This Mahershala Ali Cult Classic Was the Sleeper Sci-Fi TV Event of the 2000s

by

Mahershala Ali is a major star today, but before his success in films, he had some notable television roles. Back in 2004, when he was still known by his birth name, Mahershalalhashbaz, he played a key part in the popular sci-fi series The 4400 on the USA Network.

While it never became as widely popular as shows like Lost or Heroes, The 4400 was just as skillfully made. In fact, it’s had a greater impact on later science fiction shows. Today, it’s remembered as one of the best sci-fi series that didn’t receive the attention it deserved.

Ali Was Incredible as Richard Tyler in The 4400

As a film buff, I’ve always loved uncovering those hidden gems from the 2000s, and this show is definitely one of them. It starts with a really cool premise: multiple government agencies pick up on what they think is a comet heading straight for Earth. Naturally, they don’t hesitate – they launch missiles to try and destroy it, believing it’s an unavoidable disaster for all of us.

When initial attempts to destroy the object fail, people start to panic. The situation becomes even more unsettling when the object unexpectedly slows down, revealing that it’s being controlled – and isn’t a comet as everyone thought. This realization is reinforced when a massive sphere of light lands near Seattle, Washington, suggesting something extraordinary is happening.

From this bright flash of light, 4,400 people suddenly appear, representing all ages and backgrounds. None of them remember how they arrived or their past. It quickly becomes clear that each person was taken by a green beam of light sometime in the last sixty years, and they’ve all been returned at the same age they were when they disappeared.

It’s already unusual that someone would vanish and then reappear after years, but characters like Richard Tyler, played by Ali, find it incredibly hard to process. Tyler was abducted in 1951 and returned 53 years later to a world completely foreign to him. Ali delivers a brilliant performance, convincingly portraying Tyler’s fear and confusion, while also highlighting his fundamental goodness.

I was totally hooked from the start! It’s crazy – Tyler suddenly finds himself stuck in quarantine with all 4,400 people who just reappeared. And the government? They’re scrambling! Homeland Security puts this special team in charge, and they assign two agents to figure out what’s going on with everyone. These returnees quickly become known as ‘The 4400,’ and honestly, they’re treated like a potential problem right away.

Baldwin and Skouris, the show’s main investigators, aren’t convinced the events were caused by aliens. As more of the 4400 start developing unusual powers, solving the mystery only becomes harder.

The 4400 Deals With Very Modern Social and Political Themes

This highlights how society often fails to learn from history, but also proves that the show’s creators, Rene Echevarria and Scott Peters, aimed for more than just exciting science fiction. They deliberately connected the characters to the experiences of historically marginalized groups.

While some, like Baldwin and Skouris, are open-minded about the returned 4400 and curious about their impact on the world, others respond with hostility and fear. This situation strongly echoes the story of the X-Men, where, similar to the 4400, individuals have their identities exposed publicly against their will and are ultimately confined to internment camps.

The show explores the challenges faced by people returning after being missing for years – both their struggles to adapt to a changed world and their families’ difficulties reintegrating them. These stressful and emotionally draining situations can actually amplify the returnees’ unique abilities, sometimes leading to accidental harm, which unfortunately fuels the public’s fear and distrust.

The show cleverly explores the new lives of the 4400, creating a complex situation where it’s hard to pick a side. While some humans act as villains, many of those who returned have troubling perspectives, making it difficult to know who to support.

I’ve been following Jordan Collier’s story, and he’s a really fascinating, yet unsettling, character. He’s this incredibly charismatic real estate guy who disappeared back in 2002. When he reappeared, he created the 4400 Center – a safe haven for those who returned with special abilities. It’s clear he thinks a conflict with the government is coming, and he’s become something of a leader, almost like a savior, for many of the 4400 who feel lost and powerless. They’re really starting to look up to him and rally around his ideas.

As his following increases, he creates a secluded community for the 4400, isolating them from the rest of the world. His views become increasingly extreme, even advocating for the elimination of those outside his group. He believes everyone on Earth should receive an injection of promicin – the substance that gives the 4400 their powers – even though the injection has a fifty percent chance of being fatal, causing a brain aneurysm.

A Writer’s Strike Sadly Cut The 4400 Short After Four Seasons

Throughout the four seasons of The 4400, Mahershala Ali’s acting became more complex as his character developed. His character, Tyler, sometimes worked with Agent Collier, and at other times, strongly opposed him. He even became the public spokesperson for the 4400 at one point. A central part of his storyline focused on his connection with Lily, another member of the 4400 and the granddaughter of a woman he loved decades earlier, and her daughter, Isabelle.

Isabelle, the first child born within the 4400 community, is immediately seen as unique, though it’s uncertain if she’ll use her abilities for good. When she suddenly ages twenty years and is portrayed by Megalyn Echikunwoke, her powers grow significantly, forcing Tyler to oppose her as she becomes the show’s biggest threat.

Even as the show’s plots become more unbelievable, Ali consistently portrays Tyler with genuine emotion. He manages to make even the most far-fetched situations – like having to stop his superpowered daughter by injecting her with a serum from future humans who originally abducted the 4400 – feel believable to the audience.

By the end of Season 4, Tyler faced many challenges and ended up in jail. Everyone anticipated Ali’s return for Season 5, but a writer’s strike allowed the studio time to consider the show’s rising costs. Ultimately, The 4400 was canceled because the show had become too expensive to produce.

In total, four novels were released to accompany the show, with the last two set after the fourth season. Interestingly, the final book didn’t provide a clear resolution, instead ending on a cliffhanger like the series itself. While fans were disappointed, they could still fondly remember the 44 episodes that aired. Plus, they knew The 4400 was…

Surprisingly, The CW tried to bring back the show in 2021 with a new version simply called 4400, but it was almost universally disliked and quickly cancelled after just one season. Perhaps fans actually preferred the original The 4400 as a beloved, four-season show that also helped launch the career of a major Hollywood star.

Read More

2025-12-14 05:41