This Is the Best Adventure Game of All Time, and It’s Not Even Close

by

The word ‘adventure’ is used a lot in gaming, but often doesn’t really capture what it means. We tend to label any game with a large world and open-ended goals as an ‘adventure,’ but true adventure is much more than that. It’s not about how big the game is or how impressive it looks. It’s about feeling curious and realizing that your choices can have significant and unpredictable consequences – leading to either amazing discoveries or terrible setbacks.

I firmly believe in the headline: Elden Ring is the greatest adventure game of all time, and it’s not a close competition. I have a deep fondness for Knights of the Old Republic, which greatly influenced my gaming preferences and appreciation for storytelling. However, Elden Ring achieves something truly unique. It seamlessly integrates adventure into every aspect of the game – it’s how you play, what drives you, and what you’re rewarded for – all without excessive hand-holding or unnecessary explanations. The game trusts you to discover things for yourself.

Elden Ring Understands What “Adventure” Actually Means

As a gamer, what I really want from an open world isn’t just a list of things to do, or being led around on rails. It’s about genuinely exploring, not knowing what’s around the corner, and being trusted to figure things out as they happen. Honestly, a lot of modern open-world games seem scared of that. They feel the need to mark everything on the map, over-explain everything, and basically remove any challenge. It’s like they’re afraid of letting you actually feel lost. And when they do that, they ruin the adventure, honestly. It’s a total misunderstanding of what makes these games fun in the first place.

Unlike many games, Elden Ring intentionally throws you into its world with very little explanation or guidance. You won’t find a list of things to do; instead, you’re placed in a vast land that doesn’t immediately reveal its secrets. This feeling of exploration – stumbling upon something interesting in the distance and deciding whether to check it out – is at the heart of the game’s adventure. Elden Ring focuses on creating that sense of wonder and unpredictability, where every encounter is a surprise and could either help or hinder your progress.

The problem is that open-world games have largely lost the feeling of true exploration and danger. Ideally, these worlds should feel unpredictable, but now, as soon as you pull up the map, everything feels safe and predictable. You immediately see clearly marked locations needing your help, and enemies become easy targets. While you might have choices in how you approach them – stealthily or with force – it doesn’t really matter, because the challenge is minimal. This lack of genuine threat turns the whole experience into a routine process.

Unlike many games, Elden Ring doesn’t hold your hand. The constant risk of danger makes finding new areas, shortcuts, and defeating bosses truly rewarding. The game doesn’t guarantee success or point you in the right direction – it simply lets you explore and try your best.

A World That Doesn’t Need to Explain Itself

One of the best things about Elden Ring is that it doesn’t hold your hand or explain everything. The world feels real and lived-in, existing independently of your understanding, and that’s what makes it so special. You’re just one small part of a much larger, ancient world, and the game immediately conveys that feeling. Unlike many games, it doesn’t constantly interrupt you with explanations or treat its story like a guided tour. Instead, the lore is discovered through exploring crumbling ruins, observing enemy placement, reading item descriptions, and simply experiencing the quiet moments – allowing you to piece the story together yourself.

As a huge fan, what really gets me about Elden Ring is how it understands adventure. For me, a great adventure needs mystery, and this game is full of it. If a game spells everything out for you, where’s the fun in discovering things? Elden Ring doesn’t do that – it trusts you to figure things out yourself, to connect the dots and build your own understanding of the world. Honestly, you can spend ages digging into the backstory and hidden details if you want, or you can just focus on surviving and exploring, and both ways to play feel equally good. It never forces you down a certain path, but it always makes you feel rewarded for whatever you choose to do.

This sense of trust also applies to the game’s world design. The Lands Between aren’t structured to simply guide you from one major event to the next. Instead, they’re designed to intrigue you. A faraway tower, a huge glowing tree on the horizon, or even a frightening shape in the mist can draw you away from your intended route, leading you into a separate story that existed long before your arrival. These choices can lead to incredible discoveries or harsh lessons, but the world always reacts truthfully, and that honesty is what truly sets Elden Ring apart.

Looking back on my experience with the game, it wasn’t the planned events that I remember most. It was the personal, unscripted moments – like getting lost and discovering areas before I was supposed to, unexpectedly facing a tough boss and figuring out how to win, or finding a beautiful hidden spot and just taking it all in. These weren’t designed experiences or things to check off a list; they were unique adventures, and that’s what made the game so special.

Elden Ring is the ultimate open-world adventure because true freedom comes with genuine challenges. Discovering something feels special only if it’s not handed to you. Above all, the game recognizes that players want to feel like they’re exploring uncharted territory, not just following a guided tour. It’s not just the best Souls game or the most visually stunning open world; it’s the most authentic adventure gaming has ever offered. Until another game trusts players as much as Elden Ring does, it will remain unmatched, casting a long shadow over the entire genre.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

Read More

2026-02-07 00:15