The Phoenix Force is the Worst Thing to Happen to the Marvel Universe

I’ve always been a Marvel fan, and what they did differently in their superhero comics truly resonated with me. Unlike DC’s heroes who seemed more like deities on Earth, Marvel made theirs feel more relatable – ordinary people facing extraordinary circumstances. For instance, Spider-Man was just like us readers, the Fantastic Four were a close-knit family, and Captain America was the wise uncle who had lived through World War II or Korea. This unique approach set Marvel apart, making it a favorite among fans.

Of course, there were gods and cosmic entities like Thor, Galactus, Loki, Silver Surfer, and others, but the heart of Marvel lay in its characters – ordinary people dealing with extraordinary situations. The X-Men took this concept to another level. They weren’t just a team; they were a family, a group of friends bound together by shared experiences and mutual understanding. This was something everyone could relate to.

And then came the Phoenix Force. It was a game-changer, an event that shook the Marvel Universe to its core. The Phoenix Force wasn’t just a cosmic entity; it was a symbol of power, change, and rebirth, touching the lives of some of Marvel’s most iconic characters. It was a testament to Marvel’s ability to weave complex narratives around their characters, making them feel real and relatable even in the face of cosmic forces.

To put it simply, “The Dark Phoenix Saga” stands out among all Marvel stories as their absolute best. While personal preferences may vary, this tale uniquely combines what Marvel does best – authentic character development and emotional depth – with something divine. No subsequent Marvel story has matched its brilliance. Over time, I’ve come to see the Phoenix Force not as a positive influence but rather as a detriment to the Marvel Universe. Its impact has been increasingly harmful, spreading far and wide throughout the universe.

The Phoenix Force Is More Trouble Than It’s Worth

The storyline “Dark Phoenix Saga” is marked by Jean Grey’s death, yet it doesn’t stop there. Her demise in the narrative remains one of the most heartrending moments in comic book history, a sorrow that lingers even when considering the subsequent events. The emotional depth of this tale is what makes it so compelling, portraying the pain of the X-Men over their lost friend and their determination to save her. When Jean finally frees herself from the Phoenix, the sense of relief is intense, but the climax – a fight between the X-Men and the Shi’Ar Imperial Guard in the Blue Area of the Moon – shatters all that. In the end, Jean realizes that those she loves are more valuable than her own life, and her death resonates through the years. Later on, Marvel chose to resurrect Jean, which was initially acceptable. They devised a plausible explanation for this return. However, in recent times, writers have been trying to connect Jean and the Phoenix, leaving even avid X-Men fans confused about her current status. Apparently, she is now revealed as always being the Phoenix, rather than Dark Phoenix Jean being a Phoenix-created duplicate. To me, it seems like an illogical twist. Retcons should provide clarity and simplify complexities, but this latest one has only added to the confusion.

As a dedicated cinema enthusiast and comic book lover, I’ve noticed a recurring issue that’s been causing quite a stir among superhero fans lately – power scaling. This phenomenon involves fans comparing the abilities of characters to determine who is objectively the most powerful. Now, let me tell you, this is a concept that’s flawed on numerous levels, with the most straightforward being that each character’s power level is as strong or weak as the story demands it to be.

Take Marvel, for instance, which boasts some truly overpowered heroes. However, the Phoenix Force takes things to another level, becoming a cosmic entity of death and rebirth capable of annihilating entire diseased universes. Introducing this force into the Marvel Universe, under Jean Grey’s control, has created quite a conundrum for creators dealing with an all-powerful entity in a universe already teeming with characters like Thor and Eternity.

In earlier times, the Phoenix Force was powerful, yes, but not universe-destroying powerful. However, things have changed drastically now, as creators have transformed it into something it wasn’t originally intended to be. The Phoenix Force, in its current form, is like power scaling fan fiction – it may lead to intriguing narratives, but it’s mostly just that.

Unfortunately, this transformation has made Jean Grey a less captivating character in recent times. It seems only Chris Claremont and Grant Morrison can craft compelling Phoenix tales, as the stories now revolve more around her powers than her character development. Frankly, since the “Avengers Vs. X-Men” saga, I haven’t seen anything particularly noteworthy from the Phoenix Force.

Nowadays the Phoenix Force Makes Everything Worse

I was thrilled when the Phoenix Force resurfaced lately, primarily because I anticipated Kieron Gillen would be handling it at the tail end of Krakoa Era and due to nostalgia. It seemed appropriate for the Phoenix Force to manifest then, reminding me of Morrison’s New X-Men and how that series handled the Phoenix Force. However, over time I’ve come to realize that this latest revival has been a misstep. It seems as though no one knows how to effectively utilize it, with those who could, like Al Ewing, absent from the X-Men team. For many Jean Grey fans, Phoenix has turned out to be quite a letdown, as indicated by its declining sales.

In simpler terms, the Phoenix Force was initially intriguing as it delved into the characters’ personal growth rather than just their power. However, over time, it’s been reduced to a tool in debates online and hasn’t produced a truly exceptional story for quite some time. The Phoenix Force has become detrimental to the Marvel Universe, and creating a compelling narrative to reverse this trend seems challenging, given the current capabilities of the X-office.

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/10-best-wolverine-stories-20s-marvel-comics/embed/#

Read More

2025-08-08 22:18