Why I Refuse To Accept Nightmare Before Christmas As A Halloween Movie

by

Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before Christmas is a classic holiday film, and it’s always puzzled me when people also consider it a Halloween movie. Created by Tim Burton and brilliantly animated with stop-motion by Henry Selick and his team, it’s a wonderfully dark and funny movie.

As a huge fan, I just think this movie is special – everything from the music to the characters and how it looks just feels timeless. It’s definitely a movie for the holidays, and it really hits on those classic themes you see this time of year. But honestly? Even with all the spooky stuff, it doesn’t really feel like a Halloween movie to me.

Nightmare Before Christmas Isn’t A Halloween Movie

I firmly believe that The Nightmare Before Christmas isn’t a great choice for a Halloween movie. It truly shines as a story deeply connected to the traditions we associate with Christmas. The film centers around Jack Skellington and the inhabitants of Halloween Town, and their spooky nature is fundamental to who they are.

It makes sense why people might think of these characters as perfect for Halloween. However, that’s not my issue with showing the movie so early in the season. While the characters are fine, the movie itself doesn’t really capture the feelings or storytelling elements we usually associate with Halloween.

The movie The Nightmare Before Christmas begins just as Halloween ends. The residents of Halloween Town are already getting ready for the next Halloween, but Jack Skellington is feeling restless and uninspired. This leads him to stumble upon Christmas Town and a whole new world.

The movie takes place after Halloween night is over, and it’s full of jokes about how the people of Halloween Town struggle to understand anything that isn’t spooky. Besides Oogie Boogie, the characters aren’t really villains – they’re just a group who really love scary things. It doesn’t have many of the typical elements you’d expect in a Halloween movie.

Even when the characters finally experience a beautiful snowy night, courtesy of Santa, their winter traditions still have a slightly spooky twist. This difference between the typical holiday cheer and their darker take on things is a major source of the film’s comedy and is central to the plot, but it doesn’t turn the movie into a Halloween story.

The Thematic Core Of Nightmare Before Christmas Is What Makes It A Holiday Film

Despite being set in Halloween Town and featuring spooky characters, The Nightmare Before Christmas isn’t really about Halloween. The movie’s core message and emotional story are more similar to those found in traditional Christmas or holiday films, focusing on themes of belonging and finding your place.

At its heart, The Nightmare Before Christmas is a story about discovering happiness and spreading it to those around you, beautifully shown through Sally’s affection for Jack and his eventual understanding of how much she means to him. Jack initially tries to change Christmas to fit his own perspective, which leads to chaos, but he learns from his errors and finds fresh ways to celebrate Halloween’s spookiness.

This film shows how different cultures can live together without losing what makes them special. By the end, the people of Halloween Town come to appreciate the spirit of the season and celebrate it in their own unique way. Ultimately, it’s a story about valuing the people you love instead of pursuing unrealistic and self-centered goals.

Unlike Christmas movies, Halloween films delve into the darker sides of life. They often explore themes of death, trauma, and simply trying to survive, highlighting the dangers that can come from both the mysterious and the everyday. A key idea in these movies is how rules and boundaries can keep you safe, and what happens when people ignore them – often facing harsh consequences in a world that doesn’t hesitate to be unforgiving.

At their heart, many Halloween movies show us that appearances can be deceiving – someone who looks scary might actually be a good person. While The Nightmare Before Christmas touches on this idea, it’s really just one part of the film’s broader look at the true meaning of the holidays.

Halloween and Christmas movies usually focus on completely different themes. Although The Nightmare Before Christmas includes spooky characters and ideas, at its heart it’s about universal human desires—like wanting to belong and share joy—that can be found through the spirit of togetherness and the holidays. Ultimately, it’s a story about discovering the magic of Christmas, even in a town dedicated to Halloween.

You’re welcome to enjoy The Nightmare Before Christmas as a Halloween film if you like, but for me, it just doesn’t fit. I think it’s best watched during the winter holidays, when people are more focused on thinking about themselves and accepting others. It’s a movie I love and I really feel it loses something when watched at other times of the year.

Read More

2025-12-07 18:19