3 Buffy the Vampire Slayer Episodes That Still Make No Sense, And One of Them Is Still Perfect

by

While *Buffy the Vampire Slayer* is often considered one of the greatest urban fantasy shows of all time, not every episode was a success. For every truly outstanding episode like “The Body” or “Once More, With Feeling,” there are some that are confusing or just don’t quite work. The show sometimes overextended its themes or explored strange storylines for comedic effect, resulting in episodes that felt underdeveloped and perhaps should have remained as ideas on paper.

Joss Whedon took risks with *Buffy the Vampire Slayer*, and even when episodes didn’t quite work, they often became entertaining in their own way. Some have become beloved cult favorites *because* of how strange they are, while others are still disliked and often skipped. Here, we’re highlighting three *Buffy* episodes that are particularly confusing, including one comedy episode that fans fiercely defend.

3) “Doublemeat Palace”

The Season 6 episode “Doublemeat Palace” is widely considered one of the most confusing installments of *Buffy the Vampire Slayer*. Buffy takes a low-paying job at the fast-food restaurant Doublemeat Palace and quickly realizes something strange is going on. The mystery centers around a secret ingredient, leading Buffy to suspect something sinister – even cannibalism. With coworkers disappearing and a strange wig maker always present, the episode attempts to explore the idea of jobs that drain your spirit, but the final explanation doesn’t quite live up to the suspense that was built.

Honestly, even as a huge *Buffy* fan, that episode always felt…off. It just wasn’t a good look for the character, stuck with that ridiculous hat and uniform doing a dead-end job. It didn’t really advance the overall story, and there wasn’t much emotional resonance – it just felt like another instance of the show trying to put Buffy down, which made that part of the season pretty depressing. What bothered me most was they had this opportunity to deal with her trauma in a thoughtful way, but instead just added another humiliating experience. Seriously, why didn’t the Watchers’ Council just *pay* her instead of forcing her into this awful fast-food job? A lot of fans have even said it would have made more sense if Xander was the one flipping burgers. Ultimately, it was a confusing, unpleasant episode that wasn’t scary, and definitely wasn’t funny.

2) “Where the Wild Things Are”

“Where the Wild Things Are” is a contender for the most strangely mixed-tone episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. The premise is bizarre: Buffy and Riley’s frequent intimacy accidentally empowers a haunted fraternity house, releasing the spirits of children burdened by shame and hidden emotions. This leads to characters experiencing unsettling erotic visions and seeing ghostly children. Even Giles gets caught up in the strangeness, offering a standout moment with a surprisingly emotional performance of “Behind Blue Eyes” that feels out of place for the episode.

Aside from its main flaws, the episode struggles with Buffy and Riley’s romance, portraying it in a flat and unengaging way. Their frequent, tame romantic scenes interrupt the flow of the central plot. Even a potentially compelling subplot involving a haunted orphanage is abandoned without resolution. While the episode seems to be striving for complexity, it ends up feeling like a simplistic moral lesson – a heavy-handed message about the dangers of sin – which doesn’t fit with the show’s usual themes. This underdeveloped concept creates an awkward combination of horror, attempts at humor, and confusing ideas.

1) “Beer Bad”

The Season 4 episode “Beer Bad” is famously illogical, but surprisingly enjoyable. In it, Buffy drinks a cursed beer and transforms into a primitive, caveman-like version of herself, complete with grunting and clubbing-even managing to save the day in this state! While the episode’s message about the dangers of drinking is rather obvious and it’s faced criticism for its approach, it’s recently been gaining renewed appreciation from both fans and critics.

This episode offers a fun, lighthearted change of pace from the season’s more serious storylines. While it doesn’t delve as deeply into character development or emotional themes as other episodes, it excels as a purely silly adventure. “Beer Bad” stands out because it fully leans into its own absurdity, keeps the story straightforward, and delivers genuinely funny moments. It’s not perfect – the rules about how people regress are a bit confusing, and there are some plot gaps. However, despite not being an instant hit with everyone, the episode has gained a dedicated fanbase, proving its enduring entertainment value. For many viewers, it’s a perfect example of *Buffy the Vampire Slayer* at its most playful and ridiculous.

https://comicbook.com/tv-shows/news/buffy-vampire-slayer-tv-episodes-underrated/embed/#

Read More

2025-09-18 04:13