10 Most Overused Tropes in X-Men Comics That Really Need to End

As a huge comic fan, I’ve always found the X-Men to be one of the most fascinating superhero franchises. Back in the Silver Age, the big, character-focused storytelling Marvel was known for just didn’t quite click with audiences for the X-Men. Things *really* took off when Chris Claremont came on board as the writer. Seriously, Claremont is responsible for pretty much everything people love about the X-Men. He brilliantly blended the drama of soap operas with all the wildness of superheroes, and then threw in sci-fi, fantasy, even psychological elements, plus really important themes like civil rights. It all came together in Uncanny X-Men to create a comic that’s become a true classic. Claremont established so many iconic X-Men tropes, and he definitely wasn’t the last writer to add to them!

All superheroes and teams of heroes have common themes that show what they’re good at. But sometimes, these themes become repetitive and annoying. Certain X-Men tropes that fans used to enjoy are now overdone, and these ten are the ones we’re ready to see disappear for good. It’s time to move past them.

10. Magneto Was Right

As a huge fan of the X-Men, I’ve always been fascinated by Magneto. He’s such a complex character! His conviction that mutants are superior, especially when you consider his own history as a Holocaust survivor, really makes him someone fans connect with. But over time, the way we see Magneto has definitely shifted. He’s gone from being portrayed as a straightforward villain to someone a lot of people sympathize with. In fact, a lot of fans – and even characters *within* the comics – actually think Magneto was right! This has created this whole “Magneto was right” trope, where people tend to excuse his more extreme actions by pointing to his past and the fact that he’s fighting for a group who’ve been oppressed. But let’s be real, Magneto is still a racist mass murderer, and it’s important we don’t forget that. He’s a *great* character, absolutely, but it’s his sheer complexity and how interesting he is that makes him so compelling, not because he’s actually right. It’s a nuanced portrayal, and that’s what I appreciate.

9. Unending Plot Lines

Chris Claremont is credited with making the X-Men a success, largely through the use of ongoing storylines. He’d introduce plots that would develop subtly in the background of individual issues, gradually building tension until they became central to the narrative. This technique kept readers invested in the X-Men comics, eager to see how these complex threads would resolve. While writers after Claremont have attempted similar approaches, the results are often disappointing. The 1990s provide a clear example: storylines launched in 1991 sometimes didn’t reach a satisfying conclusion until 1999. It’s frankly quite absurd, and this tendency unfortunately continues even today.

8. Evil Xavier

Over time, Xavier has increasingly been portrayed as a villain, which has become quite frustrating. While he was always depicted as somewhat questionable, this became a major storyline in X-Men comics during the 2000s. It was revealed that the Danger Room had gained sentience, and Xavier had enslaved it. He then formed a team of X-Men to liberate the original team from Krakoa, but they were killed, and Xavier erased everyone’s memories of them. This pattern continued, with Xavier constantly engaging in questionable acts with his mental powers or harboring dark secrets. This is a significant departure from the Xavier that most fans have come to know, particularly those familiar with the movies or TV shows. It’s time to move past this trope, as it has made Xavier a rather predictable character.

7. “Age of” Stories

“The Age of Apocalypse” is a beloved X-Men story, but it has unfortunately popularized a problematic pattern. While “The Age of Apocalypse” was the first time X-Men fans explored an alternate reality, it certainly wasn’t the last. We saw this with “Age of X” in the mid to late 2000s, then “Age of X-Man” in 2019, plus multiple follow-ups to the original “The Age of Apocalypse.” “Age of Revelation” is the newest story in this trend. These stories can be enjoyable, and a well-executed “Age of Apocalypse” tale is truly impressive, but the X-Men comics have revisited this concept too many times, which has ultimately been detrimental. None of the subsequent stories have lived up to the original, and they’ve suffered from diminishing returns. It’s a case of repeating a formula without achieving the same impact.

6. Dark Dystopian Futures

“Days of Future Past” really kicked off the trend of dystopian futures, inspiring many stories that followed. Now, it’s common to see superheroes fail in future timelines, and that’s compelling because it shows us how they cope with their most desperate moments. Seeing them lose-even die-can be powerful. However, the X-Men comics have explored so many of these dark futures that the idea has become overdone. While every X-Men fan likely has a favorite, that’s part of why we need to move past them. We simply don’t need these bleak futures anymore.

5. X-Men Fighting X-Men

As a longtime fan, I’ve gotta say, seeing superheroes brawl with each other is getting old, and it’s become a real trend at Marvel. It’s been a particular issue with the X-Men. We’ve seen so many instances over the years of different X-Men teams turning on each other. Remember when the X-Men and X-Force were constantly at odds? It always feels like there are different groups within the X-Men fighting, like during the Schism era and what’s happening now in the “From the Ashes” era. Honestly, it’s just one of those frustrating things with superhero comics that needs to stop. The X-Men are at their best when they feel like a family, and this constant infighting really ruins that. I just wish they’d focus on a common enemy instead of each other!

4. Too Much Focus on Wolverine

I’m a big Wolverine fan, like a lot of other X-Men enthusiasts, but honestly, sometimes it feels like there’s *too* much Wolverine. He’s definitely the most popular character in the whole X-Men universe, which means he always gets most of the attention. And that can be great – his backstory is really engaging! But when the focus is *always* on him, it leaves other characters, the ones who don’t have their own solo comics, in the shadows. He already *has* his own book, is part of several teams, and pops up everywhere in the Marvel universe. We don’t need *every* X-Men story to revolve around him. I think Wolverine works best in team books when he’s used in moderation, because otherwise he just tends to overshadow everyone else. It’s a delicate balance, but it would be nice to see more focus on the rest of the team!

3. Every Non-Mutant Hero Is an Enemy

A common issue within the Marvel Universe is the unequal treatment of heroes. While the X-Men often face fear and prejudice, other superpowered individuals, like the Avengers, are generally celebrated and enjoy a strong connection with the government. Whenever the Avengers appear in an X-Men story, they’re often portrayed as adversaries due to their ties to authority and humanity. This pattern extends to most non-mutant heroes featured in the X-Men comics. The X-Men frequently take a moral high ground against these heroes, but this has become repetitive and frustrating. It’s time for non-mutant heroes to stop being automatically cast as the villains in X-Men storylines. This shift is long overdue, and has been for quite some time.

2. Mutants Losing Their Powers

House of M caused most mutants to lose their abilities, but this wasn’t the first instance of that happening. Throughout the history of the X-Men comics, characters have repeatedly had their powers taken away. If you can name a significant X-Men character, chances are they’ve lost their powers at least once. They’ve all experienced a weakening or complete loss of their abilities at some point, and it’s become quite repetitive. While this plot device is fairly common in superhero comics overall, it’s time for it to stop.

1. Mutant Genocide

It’s difficult to say exactly when the idea of mutants being wiped out began. Some believe “Days of Future Past” started this trend. Others point to “Mutant Massacre” as the origin. However, “E Is for Extinction” was the first time readers witnessed it happening on a large scale, with the instantaneous death of 16 million mutants on Genosha. From that point on, the idea of mutant genocide-and the threat of it-became a common theme in X-Men comics. Many fans dislike this trope because it often leads to overly dark and depressing storylines, shifting the focus away from the more enjoyable aspects of X-Men. I, for one, would be thrilled to never read another mutant genocide story in the X-Men, and many other fans feel the same way.

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/10-best-x-men-stories-20s-marvel-comics/embed/#

2025-10-04 02:42