10 Weirdly Underrated Marvel Retcons That Rewrote Decades of Broken Lore

by

As a comic book critic, I often hear fans complain about ‘retcons’ – that’s retroactive continuity, basically changing established history. And honestly, a lot of the time, the criticism is deserved! Nobody wants to see a beloved character’s backstory suddenly altered for no good reason. But here’s the thing: retcons aren’t *always* bad. In fact, they’re a vital tool for comic book writers. They allow creators to tidy up messy plotlines, simplify confusing details, or even free a character from a stale direction. When handled well, a retcon doesn’t destroy a story, it *improves* it, adding depth and making things more compelling. It’s about enhancing the narrative, not ruining it.

Interestingly, many popular and accepted parts of comic book history are actually retcons – changes to previously established storylines. A prime example is Captain America being frozen at the end of World War II. While it was a significant change, it became central to his character, portraying him as a man lost in time. So, to highlight the positive side of something often criticized, we’re going to explore ten Marvel retcons that improved the stories, but don’t always get the recognition they deserve.

10) Wolverine’s Healing Factor

Wolverine is famous for being nearly indestructible, but that wasn’t always true. When he first appeared in comics, as a villain in *The Incredible Hulk* and later as an X-Man, his powers were limited to his claws, adamantium skeleton, and enhanced senses. It wasn’t until *Uncanny X-Men* #142 – seven years after his debut – that he developed his incredible healing ability. While hints of faster healing appeared briefly before, this was the first time readers saw him recover from a serious injury during a fight. Even then, his healing wasn’t as powerful as it would later become. It’s hard to picture Wolverine without his rapid healing, but for a long time, he simply didn’t have it.

9) Cable Is Nathan Summers

When Cable first appeared in Marvel comics, he was initially very similar to the character the Terminator – a mysterious time traveler with unclear ties to the present. His background wasn’t fully developed at first, and early stories hinted he might even be the time-traveling father of Mister Fantastic. However, his official origin wasn’t established until the *Cable* comic series in 1993. It was then revealed he was Nathan Summers, the son of Cyclops and Madelyne Pryor, taken from his parents by the villain Mister Sinister. Now, he’s a central figure in the complicated Summers family, but for a long time, even the writers didn’t fully know his story.

8) Joe Fixit

Most people think of the Hulk as green, but he originally appeared with grey skin. Back then, it was difficult for printers to consistently reproduce grey tones, so the color was changed to green. Later, in *Incredible Hulk* #324, a story explained that the grey Hulk was actually an earlier, less powerful, but more intelligent, form of the transformation. This idea was developed further in *Incredible Hulk* #347 with the introduction of Joe Fixit, the grey Hulk’s alter ego. This concept of multiple Hulk forms paved the way for many other unique versions of the character and introduced a compelling character in Joe Fixit.

7) Uncle Ben’s Famous Quote

The famous line defining Spider-Man – “With great power comes great responsibility” – wasn’t always connected to Uncle Ben. Initially, a narrator spoke these words at the end of Spider-Man’s first comic. Later, in the *Spider-Man vs. Wolverine* comic, it was rewritten as something Uncle Ben actually *said* to Peter. This change was significant because it allowed Peter to directly share the lesson with others, turning a general idea into a specific, memorable quote. Many fans consider this retcon worthwhile simply because it gives Marvel’s most popular hero the chance to deliver their most famous line.

6) Sam Wilson’s Real Origin

Sam Wilson was initially presented as a social worker who befriended Steve Rogers through his commitment to helping others, eventually becoming Captain America’s partner. However, it was later discovered that this backstory was a fabrication. Red Skull used the Cosmic Cube to create a false history for Sam, intending to manipulate him into becoming a sleeper agent and ultimately destroying Captain America.

As a huge Captain America fan, I was really disappointed when they tried to rewrite Sam Wilson’s backstory. Apparently, Skull claimed Sam was this awful stereotype – a pimp connected to the mafia – and that he met Cap after a plane crash on the island. It was just… a mess of negativity. Thankfully, they fixed it in *All-New Captain America* #3! It turned out Red Skull deliberately created that whole story, planting fake memories to try and ruin Sam’s reputation. Honestly, I’m so glad they went back to Sam’s original, amazing origin. It makes way more sense that Skull just threw a bunch of harmful tropes at the wall out of spite, rather than that being Sam’s real past. I’ll take that explanation any day!

5) MJ Knew Peter’s Identity

I’ve always been fascinated by Spider-Man, and one of my favorite reveals is how Mary Jane knew Peter was Spider-Man all along! For so long, he kept that a secret from *everyone*, but it turned out she’d known from the very beginning – it was revealed in *Amazing Spider-Man* #257. It completely changed how I saw her! Suddenly, rereading old issues was amazing because I realized she’d been covering for him the whole time, playing it cool when he was in danger. What’s so brilliant is that it didn’t change *what* happened, just *how* we understood it. It made MJ so much more compelling and proactive, and really fleshed out her character in a way that felt natural and added so much depth. It’s a perfect example of a retcon done right!

4) Alicia Masters the Skrull

Comic book relationships often don’t last, but the connection between the Thing and Alicia Masters feels different – they seem truly meant for each other. It wasn’t always this way, though. At one point, they broke up, and Alicia even married Johnny Storm (the Human Torch) after the Thing stayed away on Battleworld. This caused some fan upset, as Johnny was marrying his friend’s former partner.

The mystery surrounding Johnny Storm’s wife was solved in *Fantastic Four* #357. It turned out she was actually a Skrull impostor named Lyja, sent to spy on the team after they’d taken the real Alicia captive. The Fantastic Four eventually rescued Alicia, which explained why she would have fallen for Johnny and allowed the beloved romance between Thing and Alicia to rekindle – they’re now a happily married couple and parents.

3) The Second Steve Rodgers

As I mentioned before, a really clever story change in comic book history involved Captain America being frozen at the end of World War II. What made it such a big change was the fact that Captain America and Bucky continued having adventures in the 1950s. This was explained in *Captain America* #153, which revealed a fanatical fan named William Burnside discovered how to recreate the original Super Soldier Serum. He even had plastic surgery to look like Steve Rogers and legally changed his name to match, and a Bucky fan did the same. They both used the serum, but without the special Vita-Rays, it drove them insane. This provided a great explanation, introduced a compelling new villain, and neatly resolved any plot holes.

2) Scarlet Spider

I remember when the first Spider-Man clone story happened – it was a huge deal! The Jackal made a copy of Spider-Man, and we all thought he was gone after their fight. But then, in *Spectacular Spider-Man* #216, it turned out he’d actually survived! He reinvented himself as Ben Reilly, and while his return kicked off the often-criticized “Clone Saga,” it also gave us an amazing character. It was incredible to see him rise from what everyone thought was certain death in that smokestack and become a genuinely fantastic hero all on his own.

1) Weapon Plus

As a huge Marvel fan, I have to say the reveal of Wolverine’s true origins is one of the smartest story changes *ever*. It wasn’t just about him being Weapon X, but Weapon 10 – part of a much larger program called Weapon Plus, designed to create the perfect soldier. And get this – the *first* Weapon I was Captain America! Suddenly, everything about Wolverine’s past clicked into place, and it beautifully connected him to Cap in a way I hadn’t even imagined. That issue of *New X-Men*, #128, totally flipped the script on everything we thought we knew. What I love is that it didn’t *erase* anything, it just added layers of awesome backstory and pushed the whole story forward. It’s become so ingrained in the lore that people almost don’t even talk about it anymore, but honestly, it’s the gold standard for how a retcon should be done – it enhances, rather than destroys, what came before.

As a long-time fan, I think there are ten changes the creators made that actually *improved* things, and honestly, they don’t get nearly enough credit! I know retcons often get a bad reputation, but when they’re pulled off well, they can seriously make a comic – and everything that came before and after – so much better. It’s like the whole story gets a boost!

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/comics/news/10-worst-retcons-in-dc-history-superman-wonder-woman-the-flash-new-52/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-18 03:42