‘They Really Maligned Our Films.’ The OG Fantastic Four Was Panned By Critics, But One Star Thinks They Got It Wrong

The Debate Surrounding “The Fantastic Four: Rise and Shine”

Recently, there has been considerable discussion about “The Fantastic Four: First Steps,” as Matt Shakman’s film marks the entrance of the iconic superhero quartet into the Marvel Cinematic Universe. While both fans and critics have generally praised the movie, some still hold a soft spot for the FF films from the 2000s. Although these two films garnered a dedicated following, they were met with criticism when they initially hit theaters. However, one of the cast members, Michael Chiklis, now believes that the initial reviews might not have been entirely accurate.

In Tim Story’s two “Fantastic Four” films, Michael Chiklis portrays Ben Grimm, also known as The Thing. Over time, Chiklis has shown great pride for the superhero series he was part of in the early 2000s. Despite this, during an interview with Collider, the seasoned actor passionately argued why these two superhero movies are still overlooked or “underrated” today. When making his case, Chiklis highlighted the strong affection that fans have for these films.

Many people, as I perceive, had misjudged these films, often criticizing them harshly. However, the public held them in high regard, and I believe they were unfairly underestimated given their popularity. It’s one of those situations where critics didn’t quite appreciate the films, but the audience certainly did, and that trend persists to this day. I’ve always found myself thinking, “Say what you will, but the people have spoken.

In 2005, the film version of Fantastic Four debuted to mostly unfavorable critic reviews, currently boasting a 28% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes (and a more positive 45% rating from audiences). Despite this, it managed to be financially successful, raking in over $333 million globally while spending between $87.5 and $100 million to produce. The sequel, Rise of the Silver Surfer, released in 2007, also received mixed reviews, earning a 37% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes with an audience approval rating of 51%. However, it still managed to gross $301.9 million against a production budget between $120 and $130 million.

Despite some mixed reactions to the two Fantastic Four films, it’s clear that a dedicated fanbase continues to cherish these movies. Michael Chiklis, in particular, highlighted the enthusiasm shown toward these supposedly flawed movies.

Now, after all these years, it seems folks are finally admitting that these films are enjoyable, family-oriented flicks… they managed to get many things correct. Despite their flaws, they’re truly excellent motion pictures.

More on Michael Chiklis

During the filming of Fantastic Four, Michael Chiklis, who is known as an actor and a Boston Celtics fan, reportedly used an expletive directed at basketball legend Magic Johnson.

The influence of the specific “Fantastic Four” films remains strong and is occasionally acknowledged in titles like “Deadpool” and “Wolverine”. In one such instance, Chris Evans reprises his character as Johnny Storm (The Human Torch), whose comedic role unfortunately leads to a tragic end. However, on a more emotional note, the closing credits of this third installment contain heartwarming behind-the-scenes footage from Tim Story’s “Fantastic Four” productions, demonstrating that there are still many who hold fond memories of these movies.

Michael Chiklis, known for vigorously supporting his films, has also shown enthusiasm for the upcoming project First Steps. He posted a heartfelt message on social media, acknowledging the transition of the Thing role to Ebon Moss-Bachrach and extending well wishes to the entire cast and crew. Over time, it’s probable that fans will continue debating their favorite big-screen adaptations of Marvel’s First Family, with each person having their unique perspective. In essence, everyone is allowed their own preferences.

With Disney+, you can enjoy Marvel titles like the Fantastic Four movies. For an ad-supported plan, it’s only $9.99 per month, or go ad-free for $15.99 monthly. You can also save 16% by pre-paying $159.99 for a year of service. Check out the deal here!

Discover “The Fantastic Four: First Steps,” one of this year’s highly anticipated films, now playing in cinemas. For those yearning for a blast from the past, you can stream the Tim Story-directed films by subscribing to Disney+.

Read More

2025-08-12 21:16