5 Underrated 2000s Superhero Movies Nobody Talks About

by

Superhero movies are hugely popular now, but that wasn’t always the case. In the early 2000s, the genre was still finding its footing, and many films were released without a clear sense of what would succeed. As a result, some interesting movies flew under the radar, even though they were exploring ideas that fans would love today. Looking back, it’s clear that these films weren’t just unique – they were often ahead of their time. They really shine now, when we can see how they paved the way for the more formulaic superhero movies we see today, and appreciate their originality.

These superhero movies from the 2000s don’t get much attention, but they were actually quite innovative and stand out from what came after – even the big Marvel and DC universes eventually had to change things up! They deserve another look because they offer more than people appreciated at the time. Here are 5 seriously underrated films that often get forgotten when people talk about the best superhero movies.

5) V for Vendetta

Most people remember V for Vendetta simply because of its iconic mask, but it deserves to be discussed as more than just a superhero film. It’s primarily a smart and thought-provoking political thriller, which likely led many viewers to categorize it differently. The story centers on Evey (Natalie Portman) and her encounter with V (Hugo Weaving), a masked rebel determined to overthrow England’s oppressive government. It’s a film that prioritizes strong ideas and compelling dialogue, achieving more with these elements than many big-budget action movies do with special effects.

The movie still holds up remarkably well today. It’s unique, has a clear message, and doesn’t compromise its vision to follow trends. While many remember the famous line, “Remember, remember the fifth of November,” they often overlook that V for Vendetta offers a particularly strong portrayal of a vigilante character in film. It wasn’t simply good for when it was released – it’s genuinely a good movie, full stop. The reason it’s not discussed as often now is likely because it wasn’t marketed as a superhero film, even though it’s one of the most impactful from that period – and it’s probably not a surprise that a remake is being planned.

4) Watchmen

Okay, so Watchmen… that movie really got people talking, and honestly, it’s one I think you really get on a second viewing. When it first came out, everyone seemed to want a straightforward superhero spectacle, but Zack Snyder gave us something completely different. It’s a dense, complex story – a real epic – and it doesn’t shy away from difficult questions. It’s about these retired superheroes who end up uncovering a conspiracy that could throw the whole world into chaos. It’s definitely not a light watch, but it never tried to be, and I respect that.

Over time, it became clear that Watchmen aimed for something incredibly complex for its era, and that’s not a bad thing. It tackled difficult themes like power, trauma, failure, and ego in a way few superhero movies of the 2000s even tried. While it’s flawed and makes some questionable decisions, very few adaptations stay so committed to their original vision. That’s why Watchmen often appears on lists of underrated superhero films – many people didn’t fully appreciate its depth until years later.

3) Spider-Man 3

Many older fans still love Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man movies, but Spider-Man 3 gained a reputation as a bit of a mess and people mostly just made fun of it. Re-watching it now, though, it’s surprisingly more engaging than most remember. It does have a lot of villains and Peter Parker’s angsty phase became famous online, but the film was actually attempting something unusual for superhero movies at the time: showing a hero struggle with real moral failings. The story follows Peter (Tobey Maguire) as he battles a new suit, new enemies, and the difficulties of balancing his personal life. While the movie isn’t perfect, it’s clear it was trying to do something ambitious.

Despite its flaws, Spider-Man 3 isn’t a bad movie – it’s ambitious and genuinely tries to deliver a dramatic conclusion to the trilogy, pushing Spider-Man to his emotional limit. It was unfairly criticized upon release, but today’s audiences, accustomed to more complex superhero stories, would likely appreciate it much more. It’s a shame such a significant film became known mostly as a joke, and it deserves to be part of a more thoughtful conversation about superhero cinema.

2) Sky High

Many people vaguely remember the movie Sky High, usually only when talking about superhero films from their teenage years. That’s surprising, because it did something that wouldn’t become really popular in the genre for years: it showed superpowers as just a normal part of life, with a lot of humor and no attempt at being overly dramatic. It doesn’t take itself too seriously (but it’s also not silly), and that’s what makes it so fun to watch. The film centers on Will Stronghold (Michael Angarano), whose parents are well-known superheroes, as he starts high school – a high school specifically for students with powers. It sounds straightforward, and it is, but it’s surprisingly effective.

This movie’s strength lies in its realistic portrayal of its world. It avoids excessive spectacle or melodrama, instead focusing on the everyday struggles of teenagers navigating power dynamics, social status, and expectations – which gives it a genuine quality often missing in today’s big-budget superhero films. Sky High had all the ingredients to become a successful franchise and a strong competitor to X-Men within the teen-superhero genre. It’s a shame it faded into obscurity. However, watching it now reveals how innovative it was for its time, and it’s surprising that it’s not discussed more often.

1) Unbreakable

It’s surprising how easily Unbreakable has been overlooked – it truly deserves more recognition. It’s not just underrated; it feels like many people have completely forgotten it existed. When the film was released, audiences anticipated a typical M. Night Shyamalan thriller, but instead they got a superhero story told as a character-driven psychological drama. This unexpected approach confused many viewers, and ultimately contributed to its lack of success. The film centers on David Dunn (Bruce Willis) as he begins to realize he may have superpowers, and Elijah Price (Samuel L. Jackson) who believes he’s destined to be a hero. It’s a film focused on concepts and character development, rather than relying on typical superhero tropes like explosions or flashy costumes.

The film resonates deeply with those seeking something unique because it pioneered what we now recognize as modern superhero storytelling. Long before other films in the genre caught on, Unbreakable featured realism, nuance, subtle acting, a deliberate pace, and a focus on emotional depth. While many movies from the early 2000s were forward-thinking, this one was truly ahead of its time – audiences weren’t prepared for a superhero story that required careful attention and patience. Given the more mature superhero films we see today from the MCU and DCU, it’s clear this film was unfairly overlooked. It’s not simply underrated; it’s a crucial film in the genre.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/underrated-superhero-movies-that-should-have-started-franchises/embed/#

Read More

2025-11-24 16:13