might have even given *Enterprise* the boost it needed to continue for another season.

Despite initial planning, the idea of bringing William Shatner back to *Star Trek: Enterprise* didn’t work out. According to *TrekMovie.com*, Paramount even tested the idea with focus groups and created a promotional reel using footage of Captain Kirk from *The Wrath of Khan*. Ultimately, the project was cancelled due to budget constraints and scheduling conflicts. Shatner was busy with the TV show *Boston Legal*, and by the time serious talks about his return began, *Enterprise*’s future was already decided. UPN, the network airing the show, likely wasn’t willing to pay Shatner’s asking price, as they weren’t confident his appearance would revive a series that was already losing viewers.

What the Mirror Episode Became

Although William Shatner couldn’t be involved, the show *Enterprise* still delivered a story set in the Mirror Universe. Writer and producer Mike Sussman took ideas he’d previously developed and turned them into “In a Mirror, Darkly,” a popular two-part episode. It showed a darker, more ruthless version of the NX-01 crew within the ‘Terran Empire’. Instead of focusing on Kirk or the Federation, the episode delved deeper into the Mirror Universe, revealing how the crew finds the USS Defiant—a ship originally seen in the classic *Original Series* episode “The Tholian Web”—and uses its futuristic technology to speed up their efforts to dominate space. Fans loved the story, which combined a vintage look with nods to classic *Star Trek*. It was a clear tribute to the original series and its 1960s style.

It’s hard not to think about how great it would have been to see William Shatner return as Captain Kirk – but as a villainous version from the Mirror Universe. This would have been a compelling addition to the existing Mirror Universe stories, connecting the original series with the era of *Enterprise*, and given Shatner a chance to play a really dramatic role he’s known for. Just picture Shatner’s Kirk clashing with an evil version of Captain Archer, played by Scott Bakula. It would have been quintessential *Star Trek* – a perfect blend of fun, seriousness, and humor.

“In a Mirror, Darkly” really ended up being an episode I adore, but I always wonder about the one that almost was – William Shatner’s potential appearance in a mirror universe story. It’s particularly frustrating because he was genuinely keen to do it, and apparently, his schedule on *Boston Legal* could have worked! As the Reeves-Stevens recalled, he really loved the idea of playing a version of Tiberius again. It would have been a fantastic way for him to both honor his iconic role and playfully reimagine it.

Although William Shatner appearing on *Enterprise* wouldn’t have prevented its cancellation, it would have created a memorable crossover moment that fans would still be discussing today, and given the show a strong finale. Even now, decades later, efforts to bring Captain Kirk back continue to generate discussion among *Star Trek* fans. While recent *Star Trek* shows like the JJ Abrams films and *Strange New Worlds* have found new ways to feature classic characters, the planned *Enterprise* appearance wasn’t simply about revisiting Kirk. It was about imagining an alternate version of him, and knowing Shatner, it would have been a bold and dramatic portrayal.

Star Trek: Enterprise and Star Trek: Strange New Worlds are streaming now on Paramount+.

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/review/7-star-trek-theories-that-completely-change-major-characters/embed/#

Read More

2025-10-08 19:11