Pirates of the Caribbean 6 Bringing Back Jack Sparrow Would Be a Mistake

by

It’s quite surprising that there are plans for a sixth installment of “Pirates of the Caribbean,” given the series’ decline in popularity. Although the initial four movies were highly successful, generating substantial revenue for Disney, and the 2017 film “Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales” earned $795 million domestically, it’s important to note that this movie had a production budget of $320 million – making it the first in the series to fall short of $180 million in North America. This suggests a decrease in interest for this franchise. With the international box office potential for American blockbusters experiencing a significant drop in the 2020s, it seems uncertain that “Pirates of the Caribbean 6” would be profitable in cinemas right away.

As a devoted movie enthusiast, I can’t help but feel a mix of anticipation and concern as the production of Pirates of the Caribbean 6 continues to progress. Notably, producer Jerry Bruckheimer has shared that Johnny Depp has shown interest in reprising his iconic role as Captain Jack Sparrow. While it’s no secret that having Depp back as Sparrow could be a significant draw for fans, I can’t help but feel it might be an artistic misstep to bring him back once more.

Jack Sparrow’s Schtick Grew Tiresome

To start with, it’s important to acknowledge that Johnny Depp has his loyal supporters; however, he’s also a figure mired in much debate due to multiple legal controversies. Leaving personal issues behind, the notion of re-casting Depp for Pirates of the Caribbean 6 is questionable from the get-go. This is because Depp no longer consistently drives box office success as he once did.

During the 2010s, Johnny Depp experienced a series of flop movies such as “Dark Shadows,” “Mortdecai,” “Transendence,” and numerous others. This marked a significant decrease in his popularity compared to his days starring in “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory.” Even when he reprised his role as Jack Sparrow in 2017 for “Dead Men Tell No Tales,” it couldn’t prevent the film from becoming the lowest-grossing sequel of the “Pirates of the Caribbean” series globally (and the lowest-earning domestic entry). From a practical standpoint, Depp’s return doesn’t seem like a guaranteed financial success. Moreover, movies like “Ballerina” and “Karate Kid: Legends,” which bombed in 2025, demonstrated that reviving old cast members to revive exhausted franchises may not generate interest from the audience.

More significantly, as the Pirates of the Caribbean series progressed, Johnny Depp’s portrayal of Jack Sparrow became increasingly tiresome. In The Curse of the Black Pearl, Depp’s Sparrow was a thrilling surprise, hiding his sharp intellect beneath a pretense of drunkenness. However, by At World’s End, four years later, Depp’s acting had devolved into an irritating imitation. By Dead Men Tell No Tales a decade later, the actor’s exaggerated performance had reached cringeworthy levels. Why would anyone want this character to return?

Jack Sparrow had already been quite bothersome during the initial runs of the saga’s regular installments. In the context of a “legacy sequel,” where Sparrow would inevitably make numerous references to past escapades, the character seemed to merely repeat himself, which was unfortunate for a character who once embodied such subversion.

Let This Franchise Grow & Evolve

Jack Sparrow’s continuous irritating role in this series might warrant a break for his character. Additionally, it’s worth noting that since At World’s End, the franchise has neglected to create compelling new characters like Will Turner or Elizabeth Swann, who could potentially replace them. The straight-laced leads portrayed by Brenton Thwaites and Sam Claflin in the more recent films of the 2010s series have not left a lasting impression on audiences.

As a dedicated film enthusiast, I can’t help but feel that the upcoming Pirates of the Caribbean sequel might be missing an opportunity for freshness if it continues to heavily feature Johnny Depp’s character. Rehashing the past, especially with the enigmatic post-credit scene hinting at the return of Davy Jones in Dead Men Tell No Tales, risks overshadowing any new talent who could potentially redefine this saga for a new era. A chance to introduce new faces as the future of the franchise should not be squandered on repeating past successes.

Some online enthusiasts reacted strongly to rumors (without solid evidence) that Ayo Edebiri might star in a new installment of “Pirates of the Caribbean”. While such a decision could indeed revitalize this long-running story, it seems questionable given Edebiri’s notable talent as seen in “The Bear”. Taking on a major PG-13 action film may not fully utilize her artistic abilities. However, having a performer of her caliber could rejuvenate “Pirates of the Caribbean” and attract younger audiences, potentially signaling that the series is venturing into unexplored creative territories.

To stay culturally relevant in the 2020s, the “Pirates of the Caribbean” films should avoid relying solely on the popular leading man from 2004, as Jack Sparrow was outdated by 2017 and has become increasingly unappealing. The public isn’t clamoring for a return to this fictional universe, but if more movies are made, they should introduce new characters and stories that resonate with contemporary audiences. Reviving Jack Sparrow may not be the best choice. Lessons can be learned from struggling Disney franchises like the Marvel Cinematic Universe, which show that relying solely on nostalgia has its limits.

The first five Pirates of the Caribbean movies are now streaming on Disney+.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/10-best-fight-scenes-pirates-of-the-caribbean-franchise/embed/#

Read More

2025-08-14 05:42