The GameCube RPG That Fans Still Beg Nintendo to Revive

by

While the GameCube wasn’t Nintendo’s biggest hit, it boasts a collection of timeless games – some continued popular franchises, while others were completely original. It was also a strong platform for RPGs, offering titles like Tales of Symphonia, Skies of Arcadia Legends, and, naturally, Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door. However, there’s one game that hasn’t received much attention, despite being a great title. Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean was highly praised upon its 2003 release, but the developers at Monolith Soft weren’t able to expand on its success.

Baten-Kaitos’s Lackluster Sales and Disappointing Sequel

Baten-Kaitos offers a fresh and unique approach to role-playing games. Instead of directly controlling the main character, you play as a “guardian spirit.” You’ll communicate with other characters through a text-based conversation system. Since you don’t directly control the characters’ actions, Baten-Kaitos features a battle system using collectible magical cards called “Magnus” – you build a deck to fight your enemies.

As a fan, I’ve found the battles are really interesting because they mix turn-based strategy with real-time action. You’ve got to think fast and play your cards quickly during your turn to do damage and protect yourself. This keeps things moving at a good pace, and honestly, it makes what could be a long, drawn-out fight feel much more action-packed. It’s a clever way to keep you engaged!

I gotta say, this game really did something different with the genre, and people noticed! When it first came out, reviewers were really impressed. They especially loved how good the graphics and music were – it all felt fresh and unique compared to other games back then. And the gameplay? Man, it was a standout! It was this cool mix of collectible card games, poker, and RPG battles. Okay, the story and voice acting weren’t perfect, but overall, Baten-Kaitos was considered a big win by the critics.

It’s a shame, because even though critics seemed to like the game, Baten-Kaitos didn’t actually *sell* very well. It moved just under 250,000 copies total between Japan and North America. Namco, the publisher, was hoping for a lot more – roughly twice that number, actually, since Tales of Symphonia sold about 500,000 copies around the same time. This was a real problem, because they were hoping to build a whole new series with Baten-Kaitos, but it just didn’t find a big enough audience, even with the good reviews. Everything kind of stalled after that, but thankfully Nintendo eventually agreed to let them make a prequel called Baten Kaitos Origins.

Just like the first game, Origins actually got pretty good reviews. People thought the story was a lot better, and a lot of reviewers really liked how they simplified the combat. But, unfortunately, it came out right before the Wii launched. Because everyone was excited about the new system, Origins didn’t sell as well as the first one – even though it was a solid game! It ended up being one of the last games released for the GameCube.

The Rise of the Xeno Series

While the somewhat weak sales of both Baten-Kaitos games likely contributed to the series ending, it’s probably not the sole reason we haven’t seen a new installment. Many people at Monolith Soft and Tri-Crescendo have expressed interest in developing another game, and rumors about Baten-Kaitos 3 have circulated for the past ten years. The real problem might be that Monolith Soft discovered another series that fulfilled their ambitions for an RPG franchise.

Monolith’s debut game was Xenosaga Episode 1 for the PlayStation 2 in 2002, a year before the original Baten-Kaitos. It sold better than Baten-Kaitos, likely because it was released on the more popular PS2 console.

Selling 340,000 copies is a good achievement, however the PlayStation 2 had almost eight times more users than the GameCube by the time both consoles were discontinued. While it’s difficult to pinpoint the exact difference when the consoles first launched, game developers generally had a higher potential for strong sales on the PlayStation 2. Ultimately, this made Sony’s console a more attractive platform for many. It’s important to note that user base size significantly impacted sales potential.

Even so, the Xeno series is now Monolith Soft’s most successful creation. Starting with the release of Xenoblade Chronicles in 2010, the Xeno saga has become a beloved RPG franchise. It’s essentially Monolith Soft’s most profitable series, so it’s unrealistic to expect them to abandon it in favor of a series that hasn’t sold well. It’s a tough ask, and likely won’t happen. Fans continue to eagerly await new installments.

With that in mind, Baten-Kaitos has gained a dedicated following over the years. In 2024, the original two games received a remastered version, allowing a wider range of players to experience them. Should a new installment be made, Bandai Namco might choose to let Tri-Crescendo have complete creative control this time around.

The studio was responsible for the combat and sound effects in the initial two games, and they’ve also assisted Bandai Namco with titles like Tales of Arise and Tales of Berseria. Currently, everything is just based on rumors, but the remaster has led fans to believe that the long-awaited Baten-Kaitos 3 could actually happen.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/gaming/news/nintendo-switch-baten-kaitos-remasters-gamecube-gcn/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-30 21:22