Star Trek: TNG’s Chain of Command Is a Must-Watch for Sci-Fi Fans

by

As a huge Star Trek fan, I was so excited when Gene Roddenberry brought us The Next Generation in 1987, with Patrick Stewart taking on the role of Captain Picard. For a lot of us, it quickly became even better than the original series – some of those episodes were truly amazing! I remember when Season Six aired in 1992 – it gave us one of the most intense and seriously dark storylines in all of Star Trek.

When Star Trek: The Next Generation debuted in 1987, it quickly established itself as a strong continuation of the original series. It benefited from a changing cultural landscape where science fiction was more respected, and improved special effects made it an immediate hit. However, what fans truly loved was its intelligent and thought-provoking storytelling, which explored philosophical and political themes even more deeply than the original series with William Shatner. In its second-to-last season, Captain Jean-Luc Picard faced his most challenging and darkest storyline, “Chain of Command,” a story that remains powerful and relevant even today, thirty-three years later.

Chain of Command is Star Trek’s Darkest Episode

In the episode “Chain of Command,” Captain Picard undertakes a secret mission to demolish a Cardassian base producing biological weapons. After being captured, he’s held prisoner while Captain Edward Jellico, the new commander of the Enterprise, tries to resolve the crisis. While in captivity, Picard endures harsh psychological torture at the hands of Cardassian commander Gul Madred, who subjects him to a particularly cruel test: forcing him to believe that four lights actually represent five.

With the conflict between the Federation and Cardassians growing worse, the interrogation and mental manipulation of Captain Picard becomes increasingly intense. His crew works frantically to free him, and while Picard fights back, he becomes noticeably weaker as the situation unfolds.

Jellico’s crew has to compensate for his weaknesses as they begin to doubt his ability to lead. When Madred learns his prisoner will be freed, he attempts a desperate deception, trying to manipulate the captain into believing his version of events. However, before the captain can give in, he’s unexpectedly rescued, giving him the chance to recover and resist Madred’s control.

This episode is particularly disturbing, offering a rare look at a deeply personal form of torture. Since it aired, real-world torture cases have come to light, making the episode even more unsettling when viewed today. While the series is full of tragic and frightening moments, the fear of losing one’s own mind stands out as especially terrifying.

Throughout the show, the character faced many difficult situations, like being turned into a drone by the Borg. But viewers are most haunted by watching him slowly break down under Cardassian torture – it’s an experience that’s incredibly hard to fully grasp.

How Picard’s Final Words Added a Layer of Darkness to the Episode

After being rescued by my friends, Picard had a debriefing with the ship’s counselor, and it was a really powerful session. He finally opened up about just how far Madred’s torture pushed him. He admitted that, by the end of it, he actually started seeing lights – five of them, to be exact. He’d convinced himself his crew was gone and the mission had failed, and he truly believed his life had come down to choosing between more torture or a false comfort. It was like his mind just…gave in to Madred’s lies, because it couldn’t face the hopelessness of the situation. It was a way out, even if it wasn’t real.

Like many of the best Next Generation episodes, “Chain of Command” reveals more depth the more you consider it. It initially appears to be a tense psychological battle between Picard, as a prisoner of war, and his interrogator, Madred, who tries to wear him down.

The episode also cleverly examines the politics within the Enterprise, specifically challenging the idea that orders must always be followed. Ultimately, the crew’s dedication to Captain Picard is what allows them to rescue him from a truly terrible situation – one that could have been even worse than dying.

More than anything, this episode highlights how vulnerable the human mind can be, even for someone as strong and controlled as Picard. The storyline in ‘Madred’ gave us a rare look at the darker, more dangerous side of the Star Trek universe. And with Jellico, the episode explored the conflict between large-scale strategy and the importance of individual lives – a theme often seen throughout the series.

Few lines from Star Trek capture the show’s essence – and Captain Picard’s determination – quite like “There are four lights!” Even with new Star Trek series being made, it’s hard to imagine a more memorable scene.

How Chain of Command Blends Star Trek and George Orwell

George Orwell’s books are consistently praised for their insightful observations about society. He was a novelist known for his dystopian stories, which examine how societies and political systems can break down and become frighteningly distorted. Works like Animal Farm and 1984 continue to be relevant today, offering important commentary on topics such as the power of propaganda and the manipulation of truth during times of conflict.

As a huge sci-fi fan, I always found the “Chain of Command” episodes fascinating because they really dove into that whole Orwellian world. The character Madred? He’s basically a stand-in for Big Brother or O’Brien from 1984 – a total master of psychological manipulation. He’s determined to prove he can warp someone’s perception of reality, and by the end, he succeeds with Picard. It’s chilling to watch Picard get broken down and ultimately forced to see things Madred wants him to see, not what’s actually real.

As a film buff, I’ve always been fascinated by stories exploring mind control, and it’s chilling to realize it’s not just science fiction. Throughout history, oppressive governments have actually used propaganda to manipulate what people believe, essentially twisting reality. It’s terrifying to think that when information is completely controlled, people can end up believing in things that actually harm them, even actively supporting their own mistreatment. It’s a really disturbing idea that films often tap into, and it resonates because it’s sadly based in reality.

Picard realized there were four lights, but Madred was pushing him to his mental limit. While his desperate cry of “there are four lights!” was a powerful act of resistance, it was ultimately diminished by what he revealed afterward.

Subscribe to the newsletter for deeper Trek insights

Subscribe to the newsletter for deeper Trek insights

When you sign up, you’ll receive emails about our newsletter and special offers, and you agree to Valnet’s Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. You can opt out of these emails at any time.

Throughout its run, the series has cleverly referenced numerous classic fictional works, spanning from Shakespeare to Arthur Conan Doyle. Similar to many science fiction stories, it draws heavily from the work of Orwell, and its themes remain powerfully relevant even now. Few franchises have captured the spirit and ideas of Orwell’s writing as effectively as the world created by Roddenberry.

Episodes like “Chain of Command” truly showcased the best of Captain Picard and his crew. More importantly, they demonstrated the show’s ability to tackle difficult and important topics, even exposing the brutality of torture in a way that made viewers confront its reality.

Next Generation is Full of Masterpiece Episodes

Even thirty years after it ended, The Next Generation remains a beloved favorite among Star Trek fans globally. Many consider it superior to the original series, thanks to its memorable episodes. The show often showcased the captain’s cleverness, good judgment, and ability to solve problems, and episodes like “The Drumhead” and “Darmok” are still celebrated for their portrayal of his leadership. Patrick Stewart consistently delivered a performance that pleased fans.

As a huge Star Trek fan, I think episodes like “Chain of Command” really explain why so many people, myself included, consider Picard the best captain of the bunch. Everyone still argues about which Star Trek series is the greatest, but it’s hard to deny that Picard is the most compelling and well-developed captain to ever command the Enterprise.

Even after 33 years, the Star Trek franchise continues to thrive at Paramount, with shows like Strange New Worlds being well-received. The episode “Chain of Command” still demonstrates that The Next Generation was a high point for the series, and Patrick Stewart’s portrayal of Picard remains unmatched.

Read More

2025-12-25 23:40