5 Dark Crime Shows to Stream on Peacock Right Now

by

Lots of new and returning crime shows have come out recently, and this platform has a great selection of them. One standout from 2025 was All Her Fault, a limited series on Peacock starring Sarah Snook and Dakota Fanning. The show delivered everything viewers want in a new crime drama – a surprising plot twist and a compelling, original story.

Peacock also offers shows within popular crime subgenres, like those focusing on serial killers. Shows like The Hunting Party and Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy are particularly well-done, delivering dark, unsettling stories with compelling emotional depth. While they may not be the most famous crime shows, they’re among the best recent releases – hidden gems that any serious fan of the genre should definitely check out.

The Hunting Party Is the Best Criminal Minds Replacement

NBC’s new series centers around a dangerous breakout: a secret government prison called ‘The Pit’ is blown open, releasing a group of terrifying serial killers. A skilled team, led by ex-FBI profiler Bex, is assembled to track down and capture each murderer. As they hunt these criminals, the team also digs into the mystery surrounding the prison itself and what caused the explosion.

While critics haven’t been kind, audiences are really enjoying the crime show, leading to a second season despite modest ratings. Viewers appreciate that The Hunting Party brings a new and exciting energy to the crime TV landscape, using established crime show elements in a compelling way. Fans of shows like Criminal Minds are especially drawn to this serial killer procedural, finding it revitalizes a familiar genre.

Even though many TV shows have been cancelled recently, despite having loyal viewers, The Hunting Party is getting a second season thanks to incredibly positive viewer ratings. The show has become a surprising success for fans of procedural dramas, a genre where new shows rarely succeed unless they’re part of a big franchise. With Season 2 just beginning, the enthusiastic response suggests the show may be renewed for a third season.

Long Bright River Is a Layered Drama

Long Bright River tells the story of Mickey Fitzpatrick, a police officer investigating a series of murders in a troubled neighborhood plagued by crime and drug use. The case hits close to home for Mickey, as she has a personal connection to the area and a complicated past, including a sister battling a dangerous addiction. As the investigation unfolds, Mickey’s own history begins to come to light.

I’m really drawn to this show because it’s so cleverly simple. It doesn’t rely on crazy twists, but instead builds a really intriguing mystery. What I love most is how it mixes a classic detective vibe with a deeply personal story about family – it’s genuinely moving. And it’s not just entertainment; it also makes you think about the people around you and how easy it is to jump to conclusions. It really gets at the idea that everyone’s more complicated than they seem, and that’s powerful.

She’s known for her work in many different kinds of stories, and her role in Long Bright River brings a compelling new crime drama to a crowded television landscape. A great thing about the show, which is based on Liz Moore’s novel, is that it’s a limited series. This means viewers can enjoy a complete story without the commitment of a long-running or unfinished show.

BBC’s The Fall Is A Thrilling Cat-and-Mouse Narrative

The BBC series The Fall follows a London detective sent to Belfast, Ireland, to assist in the investigation of a chilling serial killer. The killer, Paul Specter, appears to be an ordinary family man, but he secretly targets and murders successful women. The show unfolds over three seasons, giving equal attention to both the detective’s pursuit and the killer’s disturbing actions.

Before watching The Fall, be prepared for a chilling look into the mind of a clever and manipulative serial killer. The show features both a fascinating detective and a captivating villain, making it consistently engaging. What sets The Fall apart is its unusual focus on the killer’s perspective, which adds depth to an already gripping story.

Even with so many excellent crime shows coming out in the last ten years, The Fall remains one of the best. While many shows in this genre follow a predictable pattern, The Fall is distinguished by its outstanding acting. Plus, it wrapped up after just three seasons, offering a complete and satisfying story without being cut short.

Serial Killer Dramas Are Reimagined in Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy

When a Chicago teenager named Rob Piest disappears, his family fights for answers, frustrated by the limited police investigation. As detectives begin to look into the case, they discover a disturbing pattern: several young men and boys have vanished after encountering John Wayne Gacy. A search of Gacy’s home reveals shocking and unimaginable horrors.

What sets Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy apart is its unique approach to the case. Instead of dwelling on the gruesome details of Gacy’s crimes, the series focuses on how he was caught and brought to justice. Importantly, it also highlights the lives of his victims before they were killed, ensuring the series remembers and honors them as individuals, not just as victims. Each episode is named after one of the people Gacy harmed – including a survivor – making it clear that their stories are the central focus, not Gacy’s.

Even though Devil in Disguise is ending, the show will return next season with a new story focusing on a different serial killer, suggesting it might become an anthology series with self-contained seasons. This format is great for viewers who prefer shorter shows, as the first season has a complete storyline and can be enjoyed on its own. Fans are eagerly anticipating the next season, particularly after the strong plot and acting in Season 1.

All Her Fault Is Shocking From Beginning to End

The new series on Peacock immediately captivated fans of crime dramas with its suspenseful and complex storyline. The plot centers around Milo, a young boy who vanishes after what appears to be a staged playdate, leaving his parents devastated and raising doubts about the seemingly perfect lives of his wealthy family. As Milo’s mother, Marissa, becomes increasingly frantic and bewildered, she uncovers startling secrets that shatter her reality.

The miniseries All Her Fault keeps viewers guessing about the motivations and ethics of everyone involved. Although the identity of the kidnapper is known early on, the reasons behind the crime become increasingly complex and unclear as the story unfolds. This made it the most captivating and consistently enjoyable crime show of 2025.

While some viewers disliked how All Her Fault challenged typical expectations in relationships, many found it disturbingly true to life. The story’s commentary on the impossible standards placed on people – particularly mothers – was a captivating part of the plot. Even viewers who struggled with the characters could acknowledge the story’s subtle complexities.

Read More

2026-01-17 20:37