5 DC Characters Sebastian Stan May Be Playing in The Batman Part II, Ranked by How Likely They Are

by

The wait for The Batman Part II took longer than expected, as director Matt Reeves focused on crafting a story that would live up to the first film’s success. With the script now complete and production planned, casting has begun. Recent news that Scarlett Johansson has joined the cast has generated a lot of excitement. She’ll be working alongside returning stars Robert Pattinson as Batman, Jeffrey Wright as Jim Gordon, and Andy Serkis as Alfred. Though details about the plot are being closely guarded by Reeves and DC Studios, rumors are already circulating and fans are eagerly analyzing every clue to uncover the sequel’s secrets.

Sebastian Stan, a well-known actor, has joined the cast of the upcoming Gotham City project. He’s the second star from the Marvel universe to sign on, though his character’s identity remains a secret. Considering his past roles, which often involve challenging and physically intense performances, he’s likely to play a major character in the series. Let’s look at the clues to figure out which DC character he might be portraying in this dark and realistic setting.

5) A Member of the Falcone Family

Gotham City’s criminal landscape has drastically changed since the events of the last film and the aftermath of The Penguin. With the Falcone family’s power broken, Oz Cobb—known as the Penguin—took over the city’s drug trade. However, the Penguin’s return in The Batman Part II suggests the fight for control is still ongoing. This means Batman will have to deal with new conflicts between gangs vying for power, now that Carmine and Sofia Falcone are gone.

Stan could play a relative of the Falcone family or a secret heir trying to restore the family’s reputation. While it’s not the most likely scenario – casting an actor of his fame in a small, one-time villain role would be unexpected – it’s still possible because the criminal underworld is a key part of Reeves’ vision for Gotham.

4) Jervis Tetch, aka Mad Hatter

I’m really excited about the rumors that Scarlett Johansson might be playing Lady Arkham in the next Batman movie! If that’s true, it sounds like Arkham Asylum is going to be a huge part of the story. Matt Reeves has already said the villain will be someone we’ve never seen in a live-action film before, and Lady Arkham would definitely fit that description. Plus, he clearly loves that location – he even worked on a whole TV series about Arkham! It feels like he’s building towards something big with Gotham and its history, and Arkham is central to all of it.

Exploring the depths of Arkham Asylum introduces audiences to new and frightening villains. Jervis Tetch, the Mad Hatter, is a perfect fit for the dark and psychological tone of this world. Stan possesses the acting skills to convincingly portray the Mad Hatter’s disturbing obsession and fractured mental state. Adding this character would create a terrifying new addition to The Batman‘s collection of villains, while also staying true to the series’ commitment to featuring villains who haven’t been fully explored on film.

3) Dr. Jonathan Crane, aka Scarecrow

With the next Batman film likely to feature Arkham Asylum, many fans believe Dr. Jonathan Crane, also known as the Scarecrow, could appear. While the character has been used in past Batman movies, his focus on psychological manipulation fits well with the dark, detective-focused style of director Matt Reeves’ films. The recent TV series The Penguin hinted at the Scarecrow’s existence through a character named Dr. Julian Rush, but it’s probably not him who will ultimately become Batman’s foe.

It makes sense that an actor as talented as Stan would be cast as the Scarecrow, as it suggests the threats against Batman are becoming much more serious. Stan is capable of portraying a character who is both intelligent and terrifying, someone who enjoys instilling fear while appearing calm and collected. He’s proven this ability in films like Fresh, where he successfully combined a menacing intellect with a strong physical presence, making him a perfect fit for the role.

2) Thomas Elliot, aka Hush

Matt Reeves has stated he wants to feature villains in The Batman Part II who have a strong, personal history with Bruce Wayne. This suggests Thomas Elliot, a childhood friend who later becomes the villain Hush, is a likely candidate. The first Batman film actually included a hidden nod to the name Elliot, leading fans to speculate about his eventual appearance and how he might threaten the Wayne family’s reputation.

Hush is a compelling villain because he’s an entirely new face for movie audiences. Stan is perfect for the part; he excels at portraying characters who are both deeply troubled and menacing. And, his similar appearance to Pattinson adds to the unsettling nature of a villain who wants to take over his enemy’s life.

1) Harvey Dent, aka Two-Face

Many believe Stan will play Harvey Dent, the district attorney who becomes a tragic figure. There’s also talk that Johansson might play Gilda Dent, Harvey’s wife, suggesting the Dent family will be central to the sequel’s political story. If that’s the case, whoever plays Two-Face will have to deliver a performance as memorable as Aaron Eckhart’s iconic portrayal in The Dark Knight, and that requires a truly talented actor.

Stan has a strong track record at Marvel Studios of portraying characters with complex inner struggles, which makes him well-suited to play the downfall of Gotham’s hero, Harvey Dent. The story could position Dent as an important, but not central, figure, with a new villain driving the main plot. This approach would let the film develop Dent’s story over time while still giving audiences a recognizable character to connect with.

The Batman Part II is scheduled for release on October 1, 2027.

Now that a sequel is coming, which DC character do you think Sebastian Stan will play? Share your thoughts in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

https://comicbook.com/movies/list/7-times-batman-definitely-killed-people-in-movies/embed/#

Read More

2026-01-07 21:41