Survivor’s Parvati Shallow Slams Jeff Probst’s Comment About Her Wins

by

Parvati Shallow isn’t going to let Jeff Probst outlast this.

A well-known player from the show Survivor publicly criticized both the host and fellow contestant Jeremy Collins, who won Survivor: Second Chance in 2015. The criticism came after they both raised doubts about her being a true two-time winner, pointing out that her second win was on Survivor: Australia vs. The World, a spin-off series, and not the original Survivor.

Jeff Probst brought up an interesting question on his podcast, On Fire With Jeff Probst, on September 24th. He asked Jeremy if winning the Australian version of Survivor – hosted by David Genat and filmed in just 16 days – should be considered a legitimate win for American Survivor players like Parvati.

Jeff put Jeremy on the spot during his podcast, asking a serious question about the reality show Survivor. He wondered if Parvati’s win on Survivor Australia should be considered equal to winning the American version of Survivor, effectively making her a two-time winner.

And Jeremy, was pretty clear about where he stood on the issue. 

“I disagree,” said the winner of Survivor: Cambodia. “In my opinion, she’s only really won one and a half times. It was a solid win, and Survivor Australia is a good version of the show. But it doesn’t compare to Survivor in the US – it’s just not the same.”

As for how Parvati reacted? Well, she quickly clapped back at their take.

Parvati, a past winner of both the Australian and U.S. versions of Survivor (including Survivor: Fans vs Favorites in 2008), responded to a podcast clip shared on Instagram on October 23rd, accusing two men of attempting to undermine her credibility. She wrote, “Get a new move boys.”

TopMob News has reached out to Jeff and Jeremy for comment and has yet to hear back.

Parvati wasn’t the only former Survivor player to call the duo out, either. 

As a longtime observer of the social dynamics in games like Survivor, I found the online reactions to a recent post particularly interesting. Kelley Wentworth, a three-time player known for her strategic awareness, playfully commented that she was ‘keeping a close watch on everything,’ while Natalie Anderson, who won Survivor: San Juan del Sur, suggested something bigger was happening – that it all felt like a carefully planned setup.

Eliza Orlins, a two-time player, also pointed out that Jeremy and Jeff weren’t challenging the winners from the last eight seasons. These seasons were 26 days long, instead of the usual 39. The show originally shortened the seasons because of COVID-19, but decided to continue with the shorter length as part of a new format.

She exclaimed, clearly frustrated, “Seriously, give me a moment!” Then she questioned, “So, if a season lasts 26 days, the winner only has a two-thirds chance of actually winning, is that right?”

Keep reading for facts you might not know about Survivor…

Each season, tens of thousands of people try out for the show. The casting team intentionally creates a diverse group, combining dedicated Survivor fans with people who often turn out to be models or actors that they specifically recruit. However, even these recruited individuals have to go through the standard audition process.

Former casting director Lynne Spillman, who worked on the show from its start until 2018, shared with Reality Wanted that they often received repeat applications from the same individuals year after year.

Now, host Jeff Probst is handling casting. 

You know, when I connect with young people these days, it’s always so inspiring. It usually starts with a Zoom call where they share what’s going on in their lives, and honestly, my first thought is always the same: ‘Wow, they’ve accomplished so much already!’ It really makes me reflect and wonder what I was up to at their age – it’s humbling, to say the least!

The selection process includes further interviews, including sessions with the show’s psychologists. Host Jeff Probst explained that their main goal is simply to understand the contestants’ true personalities. He often tells applicants that they don’t need to pretend to be someone they’re not. “It sounds simple, but it’s true,” Probst says. “You don’t need a dramatic backstory, you don’t need to be the comedian, and qualifications like a college degree aren’t important. Just be yourself.”

Even if you’re one of the first contestants voted off, you still earn money by appearing on Survivor—though it might be a blow to your pride.

Here’s a quick rundown of what competitors make:

Players voted off before the final jury still get a free trip to Fiji – they have to stay throughout filming to keep the outcome a secret. On top of that, everyone who participates receives $10,000 for appearing at the live finale and reunion show.

Jonny Fairplay, known for his appearances on the show, recently revealed to TMZ how much Survivor cast members supposedly earn. He claims the first person voted off receives $12,500, and those who make it to the jury—the final voters—get $40,000. Fairplay admitted he might have revealed confidential information, possibly violating a non-disclosure agreement.

The winner of Survivor receives a $1 million prize, but even coming in second or third place earns a substantial amount: $100,000 and $85,000 respectively. The show used to also award a fan-favorite prize of $100,000 or a car, determined by public vote, but that practice has been discontinued.

Season two of Survivor, The Australian Outback, is the only one that lasted longer than 39 days. This was likely due to the huge popularity and high ratings of the show’s very first season.

Plus, each episode covers roughly three days of the competition, which means editors face the challenge of condensing an incredible 300 to 500 hours of footage—since the contestants are filmed around the clock—into a concise 44-minute show.

Filming the Tribal Council scenes usually takes an hour or two because Jeff Probst asks each contestant the same question individually. When it’s time to count the votes, Probst works with the producers, who are watching the voting process live on a feed. Together, they decide the order in which Probst will announce the votes.

According to the Survivor Wiki, castaways are only allowed to bring one small, handheld item with them when filming begins – they can’t bring any luggage.

All clothing worn during the 39-day shoot must be approved by the production team beforehand, including any potential wear and tear.

Angelina Keeley from David vs. Goliath really wished she’d brought her parka to the game, but contestants don’t get to choose their outfits. She explained to EW that the clothes are meant to reflect who you are and what you’d typically wear. After famously trying to get a recently eliminated player, Natalie Cole, to give her a jacket (unsuccessfully), Angelina added that you start with one outfit and have to stick with it unless you can find a way to change things up.

During a Reddit Q&A, former contestant Max Dawson shared that producers sometimes give very detailed instructions, even directing players to specific stores for certain items. For example, John Cochran’s famous sweater vests were actually chosen for him by the show’s team!

According to Today, participants are provided with a kit containing essential items like feminine hygiene products, birth control, important medications, contact lens solution, sunscreen, and bug spray.

Basic necessities, like tampons, aren’t always readily available on set. Survivor Season 39 contestant Lauren-Ashley Beck shared that she had her period twice during filming, and the second time, it took almost a full day to get a tampon because the crew had to go to a local village to get more.

Some actors opt for procedures like laser hair removal or teeth whitening before filming, potentially to avoid visible imperfections like toothbrush marks or razor burn.

So…where are Probst and the crew members staying while the competitors are roughing it? 

Jeff Probst shared in a 2014 Reddit AMA that the Survivor crew’s sleeping arrangements depend on the location. When filming in the Philippines, they were lucky enough to find an abandoned casino and hotel on a remote island. He wasn’t sure what the place was normally used for, but it provided comfortable accommodations, with each crew member getting their own room complete with a shower and air conditioning.

Oh my gosh, he talked about the tents they used before, and I nearly died! He remembered being in Kenya, in these tiny, single-person tents, and said it was incredible. He described pulling his cot out just to stare at the stars – can you imagine?! But the best part? He said every morning, he’d unzip his tent super quietly because zebras or even giraffes were probably right outside! Seriously, a herd of zebras! Or giraffes! It sounded like the most magical, once-in-a-lifetime experience ever. I’m so jealous!

Jeff Probst says there’s no typical day for him. Each day is long, surprisingly enjoyable, and constantly busy because ‘Survivor’ is always in production. As Executive Producer, he’s always working, but he credits his incredible production team for making it possible.

It might surprise you to learn that Survivor has a dedicated “Dream Team”! This group of crew members actually test every challenge before the castaways do. They run through each one at least twice: first to work out any kinks and decide on the best way to film it, and then again so we can see them complete the challenge as if they were contestants – you see this footage when Jeff Probst explains the rules on the show.

If the rules of the show seem confusing – and they often do – you’re in good company. The contestants themselves usually get a more detailed explanation from John Kirhoffer, the challenge producer. He’s in charge of all the show’s games and is there to answer any questions the contestants have. A representative from CBS legal is also present to make sure everything stays fair.

Contestants meet with the show’s medical team both before and after each challenge. Medical staff are also available at all times to handle any emergencies – like the time three players actually collapsed during one challenge on Survivor: Kaôh Rõng.

Even if you’re voted off early in the competition, you’ll still spend the entire 39 days at the filming location. (Keeping things secret has some benefits!) Eliminated players who make it far enough to become jury members are sent to a place called “Ponderosa,” where they enjoy comfortable living with access to things like food, entertainment, and running water – it’s often a resort or hotel. They’re also able to hang out and talk with the other jury members.

During the Micronesia season of Survivor, CBS launched Life at Ponderosa, an online show letting viewers see what happens after contestants are eliminated from the game.

If you’re voted out of the competition before the final group, and therefore aren’t on the jury, you’ll be moved to a nearby location once the jury members begin gathering.

Surprisingly, the show wasn’t forced to evacuate the cast because of a natural disaster until a cyclone struck Fiji during Season 33, Millennials vs. Gen X, in 2016. And when something happens that halts the game, it truly comes to a complete stop.

After shutting down the game, we brought all the tribes back to base camp to keep everyone together. We isolated each tribe in a completely empty room – no food, bedding, or anything at all. Producers watched them closely throughout the night, and surprisingly, they kept to themselves and didn’t attempt to talk or make deals, respecting our agreement. The next morning, we brought them back to their beaches, and the game continued as normal, according to Probst.

During season 37 in 2018, the contestants had to be evacuated twice because of cyclones in Fiji. Both times, they were kept isolated to avoid any unfair advantages. However, host Jeff Probst praised the players for respecting the rules and the spirit of the game even during the interruptions.

The contestants were grateful we had their best interests at heart,” Probst explained to EW. “They also understood the game wasn’t over, even though it was paused, and that’s why they didn’t try to break any rules or cause trouble.

Although it often appears that players walk to challenges and Tribal Council on their own, production staff actually transports them. However, they aren’t allowed to discuss strategy or the game while they’re being moved behind the scenes.

Jeff Probst, host and producer of Survivor, recently shared his favorite winner during an EW panel: John Cochran from Season 26. He also named Parvati Shallow and Rob Mariano as players who have consistently demonstrated exceptional strategic gameplay.

And during a Reddit AMA, he revealed his least favorite Survivor twist ever: The Medallion of Power. 

He admitted he wasn’t happy with how things turned out. He acknowledged mistakes happen, but expressed confidence in the overall quality of their decisions. He explained that, like all show creators, they can only really judge what works after giving it a try.

But his favorite surprising element of the show was the hidden immunity idol, which first appeared in season 11.

As a longtime Survivor fan, I was really surprised to hear Jeff Probst tell The Hollywood Reporter that they’ve actually used ideas from Tyler Perry! Apparently, the idea for that ‘special powers’ idol – the one players could use after Tribal Council – came from him. I remember that thing vividly; it definitely played a part in Tony Vlachos winning in Cagayan, but honestly, most of us weren’t big fans of it at the time. It felt a little unfair, if I’m being honest!

Besides Perry, Jimmy Fallon has also offered ideas. A group of TV showrunners and producers are running a contest with a $200 entry fee. The winner takes the entire pot, while the loser foots the bill for a huge end-of-season dinner – it’s gotten as high as $8,000 in the past!

Before filming begins, everyone who competes on the show signs a contract. This agreement with the show and CBS prevents them from saying anything negative about Survivor or its creators, and it also confirms they understand the risks and potential for injuries that come with participating.

There’s a huge penalty – $5 million – if you break the confidentiality agreement, meaning if you reveal any details about the show or even that you’re a contestant before CBS officially announces it.

During season 37, Alec Merlino risked legal trouble when he shared a photo with competitor Kara Kay on Instagram before the show even started. He captioned the photo with a profanity. Although producers didn’t fine him the $5 million mentioned in his non-disclosure agreement, they did exclude him from attending the live finale.

The main source of conflict throughout my time on Survivor has been the reaction to a picture that circulated. I have complete respect for CBS, the show, and Jeff Probst. Despite the situation, I had an incredible experience. I own my mistake – it was unfortunate – but I believe things were misinterpreted, and that’s all I’ll say about it, as social media can easily distort situations,” Alec explained to EW.

Oh my god, you won’t BELIEVE this! Back in 2001, Stacey Stillman – you remember her, the third person voted off the original Survivor? – she actually sued CBS and Mark Burnett! She claimed Burnett totally rigged the show and made sure she was voted out. Seriously, she said he manipulated everyone, used his connections with the cast to get them to do what he wanted, and even convinced two people to change their votes! It’s insane! I always knew something felt off about that season, and she was right! It was all planned!

CBS and Mark Burnett, the creator of the show, dismissed the lawsuit as without merit. The network then filed its own lawsuit, seeking $5 million in damages due to a breach of contract – specifically, someone had spoken publicly against the show when they weren’t supposed to. Eventually, the dispute was resolved privately, outside of court.

Over the years, Survivor has seen many couples find love, with Boston Rob Mariano and Amber Brkich being the most famous example. They met during All-Stars and are now married with four daughters.

I was so surprised to learn that even Jeff Probst found romance through the show! He started dating Julie Berry, a contestant from Survivor: Vanuatu, once filming finished. They were really discreet about it, keeping things under wraps until after her season aired, and they actually dated for a few years before sadly splitting up in 2008. It was a sweet story while it lasted!

Read More

2025-10-24 22:50