10 Perfect Actors to Replace Chris Evans As Captain America (If He’s Recast)

by

Secret Wars.” The MCU boss, Kevin Feige, has hinted that this 2027 film will bring about a major change, merging all timelines into one. This could potentially lead to some key characters being replaced, such as Captain America who hasn’t appeared in the MCU since “Avengers: Endgame” in 2019.

Chris Evans first portrayed Steve Rogers (Captain America) in the 2011 film “Captain America: The First Avenger,” and over the next eight years, he became a key character in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). Evans was featured in at least one MCU movie every year of his involvement, but in “Avengers: Endgame,” Rogers retired and journeyed to an alternate timeline to find a happy ending. Although there are rumors that Evans might reprise the role in upcoming films like “Avengers: Doomsday” and “Secret Wars,” Marvel Studios could potentially replace him following the MCU’s reboot, and these ten actors would be ideal for the part.

10) Sam Worthington

Sam Worthington’s career can be divided into two distinct phases. On one side, he is widely recognized for his role as Jake Sully in the record-breaking Avatar series by James Cameron. However, much of his other work has not fared well critically or at the box office. It’s believed that Worthington could benefit from greater recognition beyond the Avatar franchise. The possibility of him being cast as a new Steve Rogers offers this opportunity. His physical stature, fame, and action background make him an excellent fit for the role, while his demonstrated leadership abilities could be valuable in a fresh take on the Avengers team.

9) Garrett Hedlund

In the future of Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), it might be interesting for Marvel Studios to consider Garrett Hedlund, who was initially in the running for the role of Steve Rogers, for a potential comeback. Back then, he had to decline the part due to his commitment to Tron: Legacy. Since then, Hedlund has shown versatility and charisma in various roles, yet hasn’t landed that breakthrough part yet. Casting him as a new Steve Rogers in the MCU could potentially catapult his career, offering fans a grittier, more authentic take on Captain America.

8) Stephen Amell

Stephen Amell, famously recognized for his portrayal of Oliver Queen in The CW’s Arrow series, might switch from DC to Marvel to embody a new Steve Rogers. If Marvel opts for a more youthful version of the character, this role might not transpire; however, Amell has demonstrated his prowess in action scenes and dramatic performances through roles in Code 8, Heels, Suits LA, and possesses the ideal build and recognizable persona to tackle such an iconic character. Given that he previously led a superhero team on DC TV’s Arrow, he could potentially lead the Avengers as well.

7) Colton Haynes

Stephen Amell would make a good pick as Steve Rogers’ replacement for Chris Evans, but his Arrow co-star Colton Haynes could potentially be the more suitable choice. Haynes showcased his versatility as an actor in roles such as Roy Harper’s Red Arrow and Arsenal on Arrow, as well as appearances in Teen Wolf, American Horror Story, Dollface, San Andreas, and other productions. He possesses a youthful yet powerful appearance, which aligns with the physical requirements for Steve Rogers following his transformation. Moreover, Haynes lent his voice to Thor in the Marvel Avengers Academy video game back in 2016, suggesting that he might already be on Marvel’s radar for a live-action role.

6) Scott Eastwood

In simpler terms, Scott Eastwood, known as Clint Eastwood’s son, possesses the right physical build, charisma, leadership traits, and action background that could make him suitable to play Steve Rogers in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). Much like Garrett Hedlund, Scott Eastwood was considered for the role of Captain America prior to Chris Evans’ casting. Given his youth, there’s a chance he could still be selected for this character in the future. With experience from superhero films such as “Suicide Squad,” and major franchises including “Fast & Furious,” “Pacific Rim,” and “Texas Chainsaw,” Scott Eastwood seems well-prepared for an MCU role.

5) Chris Carmack

Known for his roles in “The OC”, “Nashville”, and “Grey’s Anatomy”, Chris Carmack is a popular choice among fans who see him as an ideal candidate to play Steve Rogers in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). His muscular build and action-filled acting skills make him a suitable match, but what truly sets him apart is his knack for comedic timing and emotional depth – traits that are essential for roles within the MCU.

In a way similar to Hedlund, Chris Carmack could portray an older version of Steve Rogers, which might not align with the MCU’s current direction. Nevertheless, casting him as Steve Rogers remains a plausible option.

4) Nick Robinson

Following breakout performances in films like “The Kings of Summer”, “Jurassic World”, and “Love Simon”, Nick Robinson has clearly demonstrated his exceptional acting abilities. Despite not possessing the robust muscular build needed for Steve Rogers’ Captain America at this time, many actors have adapted themselves for Marvel Cinematic Universe roles, and Robinson could very well be the next one. His honest and wholesome demeanor, coupled with his vibrant, young American spirit, makes him an ideal candidate to succeed Chris Evans in the role. Given his youth, he also offers ample opportunity for the character to develop and evolve over time.

3) Glen Powell

Glen Powell’s career has been rapidly ascending, marked by significant appearances in movies like “Top Gun: Maverick,” “Anyone But You,” and “Twisters.” These roles have catapulted him into the spotlight as a highly sought-after talent. It seems he’s positioning himself for a part in a prominent superhero series, and many believe he would shine as a new interpretation of Steve Rogers. His performance in “Top Gun” demonstrated his ability to portray self-assured characters with hints of arrogance, while his other standout roles have showcased his charm and on-screen magnetism. Although Powell has not yet discussed any negotiations with Marvel, it’s possible that this situation could shift soon.

2) Jacob Elordi

Jacob Elordi, at just 28 years old, could potentially be an ideal young actor for Marvel to consider when re-casting Steve Rogers in the MCU. Elordi gained popularity through his role in Euphoria, but has also made a name for himself in projects like Saltburn, Priscilla, and The Kissing Booth film series. His career is continuing to grow with upcoming roles in Frankenstein and Wuthering Heights. While Elordi possesses the acting talent and recognition required for Captain America, he has expressed a preference for more serious, grounded, and artistically rewarding roles, so it’s uncertain if a superhero franchise role would suit him.

1) Patrick Gibson

In terms of fitting the role, Charlie Heaton could make a remarkable Steve Rogers, but Patrick Gibson might be an even more suitable choice; he hasn’t ruled out joining the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) yet. Gibson has garnered recognition for his roles in shows like The OA, The Darkest Minds, and Dexter: Original Sin, many of which involve portraying characters with supernatural abilities, making him a strong candidate for an MCU role. Gibson’s physical features, including his blond hair and blue eyes, complement the description of Steve Rogers well, and his acting prowess extends beyond comedy to delivering intense, emotional performances with great precision.

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/every-version-of-captain-america-ranked/embed/#

Read More

2025-08-17 19:46