This Is Still the Gold Standard of Game Remakes

by

Remaking and updating older games is common in the gaming world, and we’ve seen a lot of classics get new life recently. However, sometimes these remakes don’t quite hit the mark. They can either feel too similar to the original, offering little new, or stray too far, losing what made the original game special.

Many games successfully modernize classic titles, improving the graphics and gameplay for new players while still honoring what fans loved about the originals. Nintendo has consistently delivered strong remakes, as seen with games like Fire Emblem, The Legend of Zelda, and Metroid. But arguably their best remake came over two decades ago, and it perfectly demonstrates the key to a truly great remake.

Why Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen Were Ideal Remakes

Released first in Japan on January 29, 2004, and then worldwide later that year, Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen were completely rebuilt versions of the original Pokémon Red and Blue games. These remakes arrived eight years after the initial releases that captured the world’s attention, and they largely maintained the same story, gameplay, and world. Players explore a world filled with Pokémon, catch and train monsters, battle other trainers, and defeat Team Rocket as they strive to become Pokémon champions. The remakes improved the classic turn-based battles and monster-catching, adding more strategic depth with a wider variety of moves, each with its own special characteristics.

Following the improvements seen in games like Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire, FireRed and LeafGreen were a fantastic reimagining of the original games. They updated the visuals and added new features to make the gameplay even better. Although some reviewers weren’t impressed with the graphics, the classic top-down perspective still captured the spirit of the original. The remakes also incorporated ideas and content from later games, offering a richer story and new experiences. For longtime fans, it was a wonderful way to relive the original adventure, while newcomers could enjoy a classic game with modern improvements. With a score of 81/100 on Metacritic, these remakes are now seen as a perfect example of how to update a beloved game.

Why Gaming Remakes Are So Tricky

Recreating an older game is surprisingly difficult. It’s often questionable whether a remake is worthwhile, especially if it doesn’t offer anything truly new. In those cases, simply re-releasing or remastering the original is usually a better option. Some remakes, like those of Silent Hill and Resident Evil in recent years, have been very loyal to the originals, but they’ve sometimes sacrificed some of the original’s unique personality to make the gameplay more standard.

Remakes like Advance Wars 1+2: Re-Boot Camp offer a polished update to familiar games, successfully modernizing the gameplay and stories. However, they often feel like a presentation of the original rather than a true improvement. The most successful remakes demonstrate a clear appreciation for the source material, staying true to the original concepts while also enhancing the overall experience. It’s a delicate balance, particularly now when remakes or remasters can sometimes eclipse the games that initially gained everyone’s attention.

Pokémon’s First Remake Stands Out Even Two Decades Later

Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen are excellent remakes because they successfully blend the familiar story and gameplay of the original games with the more complex strategies found in later Pokémon titles. They enrich the experience by adding new features and expanding on the story, all while staying true to the original characters and world. This approach makes the remakes feel substantial and worthwhile, going beyond a simple visual update to offer a genuinely improved and more complete game.

FireRed and LeafGreen subtly enhance the original story, expand the game world in a seamless way, and add enjoyable complexity to battles. They were also designed to connect with newer Pokémon games, allowing players to use all 150 original creatures alongside the latest generations. Even after over two decades, these remakes demonstrate how effectively a game can be reimagined – offering a richer experience while staying faithful to the spirit of the original.

Read More

2026-01-31 19:11